Birgalikda kasallik - Comorbidity

Yilda Dori, qo'shma kasallik ko'pincha bir yoki bir nechta qo'shimcha shartlarning mavjudligi birgalikda sodir bo'ladi (anavi, bir vaqtda yoki bir vaqtda bilan) asosiy shart bilan. Komorbidlik individual bemorning qiziqishning asosiy shartidan tashqari bo'lishi mumkin bo'lgan barcha boshqa holatlarning ta'sirini tavsiflaydi va fiziologik yoki psixologik bo'lishi mumkin. Ruhiy salomatlik nuqtai nazaridan, komorbidiya ko'pincha murojaat qiladi buzilishlar kabi bir-biri bilan ko'pincha birga yashaydigan depressiya va tashvish buzilishlar.

Birgalikda kasallik bir vaqtning o'zida mavjud bo'lgan holatni ko'rsatishi mumkin, ammo mustaqil ravishda boshqa holat yoki tegishli tibbiy holat bilan. Keyingisi sezgi atamasi ba'zi sabablarni keltirib chiqaradi ustma-ust tushish tushunchasi bilan asoratlar. Masalan, uzoq vaqtdan beri qandli diabet, qay darajada koronar arteriya kasalligi a ga qarshi mustaqil komorbiditadir diabetik asorat o'lchash oson emas, chunki ikkala kasallik ham juda o'zgaruvchan va bir vaqtning o'zida ham, natijada ham aspektlari mavjud. Xuddi shu narsa homiladorlikdagi interurrent kasalliklar. Boshqa misollarda haqiqiy mustaqillik yoki munosabat aniqlanmaydi, chunki sindromlar va uyushmalar ko'pincha ancha oldin aniqlanadi patogenetik umumiyliklar tasdiqlangan (va ba'zi bir misollarda, hatto ular mavjud bo'lmasdan) faraz qilingan ). Psixiatrik tashxislarda qisman bu "" noaniq tilni ishlatish, shunga mos ravishda noto'g'ri fikrlashga olib kelishi mumkin "deb ta'kidlangan [va], ehtimol" komorbidite "atamasini ishlatishdan saqlanish kerak."[1] Ammo ko'plab tibbiy misollarda, masalan, diabet mellitus va koronar arteriya kasalligi, tibbiyot murakkabligi tegishli ravishda tan olinishi va ko'rib chiqilishi sharti bilan, qaysi so'z ishlatilishini farq qilmaydi.

Ko'pgina testlar, ular ikkinchi darajali yoki uchinchi darajali kasalliklar bo'ladimi, qo'shni kasalliklarning "og'irligi" yoki qiymatini standartlashtirishga harakat qiladi. Har bir test har bir alohida qo'shma holatni o'limni yoki boshqa natijalarni o'lchaydigan taxminiy o'zgaruvchiga birlashtirishga harakat qiladi. Tadqiqotchilar bunday testlarni prognoz qiymatiga ko'ra tasdiqladilar, ammo hech kim hali standart sifatida tan olinmagan.

"Komorbid" atamasi uchta ta'rifga ega:

  1. bemorda boshqa holat bilan bir vaqtda, ammo mustaqil ravishda mavjud bo'lgan tibbiy holatni ko'rsatish.
  2. xuddi shu bemorda boshqa holatga olib keladigan, sabab bo'lgan yoki unga boshqa bog'liq bo'lgan bemorning tibbiy holatini ko'rsatish.[2]
  3. ularning sababiy munosabatlaridan qat'i nazar, bir vaqtning o'zida mavjud bo'lgan ikki yoki undan ortiq tibbiy holatni ko'rsatish.[3]

Charlson indeksi

Charlsonning komorbidlik indeksi[4] kabi bir qator kasalliklarga duch kelishi mumkin bo'lgan bemor uchun bir yillik o'limni taxmin qiladi yurak kasalligi, OITS, yoki saraton (jami 22 shart). Har bir shartga, har biri bilan bog'liq o'lish xavfiga qarab, 1, 2, 3 yoki 6 ball beriladi. Ballar jami o'limni taxmin qilish uchun umumiy ballni ta'minlash uchun yig'iladi. Charlson komorbidite indeksining ko'plab o'zgarishlari, jumladan Charlson / Deyo, Charlson / Romano, Charlson / Manitoba va Charlson / D'Hoores komorbidite indekslari keltirilgan.

Klinik holatlar va tegishli ballar quyidagicha:

  • Har birida 1: Miyokard infarkti, konjestif yurak etishmovchiligi, periferik qon tomir kasalligi, demans, serebrovaskulyar kasallik, surunkali o'pka kasalligi, biriktiruvchi to'qima kasalligi, oshqozon yarasi, surunkali jigar kasalligi, diabet.
  • Har biri 2: Hemipleji, buyrakning mo''tadil yoki og'ir kasalligi, yakuniy a'zolari zararlangan diabet, o'sma, leykemiya, limfoma.
  • 3 ta: O'rtacha yoki og'ir jigar kasalligi.
  • Har biri 6 tadan: xavfli o'sma, metastaz, OITS.

Shifokor uchun ushbu ball kasallikni qanchalik agressiv tarzda davolashni hal qilishda yordam beradi. Masalan, bemorda yurak xastaligi va diabet bilan birga keladigan saraton kasalligi bo'lishi mumkin. Ushbu qo'shma kasalliklar shunchalik og'ir bo'lishi mumkinki, saraton kasalligini davolash xarajatlari va xatarlari uning qisqa muddatli foydasidan ustun bo'lishi mumkin.

Bemorlar ko'pincha ularning ahvoli qanchalik og'irligini bilmasliklari sababli, hamshiralar dastlab bemorlarning jadvalini ko'rib chiqishlari va indeksni hisoblash uchun ma'lum bir holat mavjudligini aniqlashlari kerak edi. Keyingi tadqiqotlar komorbidlik indeksini bemorlar uchun so'rovnomaga moslashtirdi.

Charlson indekslari, ayniqsa Charlson / Deyo, undan keyin Elixhauzer eng ko'p qo'shma kasallik va multimorbidit o'lchovlarini taqqoslash tadqiqotlari bilan atalgan.[5]

Komorbidlik-polifarmatsiya ballari (CPS)

Komorbidlik-polifarmatsiya ballari (CPS) - bu ma'lum bo'lgan barcha qo'shma kasalliklar va barcha tegishli dorilarning yig'indisidan iborat oddiy o'lchovdir. Birgalikda kasallik va tegishli dorilar o'rtasida aniq moslik yo'q. Buning o'rniga, dori-darmonlarning soni ular bilan bog'liq bo'lgan kasalliklarning "intensivligi" ning aksi deb taxmin qilinadi. Ushbu ball travma populyatsiyasida keng miqyosda sinovdan o'tgan va tasdiqlangan bo'lib, o'lim, kasallanish, travma va kasalxonaga yotqizish bilan yaxshi bog'liqlik mavjud.[6][7][8] Qizig'i shundaki, CPS darajasining ortishi travma populyatsiyasida skorni dastlabki o'rganishda 90 kunlik hayotning sezilarli darajada pastligi bilan bog'liq edi.[6]

Elixhauzer bilan birgalikda kasallik

Elixhauser bilan kasallanish o'lchovi Kaliforniyadagi barcha federal bo'lmagan statsionar jamoat kasalxonasidan olingan shtat bo'ylab Kaliforniya shtatidagi statsionar ma'lumotlar bazasidan olingan ma'muriy ma'lumotlar yordamida ishlab chiqilgan (n = 1,779,167). Elixhauserning komorbidlik o'lchovi ICD-9-CM kodlash qo'llanmasiga tayanib, 30 ta kasallikning ro'yxatini ishlab chiqdi. Qo'shni kasalliklar indeks sifatida soddalashtirilmadi, chunki har bir komorbidiya turli bemorlar guruhlari orasida natijalarga (kasalxonada bo'lish muddati, shifoxonadagi o'zgarishlar va o'lim) turlicha ta'sir ko'rsatdi. Elixhauserning komorbidlik o'lchovi bilan aniqlangan qo'shma kasalliklar shifoxonada o'lim bilan sezilarli darajada bog'liq va o'tkir va surunkali kasalliklarni o'z ichiga oladi. van Valraven va boshq. kasallik yukini sarhisob qiladigan va kasalxonada o'lim holatini kamsitadigan Elixhauser komorbidlik indeksini ishlab chiqdi va tasdiqladi.[9] Bundan tashqari, tizimli ko'rib chiqish va qiyosiy tahlil shuni ko'rsatadiki, turli xil qo'shma kasalliklar indekslari orasida Elixhauzer indeksi, ayniqsa, kasalxonaga yotqizilgan 30 kundan keyin xavfni yaxshiroq bashorat qiladi.[5]

Tashxis bilan bog'liq guruh

Kuchliroq kasal bo'lgan bemorlar, xuddi shu sabab bilan kasalxonaga yotqizilgan bo'lishiga qaramay, unchalik og'ir bo'lmagan bemorlarga qaraganda ko'proq shifoxona resurslarini talab qiladilar. Buni tan olgan holda tashxis bilan bog'liq guruh (DRG) muayyan DRGlarni qo'l bilan ajratadi, o'ziga xos asoratlar yoki qo'shma kasalliklar (KK) uchun ikkinchi darajali tashxis mavjudligiga asoslanadi. Xuddi shu narsa Buyuk Britaniyadagi Sog'liqni saqlash resurslari guruhlariga (HRG) tegishli.

