Germaniyadagi Scientology - Scientology in Germany - Wikipedia

View of a seven-story, modern building, predominantly grey and white, with a cross-like symbol and large letters spelling
Berlin shahridagi Scientology shtab-kvartirasi

The Sayentologiya cherkovi Germaniyada 1970 yildan beri faoliyat yuritib kelmoqda. Germaniya rasmiylari 2012 yilga kelib Germaniyada 4000 ta faol sayentolog borligini taxmin qilishmoqda;[1] Scientology cherkovi 12000 atrofida a'zolik raqamini beradi.[2] Sayentologiya cherkovi Germaniya matbuoti va hukumatining o'ziga xos qarama-qarshiliklariga duch keldi va Germaniyada xavfli huquqiy, ijtimoiy va madaniy mavqega ega.

2017 yildan boshlab, Germaniya sudlari haligacha kelishish-qilmaslik masalasini hal qilishmagan Sayentologiya diniy yoki dunyoqarash jamiyatining huquqiy maqomi va turli sudlar qarama-qarshi xulosalarga kelishdi.[3] Nemis ichki razvedka xizmati tashkilotni doimiy ravishda kuzatib boradi va ularni yillik konstitutsiyaga qarshi tadbirlar to'g'risidagi sharhida eslatib turadi. The Germaniya hukumati sayentologiyani a deb tan olmaydi din; aksincha, uni suiiste'mol deb biladi biznes din sifatida yashiringan va u belgilangan qadriyatlarga zid bo'lgan siyosiy maqsadlarni ko'zlaydi deb hisoblaydi Germaniya konstitutsiyasi. Ushbu pozitsiya tomonidan tanqid qilingan AQSh hukumati.[4][5]

Germaniyadagi Scientologlar o'ziga xos siyosiy va iqtisodiy cheklovlarga duch kelmoqdalar. Ularga ba'zi bir yirik siyosiy partiyalarga a'zo bo'lish taqiqlanadi, korxonalar va boshqa ish beruvchilar "firqa filtrlari" deb nomlanib, bo'lajak biznes sherigi yoki ishchining tashkilot bilan assotsiatsiyasini ochib berishadi. Germaniya federal va shtat ichki ishlar vazirlari 2007 yil oxirida Scientology-ni taqiqlashga qaratilgan jarayonni boshladilar, ammo bir yil o'tib, etarli huquqiy asoslarni topib, tashabbusdan voz kechdilar. 2017 yilga kelib, so'rovnomalar shuni ko'rsatadiki, nemislarning yarmi Scientology-ni taqiqlashni qo'llab-quvvatlagan, uchdan ikki qismidan ko'prog'i Scientology-ni xavfli deb hisoblagan.[6]

Fon

Scientology, 1950-yillarning boshlarida AQShda tashkil etilgan L. Ron Xabard va bugungi kunda 150 mamlakatda vakili bo'lishni da'vo qilish juda ziddiyatli bo'ldi yangi diniy harakat.[7] Uning utopik maqsadi - "sayyorani tozalash", har bir inson o'zining psixologik cheklovlarini engib o'tgan ma'rifatli asrni yaratishdir.[8] Sayentologiya odamlarning baxtsizligining manbai "engramlar" da, og'riqli tajribalar davomida olingan psixologik yuklarda, deb hisoblaydi, ularni sayentologiya cherkovi tomonidan taqdim etilgan "auditorlik tekshiruvi" deb nomlangan maslahat turi yordamida tozalash mumkin.[8]

Sayentologlarning auditorlik tekshiruvi va boshqa sayentologik xizmatlari uchun katta to'lovlarni to'lashi kerakligi, tarixning ko'p qismida Scientology-ga munozaralarni keltirib chiqardi, hukumatlar uni din sifatida emas, balki foyda keltiradigan korxona deb tasnifladilar.[9] Tanqidchilar Scientology "biznesni boshqaradigan, dunyodagi hukmronlik qiladigan, psixologik manipulyatsiya qiluvchi, totalitar mafkura" ekanligini ta'kidlaydilar.[10][11] va bu o'z a'zolarini sayentologiya kurslari uchun katta miqdordagi mablag 'bilan ajratishga aldash.[7] Scientology bunday ayblovlardan o'zini himoya qilish va din sifatida qonuniy tan olinishi uchun behisob sud jarayonlarini olib bordi.[7] Ushbu sa'y-harakatlar qisman muvaffaqiyatli bo'ldi - Scientology bir qator mamlakatlarda, xususan, Avstraliya 1983 yilda va Qo'shma Shtatlar 1993 yilda va 2007 yilda g'olib chiqdi muhim ish da Evropa inson huquqlari sudi, bu tanqid qilingan Rossiya sayentologiyani din sifatida ro'yxatdan o'tkazolmagani uchun.[12]