Ruhiy salomatlik

Yilda psixiatriya, psixologiya va ruhiy salomatlik bo'yicha konsultatsiya, komorbiditatsiya bir vaqtning o'zida shaxsda yuzaga keladigan bir nechta tashxis mavjudligini anglatadi. Shu bilan birga, psixiatrik tasnifda komorbidiya, albatta, bir nechta kasalliklarning mavjudligini anglatmaydi, aksincha, barcha simptomlarni hisobga olgan holda bitta tashxis qo'yishning mavjud emasligini aks ettirishi mumkin.[10] Ustida DSM I o'qi, katta depressiv buzilish juda keng tarqalgan qo'shma kasallik. Eksa II shaxsiyatning buzilishi tez-tez tanqid qilinadi, chunki ularning komorbidlik darajasi haddan tashqari yuqori, ba'zi hollarda 60% ga yaqinlashadi. Tanqidchilarning ta'kidlashicha, bu ruhiy kasallikning ushbu toifalari juda aniq ajratilgan, ular diagnostika maqsadida foydali bo'lib, davolanish va resurslarni taqsimlashga ta'sir qiladi.

"Komorbidlik" atamasi tibbiyotda Faynshteyn (1970) tomonidan "o'ziga xos qo'shimcha klinik shaxs" "indeks kasalligi" ni davolashdan oldin yoki uning paytida yuzaga kelgan, asl yoki asosiy tashxis qo'yilgan holatlarni tavsiflash uchun kiritilgan. Bu atamalar yaratilganligi sababli, meta-tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatdiki, indeks kasalligini aniqlash uchun ishlatilgan mezonlarda nuqsonlar va sub'ektiv bo'lgan va bundan tashqari, indeks kasalligini boshqalarning sababi sifatida aniqlashga urinish, o'zaro bog'liq sharoitlarni tushunish va davolash uchun samarasiz bo'lishi mumkin. Bunga javoban, "ko'p kasallik" nisbiyliksiz yoki boshqa kasallikka bog'liqlikni nazarda tutmagan holda bir vaqtda yuzaga keladigan sharoitlarni tavsiflash uchun kiritildi, shuning uchun murakkab o'zaro ta'sirlar umuman tizim tahlilida tabiiy ravishda paydo bo'ladi.[11]

Yaqinda "komorbidlik" atamasi psixiatriyada juda modaga aylangan bo'lsa-da, uning ikki yoki undan ortiq psixiatrik tashxisning mos kelishini ko'rsatish uchun ishlatilishi noto'g'ri deb aytilgan, chunki ko'p hollarda bu aniq tashxis aniq klinikalar mavjudligini aks ettiradimi yoki yo'qmi yoki bitta klinik mavjudotning bir nechta ko'rinishiga murojaat qiling. Ta'kidlanishicha, "" noaniq tilni ishlatish, shunga mos ravishda noto'g'ri fikrlashga olib kelishi mumkin ", shuning uchun" komorbidite "atamasini ishlatishdan saqlanish kerak".[12]

O'zining artifaktual xususiyati tufayli psixiatrik komorbidiya DSMni ilmiy inqirozga olib boruvchi Kuhnian anomaliyasi sifatida qaraldi[13] va ushbu masala bo'yicha keng ko'lamli tadqiq komorbidiyani zamonaviy psixiatriya uchun epistemologik muammo sifatida ko'rib chiqadi.[14]

Muddatning boshlanishi

Ko'p asrlar ilgari shifokorlar kasallik diagnostikasi va bemorni davolashda kompleks yondashuvning hayotiyligini targ'ib qilishdi, ammo zamonaviy tibbiyot, bu diagnostika usullari va terapevtik muolajalarning xilma-xilligi bilan ajralib turadi. Bu erda bir savol tug'ildi: bir vaqtning o'zida bir qator kasalliklarga chalingan bemorning ahvolini qanday to'liq baholash mumkin, qaerdan boshlash kerak va qaysi kasallik (lar) ga birlamchi va keyingi davolash kerak? Ko'p yillar davomida bu savol javobsiz qoldi, 1970 yilgacha, taniqli amerikalik shifokor epidemiolog va tadqiqotchi, A.R. Faynshteyn Klinik diagnostika usullariga va xususan, klinik epidemiologiya sohasida qo'llaniladigan usullarga katta ta'sir ko'rsatgan "komorbidlik" atamasi bilan chiqdi. Birgalikda kasallikning paydo bo'lishini Faynshteyn jismoniy revmatik isitma bilan og'rigan bemorlar misolida namoyish etdi va bir vaqtning o'zida bir nechta kasalliklarga chalingan bemorlarning eng yomon ahvolini aniqladi. O'z vaqtida kashf etilganidan so'ng, qo'shma kasallik tibbiyotning ko'plab sohalarida alohida ilmiy-tadqiqot intizomi sifatida ajralib turdi.[15]

Terminning rivojlanishi

Hozirgi vaqtda kasallikning kelishilgan terminologiyasi mavjud emas. Ba'zi mualliflar bir qator kasalliklarni va bir nechta kasalliklarning turli xil ma'nolarini ilgari surmoqdalar, birinchisini bemorda bir qator kasalliklarning borligi, bir-biri bilan tasdiqlangan patogenetik mexanizmlar orqali bog'langanligi, ikkinchisi esa, bir qator kasalliklarning mavjudligi hozirgi kungacha tasdiqlangan patogenetik mexanizmlarning birortasi bilan bir-biri bilan hech qanday aloqasi bo'lmagan bemor.[16] Boshqalar ko'p kasallanish odamdagi bir qator surunkali yoki o'tkir kasalliklar va klinik simptomlarning kombinatsiyasi ekanligini tasdiqlaydi va ularning patogenezidagi o'xshashlik yoki farqlarni ta'kidlamaydi.[17] Shu bilan birga, ushbu atamani printsipial jihatdan aniqlashtirishni HC Kraemer va M. van den Akkerlar berishdi, ular bir-biri bilan patogenetik jihatdan bog'liq bo'lgan yoki bitta bemorda birgalikda yashaydigan 2 yoki undan ortiq surunkali kasalliklar (buzilishlar) bemorida komorbidiyani aniqladilar. har bir kasallikning bemordagi faoliyati.[iqtibos kerak ]

Tadqiqot

Psixiatriya

Jismoniy va ruhiy patologiyani keng o'rganish psixiatriyada o'z o'rnini topdi. I. Jensen (1975),[18] J.H. Boyd (1984),[19] HOJATXONA. Sanderson (1990),[20] Yuriy Nuller (1993),[21] D.L. Robins (1994),[22] A. B. Smulevich (1997),[23] Klonlovchi (2002)[24] va boshqa taniqli psixiatrlar ko'p yillar davomida turli xil psixiatrik kasalliklarga chalingan bemorlarda bir qator kasalliklarni aniqlashga bag'ishladilar. Aynan shu tadqiqotchilar komorbiditening birinchi modellarini ishlab chiqdilar. Ba'zi modellar komorbiditni odamda (bemorda) hayotning ma'lum bir davrida bir nechta buzilishlar (kasalliklar) mavjudligini, boshqalari esa bitta kasallikka chalingan odam uchun boshqa kasalliklarni ko'tarish uchun nisbiy xavfni ishlab chiqdilar. .[iqtibos kerak ]

Umumiy tibbiyot

Birgalikda kasallikning birlamchi (asosiy) jismoniy buzilishning klinik rivojlanishiga, davolovchi terapiya samaradorligiga va bemorlarning tez va uzoq muddatli prognoziga ta'siri butun dunyoning ko'plab mamlakatlaridagi iste'dodli shifokorlar va turli tibbiyot sohalari olimlari tomonidan o'rganilgan. Ushbu olimlar va shifokorlarga quyidagilar kiradi: M. H. Kaplan (1974),[25] T. Pincus (1986),[26] M. E. Charlson (1987),[27] F. G. Schellevis (1993),[28] H. C. Kraemer (1995),[29] M. van den Akker (1996),[30] A. Grimbi (1997),[31] S. Grinfild (1999),[32] M. Fortin (2004) va A. Vanasse (2004),[33] C. Xudon (2005),[34] L. B. Lazebnik (2005),[35] A. L. Vertkin (2008),[36] G. E. Caughey (2008),[37] F. I. Belyalov (2009),[38] L. A. Luchixin (2010)[39] va boshqalar.

Sinonimlar

  • Polimorbidit
  • Ko'p kasallik
  • Multifaktorial kasalliklar
  • Polipatiya
  • Ikki tomonlama tashxis, ruhiy salomatlik muammolari uchun ishlatiladi
  • Pluralpatologiya

Epidemiologiya

Ko'p tarmoqli kasalxonalarga yotqizilgan bemorlar orasida komorbidlik keng tarqalgan. Dastlabki tibbiy yordam bosqichida bir vaqtning o'zida bir nechta kasalliklarga chalingan bemorlar istisno emas, balki odatiy holdir. Tomonidan e'lon qilingan surunkali kasalliklarning oldini olish va davolash Jahon Sog'liqni saqlash tashkiloti, 20-asrning ikkinchi o'n yilligi uchun ustuvor loyiha sifatida global aholi sifatini yaxshilashga qaratilgan.[40][41][42][43][44] Bu jiddiy statistik ma'lumotlar yordamida amalga oshirilgan turli tibbiyot sohalaridagi keng ko'lamli epidemiologik tadqiqotlarning umumiy tendentsiyasining sababi. O'tkazilgan, randomizatsiyalangan, klinik tadqiqotlarning aksariyat qismida mualliflar yagona tozalangan patologiyasi bo'lgan bemorlarni o'rganib, komorbidiyani eksklyuziv mezonga aylantiradi. Shu sababli, ularning kombinatsiyasini yoki boshqa ayrim buzilishlarni baholashga yo'naltirilgan tadqiqotlarni birdamlikni yagona tadqiqotiga oid ishlarga bog'lash qiyin. Komorbiditni baholashda yagona ilmiy yondashuvning yo'qligi klinik amaliyotda kamchiliklarni keltirib chiqaradi. Kasallikning taksonomiyasida (sistematikasida) komorbidiya yo'qligini sezmaslik qiyin ICD-10.[iqtibos kerak ]

Klinik-patologik taqqoslashlar

Komorbiditening tarqalishini va uning tuzilishi ta'sirini o'rganishga qaratilgan tibbiy hujjatlarning barcha fundamental tadqiqotlari 1990 yillarga qadar o'tkazilgan. Birgalikda kasallik masalasida ish olib boruvchi tadqiqotchilar va olimlar foydalangan ma'lumot manbalari voqealar tarixi,[45][46] bemorlarning kasalxonadagi yozuvlari[47] oilaviy shifokorlar, sug'urta kompaniyalari tomonidan saqlanadigan va boshqa tibbiy hujjatlar[48] va hatto eski uylardagi bemorlarning arxivlarida.[49]

Ro'yxatda keltirilgan tibbiy ma'lumotlarni olish usullari asosan klinik, tibbiy va laboratoriya tomonidan tasdiqlangan tashxisni o'tkazadigan shifokorlarning klinik tajribasi va malakasiga asoslanadi. Shuning uchun ularning vakolatlariga qaramay, ular juda sub'ektivdir. Birgalikda olib borilgan tadqiqotlarning birortasi uchun vafot etgan bemorlarning o'limidan keyingi natijalarini tahlillari o'tkazilmagan.

"Shifokorning vazifasi - ular davolaydigan bemorlarning otopsiyasini o'tkazish", dedi bir paytlar professor M. Y. Mudrov. Otopsi har bir bemorning yoshi, jinsi va jinsiga xos xususiyatlaridan qat'iy nazar komorbiditning tuzilishini va o'limining bevosita sababini aniq aniqlashga imkon beradi. Ushbu bo'limlarga asoslangan qo'shma patologiyaning statistik ma'lumotlari asosan sub'ektivizmdan mahrum.

Tadqiqot

Avstraliyada keng tarqalgan 6 ta surunkali kasallikka chalingan bemorlarni o'rganish bo'yicha o'n yillik tadqiqot natijalari shuni ko'rsatdiki, artrit bilan og'rigan keksa bemorlarning qariyb yarmi gipertenziya, 20% yurak kasalliklari va 14% 2-toifa diabetga chalingan. Astmatik bemorlarning 60% dan ortig'i bir vaqtning o'zida artritdan, 20% yurak muammolaridan va 16% 2-toifa diabetga shikoyat qildilar.[50]

Surunkali buyrak kasalligi (buyrak etishmovchiligi) bo'lgan bemorlarda koroner yurak kasalligi chastotasi buyrak funktsiyasi buzilmagan bemorlarga nisbatan 22%, yangi koronar hodisalar esa 3,4 baravar ko'pdir. Buyrak o'rnini bosuvchi terapiyani talab qiladigan buyrak kasalligining so'nggi bosqichida KKD rivojlanishi koronar yurak kasalligi tarqalishining ko'payishi va yurak to'xtab qolishidan to'satdan o'lim bilan birga keladi.[51]

Kanadalik 483 nafar semirib ketgan bemorlar ustida olib borilgan tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatdiki, semirish bilan bog'liq kasalliklarning tarqalishi ayollarda erkaklarnikiga qaraganda yuqori. Tadqiqotchilar semirish bilan kasallangan bemorlarning qariyb 75 foizida asosan dislipidemiya, gipertoniya va diabetning ikkinchi turini o'z ichiga olgan kasalliklar mavjudligini aniqladilar. Semirib ketgan yosh bemorlar orasida (18 dan 29 gacha) 22% erkak va 43% ayollarda ikkitadan ortiq surunkali kasalliklar aniqlangan.[52]

Fibromiyalgiya - bu boshqa bir qator kasalliklarga chalingan kasallik, shu jumladan, lekin ular bilan chegaralanmaydi; depressiya, tashvish, bosh og'rig'i, asabiy ichak sindromi, surunkali charchoq sindromi, tizimli eritematoz qizilo'ngach, revmatik artrit,[53] O'chokli va vahima buzilishi.[54]

Qarish bilan birga keladigan kasalliklar soni ko'paymoqda. Qo'shni kasallik 19 yoshgacha 10 foizga, 80 yosh va undan katta yoshdagi odamlarda 80 foizgacha oshadi.[55] M. Fortinning ma'lumotlariga ko'ra, oilaviy shifokorning kundalik amaliyotidan olingan 980 ta kasallik tarixini tahlil qilish asosida, komorbidiya tarqalishi yosh bemorlarda 69% dan, o'rta yoshdagi odamlar orasida 93% gacha va 98 gacha katta yoshdagi guruhlarning% bemorlari. Shu bilan birga, surunkali kasalliklar soni yosh bemorlarda 2,8, katta yoshdagi bemorlarda esa 6,4 dan farq qiladi.[56]

Rossiya ma'lumotlariga ko'ra, surunkali kasalliklarni davolash uchun (o'rtacha yoshi 67,8 ± 11,6 yosh) ko'p tarmoqli kasalxonalarga yotqizilgan jismoniy patologiyalar bilan kasallangan bemorlarning o'limdan keyingi uch mingdan ortiq hisobotlarini (n = 3239) o'rganish asosida 94,2 foizni tashkil etadi. Shifokorlar asosan ikkitadan uchta kasallikning kombinatsiyasiga duch kelishadi, ammo kamdan-kam hollarda (2,7% gacha) bitta bemor bir vaqtning o'zida 6-8 kasallikning kombinatsiyasini o'tkazgan.[57]

Buyuk Britaniyada o'tkazilgan idiopatik trombotsitopenik purpura (Verlhof kasalligi) bilan kasallangan 883 bemorga o'tkazilgan o'n to'rt yillik tadqiqotlar ushbu kasallikning turli xil jismoniy patologiyalar bilan bog'liqligini ko'rsatmoqda. Ushbu bemorlarning qo'shma tuzilishida ko'pincha malign neoplazmalar, lokomotoriya kasalliklari, teri va genitoüriner tizim kasalliklari, shuningdek gemorragik asoratlar va boshqa otoimmün kasalliklar mavjud bo'lib, ularning rivojlanish xavfi birlamchi kasallikning birinchi besh yilligida oshib boradi. chegara 5%.[58]

196 gırtlak saratoni bilan kasallangan bemorlarda o'tkazilgan tadqiqotda saratonning turli bosqichlarida bemorlarning omon qolish darajasi komorbidit mavjudligiga yoki yo'qligiga qarab farq qilishi aniqlandi. Saratonning birinchi bosqichida komorbidiya mavjudligida yashash darajasi 17% ni tashkil qiladi va u yo'q bo'lganda u 83% ni tashkil qiladi, saratonning ikkinchi bosqichida omon qolish darajasi 14% va 76%, uchinchi bosqichda esa 28 % va 66% va saratonning to'rtinchi bosqichida u mos ravishda 0% va 50% ni tashkil qiladi. Umuman olganda, tomoq saratoni bilan og'rigan bemorlarning omon qolish darajasi qo'shma kasalliksiz bemorlarning yashash darajasidan 59% pastdir.[59]

Terapevtlar va umumiy shifokorlar bundan mustasno, komorbidlik muammosi ko'pincha mutaxassislarga duch keladi. Afsuski, ular kamdan-kam hollarda bitta bemorda bir qator kasalliklarning birgalikda yashashiga e'tibor berishadi va asosan ularning ixtisoslashgan kasalliklariga xos davolanishni amalga oshiradilar. Amaliyotda urologlar, ginekologlar, KBB bo'yicha mutaxassislar, ko'z mutaxassislari, jarrohlar va boshqa mutaxassislar ko'pincha "o'z" ixtisoslashuv sohasi bilan bog'liq kasalliklarni eslatib, boshqa mutaxassislarning "nazorati ostida" boshqa hamrohlik qiladigan patologiyalarni kashf qilishadi. Har qanday ixtisoslashtirilgan bo'lim uchun bemorni simptomatik tahlilini o'tkazishga majbur deb hisoblaydigan terapevtning konsultatsiyasini o'tkazish, shuningdek diagnostika va terapevtik kontseptsiyani shakllantirish, bu mumkin bo'lgan xavflarni hisobga olgan holda aytilmagan qoidaga aylandi. bemor va uning uzoq muddatli prognozi.[iqtibos kerak ]