Germaniya hukumati sayentologiyani din deb emas, balki "totalitar tuzilishi va usullari Germaniya demokratik jamiyati uchun xavf tug'dirishi mumkin bo'lgan" zaif shaxslardan foydalanish tarixiga ega va har qanday tanqidni o'ta yoqtirmaydigan "tijorat korxonasi" ekanligini aytdi. ".[3][13] Shunga ko'ra, Germaniya hukumati tashkilotga qarshi juda qattiq pozitsiyani oldi.[14][15] Germaniya Sayentologiyaga qarshi chiqishda yolg'iz emas; Fransiyada, Sayentologiya cherkovi 2009 yil oktyabr oyida, sud a'zolari Scientology mahsulotlari uchun katta miqdordagi pullarni to'lash uchun manipulyatsiya qilinganligini aniqlaganidan so'ng, uyushgan firibgarlikda aybdor deb topilgan va cherkov butunlay taqiqlanganidan juda ozgina xalos bo'lgan.[16] Sayentologiya ham xuddi shunday bahslidir Belgiyada, Gretsiya va Buyuk Britaniya.[13]

Sayentologiyaning din maqomi mavzusida Germaniya hukumati 1995 yilgi qaroriga ishora qildi Germaniya Federal mehnat sudi.[13] Ushbu sud Hubbardning sayentologlar "pul ishlashlari, ko'proq pul ishlashlari kerak - boshqa odamlar ko'proq pul ishlab chiqarish uchun ishlab chiqarishi kerak" degan ko'rsatmasiga e'tibor qaratib, "sayentologiya shunchaki" cherkov "bo'lishni maqsad qilib qo'ygan. iqtisodiy manfaatlar ".[13] Xuddi shu qarorda sud, shuningdek, Scientology "g'ayriinsoniy va totalitar amaliyotlardan" foydalanayotganligini aniqladi.[13] Germaniyaning 20-asr tarixidagi saboqlarni hisobga olgan holda, unda mamlakat a fashist xuddi shunga o'xshash kichik boshlanishlardan boshlangan harakat, Germaniya mutlaq hokimiyat mavqeini qidirmoqchi bo'lgan har qanday mafkuraviy harakatdan juda ehtiyotkor.[13][14][15] Sayentologiya asarlarida sayentologiya taraqqiyotiga to'sqinlik qiladigan "parazitlar" va "antisocial" odamlarni yo'q qilish haqida ma'lumot. utopik dunyo "jinniliksiz, jinoyatchilarsiz va urushsiz" bilan o'xshashliklarni noqulay keltirib chiqaradi Natsizm va Scientology-ning "ekstremistik siyosiy harakat" deb tasniflanishiga olib keldi.[17]

Germaniya hukumati o'z pozitsiyasini yanada oqlash uchun, shuningdek, Scientology bilan bog'liq AQSh sud ishlarining uzoq tarixiga ishora qildi, shu jumladan 1979 va 1980 yillarda 11 ta yuqori darajadagi Scientologlar sudlanganligi uchun AQSh hukumat idoralariga kirib borish, telefon hujjatlarini tinglash va o'g'irlash bilan bog'liq fitna, 1994 yil AQSh Oliy sudi sayentologiya amaliyotlari "majburiy muhitda" bo'lganligini va Scientology-ning tanqidchilarni zararli sud ishlari va xususiy tergovchilar orqali ta'qib qilish borasidagi tajribasi.[13] Germaniya hukumati Scientology tomonidan yuzaga kelishi mumkin bo'lgan tahdidni o'rganib chiqib, Scientology tashkilotlari "shaxsni psixologik va moddiy jihatdan Scientology tizimiga bog'liq qilish uchun tuzilganligini" va a'zolari ko'pincha do'stlari va oilalari bilan aloqani tark etishini ta'kidladi.[13]

Tarix

Sayentologiyaning Germaniyada mavjudligi

A 1950s or 1960s six-story building, predominantly made of yellow brick with red brick used around the windows. Other ornamentation include a large round black and white clock, a large black cross symbol, and
Gamburgdagi Sayentologiya cherkovi