Mavjud klinik va ilmiy ma'lumotlarga asoslanib xulosa qilish mumkinki, komorbidiya bir qator shubhasiz xususiyatlarga ega, ular uni heterojen va tez-tez uchrab turadigan hodisa sifatida tavsiflaydi, bu holatning og'irligini kuchaytiradi va bemorning istiqbollarini yomonlashtiradi. Birgalikda kasallikning heterojen xarakteri, uni keltirib chiqaradigan sabablarning keng doirasi bilan bog'liq.[60][61]

Sabablari

  • Kasal organlarning anatomik yaqinligi
  • Bir qator kasalliklarning singular patogenetik mexanizmi
  • Kasalliklar o'rtasidagi yakuniy sabab-ta'sir munosabati
  • Bir kasallik boshqasining asoratlari natijasida kelib chiqadi
  • Pleiotropiya[62]

Birgalikda kasallikning rivojlanishiga sabab bo'lgan omillar surunkali infektsiyalar, yallig'lanishlar, involyatsion va sistematik metabolik o'zgarishlar, yatrogenez, ijtimoiy holat, ekologiya va genetik ta'sirchanlik bo'lishi mumkin.

Turlari

  • Trans-sindromal komorbidlik: bitta bemorda, ikki va / yoki undan ortiq sindrom bilan birgalikda yashash, patogenetik jihatdan bir-biri bilan bog'liq.
  • Trans-nozologik komorbidlik: bitta bemorda, ikki va / yoki undan ortiq kishining birgalikda yashashi sindromlar, patogenetik jihatdan bir-biriga bog'liq emas.

Sindromal va nozologik printsiplar bo'yicha komorbiditni ajratish asosan oldindan va noaniqdir, ammo bu bizga kasallikning singular sabab yoki umumiy patogenez mexanizmlari bilan bog'liq bo'lishi mumkinligini tushunishga imkon beradi, bu ba'zan ularning klinik jihatlaridagi o'xshashlikni tushuntiradi, bu nozologiyalarni farqlashni qiyinlashtiradi.

  • Etiologik komorbidlik:[63] Bu singular patologik agent tomonidan kelib chiqadigan turli organlar va tizimlarning bir vaqtning o'zida shikastlanishidan kelib chiqadi (masalan, surunkali alkogol mastligidan aziyat chekadigan bemorlarda alkogolizm; chekish bilan bog'liq patologiyalar; kollagenozlar tufayli tizimli zarar).
  • Murakkab komorbidite: bu birlamchi kasallikning natijasidir va ko'pincha keyinchalik uning beqarorlashuvi maqsadli lezyonlar ko'rinishida paydo bo'ladi (masalan, surunkali) nefratoniya diabetning 2-turi bilan og'rigan bemorlarda diabetik nefropatiya (Kimmelstiel-Uilson kasalligi) natijasida; miyaning rivojlanishi infarkt tufayli yuzaga keladigan asoratlardan kelib chiqadi gipertonik gipertenziya bilan og'rigan bemorlarda inqiroz).
  • Yatrogenik komorbidlik: Bu shifokorning bemorga zaruriy salbiy ta'siri natijasida paydo bo'ladi, oldindan u yoki bu tibbiy muolajalar (masalan, glyukokortikosteroid) xavfi aniqlanadi. osteoporoz tizimli gormonal vositalar (preparatlar) yordamida uzoq vaqt davomida davolangan bemorlarda; giyohvand moddalar bilan bog'liq gepatit silga qarshi kimyoviy terapiya natijasida, sil testlarining konversiyasi tufayli buyuriladi).
  • Belirtilmemiş (NOS) komorbidite: Ushbu turdagi kasalliklarning rivojlanishining singular patogenetik mexanizmlari mavjudligini taxmin qiladi, bu kombinatsiyani o'z ichiga oladi, ammo tadqiqotchi yoki shifokorning gipotezasini isbotlaydigan bir qator testlarni talab qiladi (masalan, erektil disfunktsiya umumiy ateroskleroz (ASVD); "qon tomir" bemorlarda yuqori oshqozon-ichak traktining shilliq qavatida eroziv-ülseratif lezyonlarning paydo bo'lishi).
  • "O'zboshimchalik bilan" komorbidlik: kasalliklar kombinatsiyasining dastlabki alogizmi isbotlanmagan, ammo tez orada klinik va ilmiy nuqtai nazardan (masalan, yurak tomirlari kasalligi (CHD) va xoledoxolitiyaz kombinatsiyasi; orttirilgan yurak qopqoq kasalligi va toshbaqa kasalligi).

Tuzilishi

Birgalikda kasallangan bemorlar uchun klinik tashxisni shakllantirish bo'yicha bir qator qoidalar mavjud, ularni amaliyotchi bajarishi kerak. Asosiy tamoyil diagnostikada birlamchi va fon kasalliklarini, shuningdek ularning asoratlari va unga hamroh bo'lgan patologiyalarni ajratib ko'rsatishdir.[64][65]

  • Birlamchi kasallik: Bu nozologik shakl bo'lib, uning o'zi yoki asoratlar natijasida bemorning hayotiga tahdid va nogironlik xavfi tufayli o'sha paytda davolanish zarurligini talab qiladi. Birlamchi kasallik - bu tibbiy yordamga yoki bemorning o'limiga sabab bo'lgan kasallikka aylanadi. Agar bemorda bir nechta asosiy kasalliklar mavjud bo'lsa, avvalambor birlashtirilgan asosiy kasalliklarni (raqib yoki qo'shma) tushunish muhimdir.
  • Raqobat kasalliklari: Bular etiologiya va patogenezga bog'liq bo'lgan, ammo birlamchi kasallikning mezonini teng ravishda taqsimlaydigan (masalan, transmural miokard infarkti va o'pka arteriyasining massiv tromboembolizmi, pastki oyoq-qo'llarning flebemfraksiyasi) bemorda bir-biriga mos keladigan nozologik shakllardir. Amaliyotchi patologning raqibi bitta yoki bitta bemorda namoyon bo'ladigan ikki yoki undan ortiq kasallikdir, ularning har biri o'z-o'zidan yoki uning asoratlari tufayli bemorning o'limiga olib kelishi mumkin.
  • Polipatiya: Turli xil etiologiya va patogenezga ega kasalliklar, ularning har biri alohida o'limga olib kelishi mumkin emas edi, lekin rivojlanish paytida bir-biriga to'g'ri keladi va bir-birini kuchaytiradi, ular bemorning o'limiga sabab bo'ladi (masalan, femurning jarrohlik bo'ynining osteoporotik sinishi va gipostatik pnevmoniya ).
  • Fon kasalligi: bu birlamchi kasallik paydo bo'lishida yoki uning yomon rivojlanishida uning xavfini oshiradi va asoratlarni rivojlanishiga yordam beradi. Ushbu kasallik va birlamchi kasallik darhol davolanishni talab qiladi (masalan, 2-toifa diabet).
  • Murakkabliklar: Birlamchi kasallik bilan patogenetik aloqaga ega bo'lgan, buzilishning salbiy rivojlanishini qo'llab-quvvatlovchi, bemorning ahvolini keskin yomonlashishiga olib keladigan nozologiyalar (murakkab komorbiditning bir qismi). Bir qator holatlarda birlamchi kasallikning asoratlari va unga bog'liq etiologik va patogenetik omillar konjuge kasallik sifatida ko'rsatiladi. Bunday holda ular birgalikda kasallikning sababi sifatida aniqlanishi kerak. Murakkabliklar prognostik yoki o'chirib qo'yadigan ahamiyatga ega bo'lgan kamayish tartibida keltirilgan.
  • Birlashtiruvchi kasalliklar: etiologik va patogenetik jihatdan birlamchi kasallik bilan bog'lanmagan nozologik birliklar (ahamiyati bo'yicha berilgan).

Tashxis

Birgalikda kasallikning ahamiyatiga shubha yo'q, ammo u ma'lum bir bemorda qanday baholanadi (o'lchanadi)?

Klinik misol

Bemor S., 73 yoshda, ko'krak qafasidagi to'satdan bosib turgan og'riq tufayli tez yordam chaqirdi. Kasallik tarixidan ma'lum bo'lishicha, bemor ko'p yillar davomida CHD bilan og'rigan. Bunday ko'krak qafasi og'rig'ini u ilgari ham boshdan kechirgan, ammo ular bir necha daqiqadan so'ng organik nitratlarni til ostiga kiritishdan keyin yo'qolgan. Bu safar uchta tabletka nitrogliserin ichish og'riqni o'ldirmadi. Bundan tashqari, kasallik tarixidan ma'lum bo'lganidek, bemor so'nggi o'n yil ichida miyokard infarktidan ikki marta, shuningdek, 15 yildan ko'proq vaqt oldin sinistral gemipleji bilan kechadigan o'tkir qon tomir kasalligidan. Bundan tashqari, bemor gipertoniya kasalligiga chalinadi, diabetik nefropatiya, histeromiyoma, xolelitiyoz, osteoporoz va varikozli pediatrik venalar bilan kasallangan 2-toifa diabet. Bundan tashqari, bemor muntazam ravishda bir qator antihipertenziv dorilarni, siydik chiqarish vositalarini va antihiperglikemik vositalarni, shuningdek statinlarni, antitrombotsitlarni va nootropiklarni qabul qilishini bildi. Ilgari, bemor 20 yildan ko'proq vaqt oldin xolelitiyaz tufayli xoletsistektomiya qilingan, shuningdek, 4 yil oldin o'ng ko'z kataraktasi tufayli kristalli shish paydo bo'lgan. Bemor yurakning intensiv terapiya bo'limiga umumiy transmural miokard infarkti tashxisi qo'yilgan umumiy kasalxonaga yotqizilgan. Tekshiruv davomida mo''tadil azotemiya, engil eritronormoblastik anemiya, proteinuriya va chap qon tomirlari chiqarish fraktsiyasining pasayishi aniqlandi.

Baholash usullari

Hozirgi vaqtda qo'shma kasallikni baholash (o'lchash) bo'yicha bir necha umumiy qabul qilingan usullar mavjud:[66]

  1. Kümülatif kasalliklar reytingi (CIRS): 1968 yilda B. S. Linn tomonidan ishlab chiqilgan bo'lib, u inqilobiy kashfiyotga aylandi, chunki bu amaliyotchi shifokorlarga o'z bemorlarining qo'shma kasalligi tarkibidagi surunkali kasalliklarning sonini va og'irligini hisoblash imkoniyatini berdi. CIRSdan to'g'ri foydalanish biologik tizimlarning har birini alohida kümülatif baholashni anglatadi: "0" tanlangan tizim buzilishlar yo'qligiga mos keladi, "1": engil (engil) anormalliklar yoki ilgari buzilgan kasalliklar, "2": kasallik tibbiy terapiya retsepti, "3": nogironlikni keltirib chiqaradigan kasallik va "4": shoshilinch terapiyani talab qiladigan o'tkir organ etishmovchiligi. CIRS tizimi komulyativ balni 0 dan 56 gacha bo'lishi mumkin bo'lgan komorbidlikni baholaydi. Uning ishlab chiquvchilariga ko'ra maksimal ball bemorning hayotiga mos kelmaydi.[67]
  2. Geriatriya (CIRS-G) uchun kümülatif kasalliklarni baholash shkalasi: Ushbu tizim CIRSga o'xshaydi, ammo keksa yoshdagi bemorlar uchun 1991 yilda M. D. Miller tomonidan taklif qilingan. Ushbu tizim bemorning yoshini va keksa yoshdagi kasalliklarning o'ziga xos xususiyatlarini hisobga oladi.[68][69]
  3. Kaplan-Faynshteyn indeksi: Ushbu indeks 1973 yilda 5 yil davomida 2-toifa diabet bilan og'rigan bemorlarga bog'liq bo'lgan kasalliklarning ta'sirini o'rganish asosida tuzilgan. Komorbiditni baholash tizimida mavjud bo'lgan (bemorda) barcha kasalliklar va ularning asoratlari, ularning tana a'zolariga zararli ta'siri darajasiga qarab, engil, o'rtacha va og'ir deb tasniflanadi. Bu holda kümülatif komorbidit haqida xulosa eng dekompensatsiyalangan biologik tizim asosida olinadi. Ushbu indeks har bir biologik tizimning holatini baholashda CUMSga qaraganda kümülatif, ammo unchalik batafsil bo'lmagan ma'lumot beradi: "0": Kasallikning yo'qligi, "1": Kasallikning engil kechishi, "2": O'rtacha kasallik, " 3 ": og'ir kasallik. Kaplan-Faynshteyn indeksi komorbidlikni 0 dan 36 gacha o'zgarishi mumkin bo'lgan komulyativ ballar bo'yicha baholaydi. Bundan tashqari, bu kasallikni baholash uslubining sezilarli darajada etishmasligi kasalliklarning (nozologiyalarning) haddan tashqari umumlashishi va ko'plab kasalliklarning yo'qligi hisoblanadi. bu usulning ob'ektivligi va mahsuldorligini pasaytiradigan (kamaytiradigan) "turli xil" ustunda, ehtimol, qayd etilishi kerak bo'lgan o'lchov. Ammo Kaplan-Faynshteyn indeksining CIRS bilan taqqoslanmas ustunligi malign neoplazmalar va ularning zo'ravonliklarini mustaqil tahlil qilish qobiliyatida.[70] Ushbu usuldan foydalangan holda 73 yoshli S kasal bemorni komorbiditani o'rtacha zo'ravonlik darajasida baholash mumkin (36 balldan 16tasi), ammo prognostik qiymati aniq emas, chunki umumiy balning talqini yo'q, natijada to'planish natijasida bemorning kasalliklari.
  4. Charlson indeksi: Ushbu indeks qo'shma kasalliklarga chalingan bemorlarning uzoq muddatli prognozi uchun mo'ljallangan va 1987 yilda ME Charlson tomonidan ishlab chiqilgan. Ushbu indeks o'ziga xos kasalliklar bilan bog'liq bo'lgan ballarni aniqlash tizimiga asoslangan (0 dan 40 gacha). o'limga olib keladigan prognoz uchun. Uni hisoblash uchun bog'liq kasalliklar bo'yicha ballar yig'iladi, shuningdek qirq yoshdan yuqori bo'lgan bemorlar uchun har 10 yosh uchun bitta ball qo'shiladi (50 yoshda 1 ball, 60 yoshda 2 ball va boshqalar). Charlson indeksining ajralib turadigan xususiyati va shubhasiz afzalligi shundaki, bemorning yoshini baholash va bemorning o'lim darajasini aniqlash imkoniyati mavjud bo'lib, u komorbidiya bo'lmagan taqdirda 12% ni tashkil etadi, 1-2 punktda u 26% ni tashkil qiladi; 3-4 ballda u 52% ni tashkil qiladi va 5 balldan ko'proq to'planganda u 85% ni tashkil qiladi. Regretfully this method has some deficiencies: Evaluating comorbidity severity of many diseases is not considered, as well as the absence of many important for prognosis disorders. Apart from that it is doubtful that possible prognosis for a patient suffering from bronchial asthma and chronic leukemia is comparable to the prognosis for the patient ailing from myocardial infarction and cerebral infarction.[4] In this case comorbidity of patient S, 73 years of age according to this method, is equivalent to mild state (9 out of 40 points).
  5. Modified Charlson Index: R. A. Deyo, D. C. Cherkin, and Marcia Ciol added chronic forms of ischemic cardiac disorder and the stages of chronic cardiac insufficiency to this index in 1992.[71]
  6. Elixhauser Index: The Elixhauser comorbidity measure include 30 comorbidities, which are not simplified as an index. Elixhauser shows a better predictive performance for mortality risk especially beyond 30 days of hospitalization.[5]
  7. Index of Co-Existent Disease (ICED): This Index was first developed in 1993 by S. Greenfield to evaluate comorbidity in patients with malignant neoplasms, later it also became useful for other categories of patients. This method helps in calculating the duration of a patient's stay at a hospital and the risks of repeated admittance of the same at a hospital after going through surgical procedures. For the evaluation of comorbidity the ICED index suggests to evaluate the patient's condition separately as per two different components: Physiological functional characteristics. The first component comprises 19 associated disorders, each of which is assessed on a 4-point scale, where "0" indicates the absence of disease and "3" indicates the disease's severe form. The second component evaluates the effect of associated diseases on the physical condition of the patient. It assesses 11 physical functions using a 3-point scale, where "0" means normal functionality and "2" means the impossibility of functionality.
  8. Geriatric Index of Comorbidity (GIC): Developed in 2002[72]
  9. Functional Comorbidity Index (FCI): Developed in 2005.[73]
  10. Total Illness Burden Index (TIBI): Developed in 2007.[74]

Analyzing the comorbid state of patient S, 73 years of age, using the most used international comorbidity assessment scales, a doctor would come across totally different evaluation. The uncertainty of these results would somewhat complicate the doctors judgment about the factual level of severity of the patient's condition and would complicate the process of prescribing rational medicinal therapy for the identified disorders. Such problems are faced by doctors on everyday basis, despite all their knowledge about medical science. The main hurdle in the way of inducting comorbidity evaluation systems in broad based diagnostic-therapeutic process is their inconsistency and narrow focus. Despite the variety of methods of evaluation of comorbidity, the absence of a singular generally accepted method, devoid of the deficiencies of the available methods of its evaluation, causes disturbance. The absence of a unified instrument, developed on the basis of colossal international experience, as well as the methodology of its use does not allow comorbidity to become doctor "friendly". At the same time due to the inconsistency in approach to the analysis of comorbid state and absence of components of comorbidity in medical university courses, the practitioner is unclear about its prognostic effect, which makes the generally available systems of associated pathology evaluation unreasoned and therefore un-needed as well.