Scientology birinchi bo'lib 1970 yilda Germaniyada ish boshladi.[18] 2007 yilga kelib Germaniyada o'nta yirik markaz ("Sayentologiya cherkovlari"), shuningdek o'n to'rtta kichik markazlar ("Sayentologiya missiyalari") mavjud edi.[18] Nemis sayentologiya cherkovlari yirik shaharlarda joylashgan - Myunxen, Gamburg, Berlin, Dyusseldorf, Frankfurt am Main, Gannover va Shtutgart.[18][19] Scientology missiyalarining to'qqiztasi Baden-Vyurtemberg va uchta Bavariya.[19] Keyingi Germaniyani qayta birlashtirish, Scientology avvalgi hududlarda juda ko'p sonli izdoshlarni topa olmaganligini isbotladi Germaniya Demokratik Respublikasi; aksariyat tarafdorlar Baden-Vyurtemberg, Bavariya va Shimoliy Reyn-Vestfaliya.[20]

Scientology ko'plab mustaqil assotsiatsiyalar tomonidan namoyish etiladi Vereine Germaniyada; ularning soyabon tashkiloti Scientology Kirche Deutschland e.V.[21] Germaniyaning ichki razvedka xizmati Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz (BfVyoki Konstitutsiyani himoya qilish federal idorasi) Germaniyada 4000 ta sayentolog borligini taxmin qilmoqda,[1] avvalgi taxminlarga qaraganda 5000 dan 6000 gacha.[18][22][23] The Sayentologiya cherkovi 1990-yillarning o'rtalaridan boshlab taxminan 30,000 a'zolari haqida xabar berishdi; bu raqam ko'p yillar davomida barqaror bo'lib qoldi.[22][24] Ammo yaqinda Scientology uning atigi 12000 a'zosi borligini aytdi.[2] Sayentologga a'zolik raqamlaridagi tafovutlar yuzaga keladi, chunki Scientology cherkovi ularning raqamlarini aniqlashda yanada keng qamrovli mezonlarni qo'llaydi, asosan kitob sotib olgan yoki kurslarda qatnashgan har bir kishini, ularning keyingi ishtirokidan qat'i nazar.[25] Germaniya Scientology tashkilotlarida ishlaydigan shartnoma bo'yicha Scientology xodimlarining soni bir necha yuzdan oshmasligi mumkin.[26]

Scientology 1994 yilda "aniq Germaniya" strategiyasini ishlab chiqdi, bu sayentologiya tomonidan dunyoning boshqa mamlakatlari va mintaqalarida amalga oshirilgan ekvivalent strategiyalarga o'xshash - uzoq vaqt davomida nemis jamiyatini Scientological idealiga mos ravishda o'zgartirish uchun plyuralistik bo'lmagan jamiyat. qaysi Scientology ustun ta'sirga ega.[27][28] Dastur Scientology-ning Germaniyadagi imidj muammolarini hal qilishga, Germaniyaning Milliy Sotsialistik tarixi kabi siyosiy manfaatlar uchun ishlatilishi mumkin bo'lgan zaif tomonlarni aniqlashga va Germaniya jamiyatidagi a'zolik raqamlarini va siyosiy ta'sirini oshirishga harakat qildi. sayentologlarni sanoat va hukumatdagi asosiy lavozimlarga manevr qilish.[27][28] Aksariyat dinlar jamiyatdagi ta'sirini kengaytirishga intilayotgani sababli, bunday dastur, albatta, ko'p dinlar singari missionerlik harakati sifatida himoya qilinishi mumkin.[27] Biroq, BfV, strategiya sezilarli muvaffaqiyatga erishmadi.[27] 1998 yilga kelib, 90 ta davlat amaldorlari sayentologlar deb gumon qilingan va 48 ta holatda shubhalar tasdiqlangan, biroq ayrim alohida holatlardan tashqari, tegishli mansabdor shaxslarning aksariyati o'zlarining lavozimlaridan sayentologiyani reklama qilishda foydalanmaganlar.[27] Fifka & Sydora (2009) ma'lumotlariga ko'ra, "aniq Germaniya" dasturi qay darajada davom etayotgani noma'lum.[27]