Treatment of comorbid patient

The effect of comorbid pathologies on clinical implications, diagnosis, prognosis and therapy of many diseases is polyhedral and patient-specific. The interrelation of the disease, age and drug pathomorphism greatly affect the clinical presentation and progress of the primary nosology, character and severity of the complications, worsens the patient's life quality and limit or make difficult the remedial-diagnostic process. Comorbidity affects life prognosis and increases the chances of fatality. The presence of comorbid disorders increases bed days, disability, hinders rehabilitation, increases the number of complications after surgical procedures, and increases the chances of decline in aged people.[75]

The presence of comorbidity must be taken into account when selecting the algorithm of diagnosis and treatment plans for any given disease. It is important to enquire comorbid patients about the level of functional disorders and anatomic status of all the identified nosological forms (diseases). Whenever a new, as well as mildly notable symptom appears, it is necessary to conduct a deep examination to uncover its causes. It is also necessary to be remembered that comorbidity leads to polypragmasy (polypharmacy), i.e. simultaneous prescription of a large number of medicines, which renders impossible the control over the effectiveness of the therapy, increases monetary expenses and therefore reduces compliance. At the same time, polypragmasy, especially in aged patients, renders possible the sudden development of local and systematic, unwanted medicinal side-effects. These side-effects are not always considered by the doctors, because they are considered as the appearance of comorbidity and as a result become the reason for the prescription of even more drugs, sealing-in the vicious circle. Simultaneous treatment of multiple disorders requires strict consideration of compatibility of drugs and detailed adherence of rules of rational drug therapy, based on E. M. Tareev's principles, which state: "Each non-indicated drug is contraindicated"[Ushbu iqtibosga iqtibos kerak ] and B. E. Votchal said: "If the drug does not have any side-effects, one must think if there is any effect at all".[Ushbu iqtibosga iqtibos kerak ]

A study of inpatient hospital data in the United States in 2011 showed that the presence of a major complication or comorbidity was associated with a great risk of intensive-care unit utilization, ranging from a negligible change for acute myocardial infarction with major complication or comorbidity to nearly nine times more likely for a major joint replacement with major complication or comorbidity.[76]

Shuningdek qarang

Adabiyotlar

  1. ^ Maj, M (2005), "'Psychiatric comorbidity': an artefact of current diagnostic systems?", Br J Psychiatry, 186 (3): 182–84, doi:10.1192/bjp.186.3.182, PMID  15738496.
  2. ^ Valderas, Jose M.; Starfield, Barbara; Sibbald, Bonnie; Salisbury, Chris; Roland, Martin (2009). "Defining Comorbidity: Implications for Understanding Health and Health Services". Oilaviy tibbiyot yilnomalari. 7 (4): 357–63. doi:10.1370/afm.983. PMC  2713155. PMID  19597174.
  3. ^ Jakovljević M, Ostojić L (June 2013). "Comorbidity and multimorbidity in medicine today: challenges and opportunities for bringing separated branches of medicine closer to each other". Psychiatr Danub. 25 Suppl 1 (25 Suppl 1): 18–28. PMID  23806971.
  4. ^ a b Charlson, Mary E.; Pompei, Peter; Ales, Kathy L.; MacKenzie, C. Ronald (1987). "A new method of classifying prognostic comorbidity in longitudinal studies: Development and validation". Journal of Chronic Diseases. 40 (5): 373–83. doi:10.1016/0021-9681(87)90171-8. PMID  3558716.
  5. ^ a b v Sharabiani, Mansour; Aylin, Paul; Bottle, Alex (December 2012). "Systematic review of comorbidity indices for administrative data". Medical Care. 50 (12): 1109–18. doi:10.1097/MLR.0b013e31825f64d0. PMID  22929993.
  6. ^ a b Evans, DC; Cook, CH; Christy, JM (August 2012). "Comorbidity–polypharmacy scoring facilitates outcome prediction in older trauma patients". J Am Geriatr Soc. 60 (8): 1465–70. doi:10.1111/j.1532-5415.2012.04075.x. PMID  22788674.
  7. ^ Justiniano, CF; Coffey, RA; Evans, DC (Jan 2015). "Comorbidity–polypharmacy score predicts in-hospital complications and the need for discharge to extended care facility in older burn patients". J kuyish uchun parvarishlash joyi. 36 (1): 193–96. doi:10.1097/bcr.0000000000000094. PMID  25559732.
  8. ^ Justiniano, CF; Evans, DC; Cook, CH (May 2013). "Comorbidity–polypharmacy score: a novel adjunct in post-emergency department trauma triage". J Surg Res. 181 (1): 16–19. doi:10.1016/j.jss.2012.05.042. PMC  3717608. PMID  22683074.
  9. ^ Van Walraven, Carl; Austin, Peter C.; Jennings, Alison; Quan, Hude; Forster, Alan J. (2009). "A Modification of the Elixhauser Comorbidity Measures into a Point System for Hospital Death Using Administrative Data". Medical Care. 47 (6): 626–33. doi:10.1097/MLR.0b013e31819432e5. PMID  19433995. S2CID  35832401.
  10. ^ First, Michael B. (2005). "Mutually Exclusive versus Co-Occurring Diagnostic Categories: The Challenge of Diagnostic Comorbidity". Psixopatologiya. 38 (4): 206–10. doi:10.1159/000086093. PMID  16145276.
  11. ^ Rhee, Soo Hyun; Hewitt, John K.; Lessem, Jeffrey M.; Stallings, Michael C.; Corley, Robin P.; Neale, Michael C. (May 2004). "The Validity of the Neale and Kendler Model-Fitting Approach in Examining the Etiology of Comorbidity". Xulq-atvor genetikasi. 34 (3): 251–65. doi:10.1023/B:BEGE.0000017871.87431.2a. PMID  14990866.
  12. ^ Maj, Mario (2005). "'Psychiatric comorbidity': An artifact of current diagnostic systems?". The British Journal of Psychiatry. 186 (3): 182–84. doi:10.1192/bjp.186.3.182. PMID  15738496.
  13. ^ Massimiliano Aragona (2009). "The Role of Comorbidity in the Crisis of the Current Psychiatric Classification System". Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology. 16: 1–11. doi:10.1353/ppp.0.0211.
  14. ^ Jakovljević, Miro; Crnčević, Željka (June 2012). "Comorbidity as an epistemological challenge to modern psychiatry". Dialogues in Philosophy, Mental and Neuro Sciences. 5 (1): 1–13.
  15. ^ Feinstein, Alvan R. (1970). "The pre-therapeutic classification of co-morbidity in chronic disease". Journal of Chronic Diseases. 23 (7): 455–68. doi:10.1016/0021-9681(70)90054-8. PMID  26309916.
  16. ^ Лазебник Л. B. Старение и полиморбидность // Консилиум Медикум, 2005, № 12
  17. ^ Greenfield, Sheldon; Apolone, Giovanni; McNeil, Barbara J.; Cleary, Paul D. (1993). "The Importance of Co-Existent Disease in the Occurrence of Postoperative Complications and One-Year Recovery in Patients Undergoing Total Hip Replacement: Comorbidity and Outcomes after Hip Replacement". Medical Care. 31 (2): 141–54. doi:10.1097/00005650-199302000-00005. JSTOR  3765891. PMID  8433577.
  18. ^ Kristiansen, K.; Nesbakken, R. (1975). "Proceedings of the 26th annual meeting of the Nordisk Neurokirurgisk Förening (Scandinavian Neurosurgical Society) Sept. 5–7, 1974, Oslo, Norway". Acta Neurochirurgica. 31 (3–4): 257–74. doi:10.1007/BF01406298.
  19. ^ Boyd, Jeffrey H.; Burke, Jack D.; Gruenberg, Ernest; Holzer, Charles E.; Rae, Donald S.; George, Linda K.; Karno, Marvin; Stoltzman, Roger; va boshq. (1984). "Exclusion Criteria of DSM-III: A Study of Co-occurrence of Hierarchy-Free Syndromes". Archives of General Psychiatry. 41 (10): 983–89. doi:10.1001/archpsyc.1984.01790210065008. PMID  6477056.
  20. ^ Sanderson, William C.; Beck, Aaron T.; Beck, Judith (1990). "Syndrome comorbidity in patients with major depression or dysthymia: Prevalence and temporal relationships". Amerika psixiatriya jurnali. 147 (8): 1025–28. doi:10.1176/ajp.147.8.1025. PMID  2375436.
  21. ^ Нуллер, Ю. L. "Депрессия и деперсонализация: проблема коморбидности" [Depression and depersonalization: the problem of comorbidity]. Депрессии и коморбидные расстройства [Depression and comorbid disorders] (rus tilida).
  22. ^ Robins, Lee N. (1994). "How Recognizing 'Comorbidities' in Psychopathology May Lead to an Improved Research Nosology". Klinik psixologiya: fan va amaliyot. 1: 93–95. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2850.1994.tb00010.x.
  23. ^ Смулевич, А. B .; Дубницкая, Э. B .; Тхостов, А. Ш.; Зеленина, Е. V .; Андрющенко, A. В.; Иванов, C. В. "Психопатология депрессий (к построению типологической модели)" [Psychopathology of depression (the construction of a typological model)]. Депрессии и коморбидные расстройства [Depression and comorbid disorders] (rus tilida).
  24. ^ Cloninger, C. Robert (2002). "Implications of Comorbidity for the Classification of Mental Disorders: The Need for a Psychobiology of Coherence". In Maj, Mario; Gaebel, Wolfgang; López-Ibor, Juan José; va boshq. (tahr.). Psychiatric Diagnosis and Classification. pp.79 –106. doi:10.1002/047084647X.ch4. ISBN  978-0-471-49681-6.
  25. ^ Kaplan, Moreson H.; Feinstein, Alvan R. (1974). "The importance of classifying initial co-morbidity in evaluating the outcome of diabetes mellitus". Journal of Chronic Diseases. 27 (7–8): 387–404. doi:10.1016/0021-9681(74)90017-4. PMID  4436428.
  26. ^ Pincus, T; Callahan, LF (1986). "Taking mortality in rheumatoid arthritis seriously--predictive markers, socioeconomic status and comorbidity". Revmatologiya jurnali. 13 (5): 841–45. PMID  3820193.
  27. ^ Charlson, Mary E.; Sax, Frederic L. (1987). "The therapeutic efficacy of critical care units from two perspectives: A traditional cohort approach vs a new case-control methodology". Journal of Chronic Diseases. 40 (1): 31–39. doi:10.1016/0021-9681(87)90094-4. PMID  3805232.
  28. ^ Schellevis, F.G.; Van De Lisdonk, E.; Van Der Velden, J.; Van Eijk, J.Th.M.; Van Weel, C. (1993). "Validity of diagnoses of chronic diseases in general practice". Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 46 (5): 461–68. doi:10.1016/0895-4356(93)90023-T. PMID  8501472.
  29. ^ Kraemer, Helena Chmura (1995). "Statistical issues in assessing comorbidity". Statistics in Medicine. 14 (8): 721–33. doi:10.1002/sim.4780140803. PMID  7644854.
  30. ^ Van Den Akker, Marjan; Buntinx, Frank; Knottnerus, J André (1996). "Comorbidity or multimorbidity". European Journal of General Practice. 2 (2): 65–70. doi:10.3109/13814789609162146.
  31. ^ Grimby, A; Svanborg, A (1997). "Morbidity and health-related quality of life among ambulant elderly citizens". Qarish. 9 (5): 356–64. doi:10.1007/bf03339614. PMID  9458996.
  32. ^ Stier, David M; Greenfield, Sheldon; Lubeck, Deborah P; Dukes, Kimberly A; Flanders, Scott C; Henning, James M; Weir, Julie; Kaplan, Sherrie H (1999). "Quantifying comorbidity in a disease-specific cohort: Adaptation of the total illness burden index to prostate cancer". Urologiya. 54 (3): 424–29. doi:10.1016/S0090-4295(99)00203-4. PMID  10475347.
  33. ^ Fortin, Martin; Lapointe, Lise; Hudon, Catherine; Vanasse, Alain; Ntetu, Antoine L; Maltais, Danielle (2004). "Multimorbidity and quality of life in primary care: A systematic review". Sog'liqni saqlash va hayot sifati natijalari. 2: 51. doi:10.1186/1477-7525-2-51. PMC  526383. PMID  15380021.
  34. ^ Fortin, Martin; Lapointe, Lise; Hudon, Catherine; Vanasse, Alain (2005). "Multimorbidity is common to family practice: Is it commonly researched?". Kanadalik oilaviy shifokor. 51 (2): 244–45. PMC  1472978. PMID  16926936.
  35. ^ Лазебник, Л. B. (2007). Старение и полиморбидность [Aging and polymorbidity]. Новости медицины и фармации (rus tilida). 1 (205).[sahifa kerak ]
  36. ^ Вёрткин, А. Л.; Зайратьянц, О. V .; Вовк, Е. I. (2009). Окончательный диагноз [The final diagnosis] (rus tilida). Moscow: GEOTAR-Media. ISBN  978-5-9704-0920-6.[sahifa kerak ]
  37. ^ Caughey, Gillian E; Vitry, Agnes I; Gilbert, Andrew L; Roughead, Elizabeth E (2008). "Prevalence of comorbidity of chronic diseases in Australia". BMC Public Health. 8: 221. doi:10.1186/1471-2458-8-221. PMC  2474682. PMID  18582390.
  38. ^ Белялов, Ф. I. (2012). Лечение внутренних болезней в условиях коморбидности: монография Лечение внутренних болезней в условиях коморбидности [Internal Medicine in comorbidity] (PDF) (rus tilida). Irkutsk: РИО ИГМАПО. ISBN  978-5-89786-091-3.[doimiy o'lik havola ][sahifa kerak ]
  39. ^ Лучихин, Л. A. (2010). "Co-morbidity in ENT practice" Коморбидность в ЛОР-практике [Co-morbidity in ENT practice] (PDF). Вестник оториноларингологии (in Russian) (2): 79–82. PMID  20527094. Arxivlandi asl nusxasi (PDF) on 2012-01-18.
  40. ^ Starfield, B.; Lemke, KW; Bernhardt, T; Foldes, SS; Forrest, CB; Weiner, JP (2003). "Comorbidity: Implications for the Importance of Primary Care in 'Case' Management". Oilaviy tibbiyot yilnomalari. 1 (1): 8–14. doi:10.1370/afm.1. PMC  1466556. PMID  15043174.
  41. ^ Van Weel, Chris; Schellevis, François G (2006). "Comorbidity and guidelines: Conflicting interests". Lanset. 367 (9510): 550–51. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(06)68198-1. PMID  16488782.
  42. ^ Gill, Thomas M.; Feinstein, AR (1994). "A Critical Appraisal of the Quality of Quality-of-Life Measurements". JAMA. 272 (8): 619–26. doi:10.1001/jama.1994.03520080061045. PMID  7726894.
  43. ^ "Reliability and validity of a diabetes quality-of-life measure for the diabetes control and complications trial (DCCT). The DCCT Research Group". Diabetes Care. 11 (9): 725–32. 1988. doi:10.2337/diacare.11.9.725. PMID  3066604.
  44. ^ Michelson, Helena; Bolund, Christina; Brandberg, Yvonne (2000). "Multiple chronic health problems are negatively associated with health related quality of life (HRQoL) irrespective of age". Hayot sifatini o'rganish. 9 (10): 1093–104. doi:10.1023/A:1016654621784. PMID  11401042.
  45. ^ Hoffman, Catherine; Rice, D; Sung, HY (1996). "Persons with Chronic Conditions: Their Prevalence and Costs". JAMA. 276 (18): 1473–79. doi:10.1001/jama.1996.03540180029029. PMID  8903258.
  46. ^ Fuchs, Z.; Blumstein, T.; Novikov, I.; Walter-Ginzburg, A.; Lyanders, M.; Gindin, J.; Habot, B.; Modan, B. (1998). "Morbidity, Comorbidity, and Their Association with Disability Among Community-Dwelling Oldest-Old in Israel". The Journals of Gerontology Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences. 53A (6): M447–55. doi:10.1093/gerona/53A.6.M447. PMID  9823749.
  47. ^ Daveluy, C.; Pica, L.; Audet, N. (2001). Enquête Sociale et de Santé 1998 (2-nashr). Québec: Institut de la statistique du Québec. Arxivlandi asl nusxasi 2013-01-26. Olingan 2013-02-12.[sahifa kerak ]
  48. ^ Wolff, J. L.; Starfield, B; Anderson, G (2002). "Prevalence, Expenditures, and Complications of Multiple Chronic Conditions in the Elderly". Ichki kasalliklar arxivi. 162 (20): 2269–76. doi:10.1001/archinte.162.20.2269. PMID  12418941.
  49. ^ Cuijpers, Pim; Van Lammeren, Paula; Duzijn, Bernadette (1999). "Relation Between Quality of Life and Chronic Illnesses in Elderly Living in Residential Homes: A Prospective Study". International Psychogeriatrics. 11 (4): 445–54. doi:10.1017/S1041610299006067. PMID  10631590.
  50. ^ Caughey, G. E.; Ramsay, E. N.; Vitry, A. I.; Gilbert, A. L.; Luszcz, M. A.; Rayan, P.; Roughead, E. E. (2009). "Comorbid chronic diseases, discordant impact on mortality in older people: A 14-year longitudinal population study" (PDF). Journal of Epidemiology & Community Health. 64 (12): 1036–42. doi:10.1136/jech.2009.088260. hdl:2440/62696. PMID  19854745.
  51. ^ Aronow, Wilbert S; Ahn, Chul; Mercando, Anthony D; Epstein, Stanley (2000). "Prevalence of coronary artery disease, complex ventricular arrhythmias, and silent myocardial ischemia and incidence of new coronary events in older persons with chronic renal insufficiency and with normal renal function". Amerika kardiologiya jurnali. 86 (10): 1142–43, A9. doi:10.1016/S0002-9149(00)01176-0. PMID  11074216.
  52. ^ Bruce, Sharon G.; Riediger, Natalie D.; Zacharias, James M.; Young, T. Kue (2010). "Obesity and Obesity-Related Comorbidities in a Canadian First Nation Population". Preventing Chronic Disease. 31 (1): 27–32. PMID  21213616.
  53. ^ Weir, Peter T.; Harlan, Gregory A.; Nkoy, Flo L.; Jones, Spencer S.; Hegmann, Kurt T.; Gren, Lisa H.; Lyon, Joseph L. (2006). "The Incidence of Fibromyalgia and Its Associated Comorbidities". Journal of Clinical Rheumatology. 12 (3): 124–28. doi:10.1097/01.rhu.0000221817.46231.18. PMID  16755239.
  54. ^ Hudson, James I.; Goldenberg, Don L.; Pope, Harrison G.; Keck, Paul E.; Schlesinger, Lynn (1992). "Comorbidity of fibromyalgia with medical and psychiatric disorders". Amerika tibbiyot jurnali. 92 (4): 363–67. doi:10.1016/0002-9343(92)90265-D. PMID  1558082.
  55. ^ Van Den Akker, Marjan; Buntinx, Frank; Metsemakers, Job F.M.; Roos, Sjef; Knottnerus, J. André (1998). "Multimorbidity in General Practice: Prevalence, Incidence, and Determinants of Co-Occurring Chronic and Recurrent Diseases". Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 51 (5): 367–75. doi:10.1016/S0895-4356(97)00306-5. PMID  9619963.
  56. ^ Fortin, Martin; Bravo, Gina; Hudon, Catherine; Vanasse, Alain; Lapointe, Lise (2005). "Prevalence of Multimorbidity Among Adults Seen in Family Practice". Oilaviy tibbiyot yilnomalari. 3 (3): 223–8. doi:10.1370/afm.272. PMC  1466875. PMID  15928225.
  57. ^ Вёрткин, А. Л.; Скотников, А. S. Роль хронического аллергического воспаления в патогенезе бронхиальной астмы и его рациональная фармакотерапия у пациентов с полипатией [Role of chronic allergic inflammation in bronchial asthma pathogenesis and its rational pharmacological therapy for patients with polypathia] (PDF). Врач скорой помощи (in Russian) (4): 6–14.[doimiy o'lik havola ]
  58. ^ Feudjo-Tepie, M. A.; Le Roux, G.; Beach, K. J.; Bennett, D.; Robinson, N. J. (2009). "Comorbidities of Idiopathic Thrombocytopenic Purpura: A Population-Based Study". Advances in Hematology. 2009: 1–12. doi:10.1155/2009/963506. PMC  2778146. PMID  19960044.
  59. ^ Taylor, VM; Anderson, GM; McNeney, B; Diehr, P; Lavis, JN; Deyo, RA; Bombardier, C; Malter, A; Axcell, T (1998). "Hospitalizations for back and neck problems: A comparison between the Province of Ontario and Washington State". Health Services Research. 33 (4 Pt 1): 929–45. PMC  1070294. PMID  9776943.
  60. ^ Zhang, M.; Holman, C D. J; Price, S. D; Sanfilippo, F. M; Preen, D. B; Bulsara, M. K (2009). "Comorbidity and repeat admission to hospital for adverse drug reactions in older adults: Retrospective cohort study". BMJ. 338: a2752. doi:10.1136/bmj.a2752. PMC  2615549. PMID  19129307.
  61. ^ Wang, P. S.; Avorn, J; Brookhart, MA; Mogun, H; Schneeweiss, S; Fischer, MA; Glynn, RJ (2005). "Effects of Noncardiovascular Comorbidities on Antihypertensive Use in Elderly Hypertensives". Gipertenziya. 46 (2): 273–79. CiteSeerX  10.1.1.580.8951. doi:10.1161/01.HYP.0000172753.96583.e1. PMID  15983239.
  62. ^ Tomblin, J. Bruce; Mueller, Kathyrn L. (2012). "How Can Comorbidity with Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder Aid Understanding of Language and Speech Disorders?". Topics in Language Disorders. 32 (3): 198–206. doi:10.1097/TLD.0b013e318261c264. PMC  4013272. PMID  24817779.
  63. ^ Gijsen, Ronald; Hoeymans, Nancy; Schellevis, François G.; Ruwaard, Dirk; Satariano, William A.; Van Den Bos, Geertrudis A.M. (2001). "Causes and consequences of comorbidity". Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 54 (7): 661–74. doi:10.1016/S0895-4356(00)00363-2. PMID  11438406.
  64. ^ Пальцев, М.А.; Автандилов, Г.Г.; Зайратьянц, О.В.; Кактурский, Л.В. (2006). Никонов Е.Л. Правила формулировки диагноза. Часть 1. Общие положения [Rules language diagnosis. Part 1. General provisions] (rus tilida). Moscow: Scientific Research Institute of Human Morphology.[sahifa kerak ]
  65. ^ Зайратьянц, О. V .; Кактурский, Л. V. (2011). Формулировка и сопоставление клинического и патологоанатомического диагнозов: справочник Формулировка и сопоставление клинического и патологоанатомического диагнозов: Справочник [Formulation and comparison of clinical and postmortem diagnoses: A Handbook] (rus tilida) (2-nashr). Moscow: Meditsinskoe informatsionnoe agentstvo. ISBN  978-5-89481-881-8.[sahifa kerak ]
  66. ^ Degroot, V; Beckerman, H; Lankhorst, G; Bouter, L (2003). "How to measure comorbiditya critical review of available methods" (PDF). Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 56 (3): 221–29. doi:10.1016/S0895-4356(02)00585-1. PMID  12725876.
  67. ^ Linn, Bernard S.; Linn, Margaret W.; Gurel, Lee (1968). "Cumulative illness rating scale". Amerika Geriatriya Jamiyati jurnali. 16 (5): 622–26. doi:10.1111/j.1532-5415.1968.tb02103.x. PMID  5646906.
  68. ^ Miller M.D., Towers A. Manual of Guidelines for Scoring the Cumulative Illness Rating Scale for Geriatrics (CIRS-G) // Pittsburgh, Pa: University of Pittsburgh; 1991 yil
  69. ^ Miller, Mark D.; Paradis, Cynthia F.; Houck, Patricia R.; Mazumdar, Sati; Stack, Jacqueline A.; Rifai, A. Hind; Mulsant, Benoit; Reynolds, Charles F. (1992). "Rating chronic medical illness burden in geropsychiatric practice and research: Application of the Cumulative Illness Rating Scale". Psixiatriya tadqiqotlari. 41 (3): 237–48. doi:10.1016/0165-1781(92)90005-N. PMID  1594710.
  70. ^ Kaplan, M. H.; Feinstein, A. R. (1973). "A critique of methods in reported studies of long-term vascular complications in patients with diabetes mellitus". Qandli diabet. 22 (3): 160–74. doi:10.2337/diab.22.3.160. PMID  4689292.
  71. ^ Deyo, R; Cherkin, DC; Ciol, MA (1992). "Adapting a clinical comorbidity index for use with ICD-9-CM administrative databases". Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 45 (6): 613–19. doi:10.1016/0895-4356(92)90133-8. PMID  1607900.
  72. ^ Rozzini, R.; Frisoni, GB; Ferrucci, L; Barbisoni, P; Sabatini, T; Ranieri, P; Guralnik, JM; Trabucchi, M (2002). "Geriatric Index of Comorbidity: Validation and comparison with other measures of comorbidity". Yoshi va qarishi. 31 (4): 277–85. doi:10.1093/ageing/31.4.277. PMID  12147566.
  73. ^ Groll, D; To, T; Bombardier, C; Wright, J (2005). "The development of a comorbidity index with physical function as the outcome". Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. 58 (6): 595–602. doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2004.10.018. PMID  15878473.
  74. ^ Litwin, Mark S.; Greenfield, Sheldon; Elkin, Eric P.; Lubeck, Deborah P.; Broering, Jeanette M.; Kaplan, Sherrie H. (2007). "Assessment of prognosis with the total illness burden index for prostate cancer". Saraton. 109 (9): 1777–83. doi:10.1002/cncr.22615. PMID  17354226.
  75. ^ Muñoz, Eric; Rosner, Fred; Friedman, Richard; Sterman, Harris; Goldstein, Jonathan; Wise, Leslie (1988). "Financial risk, hospital cost, and complications and comorbidities in medical non-complications and comorbidity-stratified diagnosis-related groups". Amerika tibbiyot jurnali. 84 (5): 933–39. doi:10.1016/0002-9343(88)90074-5. PMID  3129939.
  76. ^ Barrett ML, Smith MW, Elizhauser A, Honigman LS, Pines JM (December 2014). "Utilization of Intensive Care Services, 2011". HCUP Statistical Brief #185. Rokvill, MD: Sog'liqni saqlash tadqiqotlari va sifat agentligi.

Qo'shimcha o'qish

Tashqi havolalar