Jamoatchilik muxolifati

Nemis jamoat nutqi sayentologiyani din deb hisoblamaydi, lekin odatda uni a Sekte (din yoki mazhab) yoki ekspluatatsiya qiluvchi foyda keltiruvchi korxona sifatida himoyasiz aqlga zarar etkazadi.[5][14][29][30] Kultlarning potentsial xavfidan jamoatchilikning xavotirlari 1970-yillarning boshlarida, "yoshlar dinlari" kabi keng muhokamalar boshlanganda boshlangan. Birlashish cherkovi, ISKCON, Xudoning bolalari, va Ilohiy nur missiyasi.[30] Bularning eng taniqli tanqidchilari yangi diniy harakatlar "mazhab komissarlari" edi (Sektenbeauftragte) Germaniyaning Protestant cherkovlari, shuningdek, "ota-onalar va manfaatdor shaxslarning tashabbuslari" ning tashkil etilishini faol ravishda targ'ib qilgan.[30] Aktion Bildungsinformation ("Ta'lim bo'yicha axborot kampaniyasi") sayentologiyaga qarshi kurashishga bag'ishlangan muhim tashkilotga aylandi; faollar pozitsiyasini qabul qilib, odamlarni sayentologiya bilan aralashmaslikdan ogohlantirdi, sayentologiya cherkovining jamoat joylarida prozelitizm qilgani uchun muvaffaqiyatli sud ishlarini olib bordi va nufuzli kitob nashr etdi, Sayentologiya mazmuni va uning oldingi tashkilotlari.[31] 1981 yilda tashkilot asoschisi Ingo Xeynemann direktor bo'ldi Freiheit für geistige und psychische ("Intellektual va ruhiy erkinlik kampaniyasi"), Germaniyaning eng taniqli dinga qarshi tashkiloti.[31] Yangi diniy oqimlarning ta'siri haqida mazhab mutaxassislarining ogohlantirishlari ommaviy axborot vositalarining e'tiborini tortdi, bu esa hukumatga vaziyatni hal qilish uchun siyosiy bosim o'tkazdi; Harakatlar noqonuniy ish qilmaganligi sababli, hukumat diniy mazhablar to'g'risida umumiy ogohlantirish beradigan bir qancha varaqalar va ommaviy bayonotlar chiqarishga kirishdi, bu nashrlarning eng qadami 1979 yilda paydo bo'lgan.[30]

Kabi voqealar bilan to'yingan Waco qamal bilan bog'liq qotillik va o'z joniga qasd qilish Quyosh ibodatxonasi ordeni va 1995 yil Aum Shinrikyo voqealar Yaponiya, Germaniyaliklarning qo'rquvi va xavotirlari yangi diniy oqimlarga nisbatan 1990-yillarda kuchaygan va Scientology alohida e'tiborni jalb qilgan.[30][32][33] Scientology totalitar xarakterga ega bo'lgan tushunchalar qachon kuchaytirildi Robert Vaughn Young, Amerikalik sobiq Scientologist va sobiq PR Scientology cherkovining rasmiy vakili, 1995 yil oxirida Germaniya rasmiylariga tashrif buyurgan va maqola yozgan Der Spiegel, Sayentologiyani a ishlaydigan totalitar tizim sifatida tavsiflovchi, haftalik keng o'qiladigan jurnal gulag - the Reabilitatsiya loyihasi kuchi - Scientology a'zolari uchun Dengiz org qonunbuzarliklarda aybdor deb topildi.[11] 1990-yillarning o'rtalaridan boshlab Scientology-ga bag'ishlangan matbuot maqolalari, ma'ruzalari va insholari deyarli har kuni paydo bo'ldi, kitoblar va televizion dasturlar bilan birga ommaviy auditoriyani qamrab oldi.[34]

Display with three types of information leaflets, with the numbers and titles
Ma'lumot varaqalari Islomiy ekstremizm, Scientology va uyushgan jinoyatchilik, Bavariya Konstitutsiyani himoya qilish idorasi tomonidan nashr etilgan[35]

Dinshunos olim Hubert Zayvert ta'kidlaganidek, sayentologiya "nafaqat shaxslarni irodasiz zombiyaga aylantirish bilan tahdid qiladigan, balki davlatning demokratik konstitutsiyasini ag'darish uchun fitna uyushtiradigan jiddiy siyosiy xavf" sifatida qaraldi.[30] Scientology-ning bu ko'rinishi a ommaviy dushman Seiwert, "siyosiy to'g'rilik masalasiga aylandi" deb qo'shib qo'ydi: katta siyosiy arboblar Scientology-ga qarshi kampaniyalarni boshlashga kirishdilar va u bilan har qanday assotsiatsiyadan gumon qilinish ijtimoiy ostrakizmga olib keldi.[30] Stiven A. Kent, 1998 yilda yozgan holda, Germaniya hukumatining barcha darajalaridagi amaldorlari Scientology-ni bostirish kerak degan talabni o'rtoqlashishini ta'kidladilar.[11] Scientology "inson huquqlarini sezilarli darajada buzganlikda aybdor bo'lgan totalitar, biznes yuritadigan tashkilot [...]" sifatida qaraldi.[36] Birlamchi va ikkilamchi manbalarni, huquqiy hujjatlarni va sobiq a'zolarning ko'rsatmalarini o'rgangan rasmiylar, tashkilot "demokratik davlatga qarshi" degan xulosaga kelishdi.[36] Federal vazirliklar va shtat hukumatlaridan so'raldi[kim tomonidan? ] Scientology faoliyatini tekshirish uchun ularning ixtiyoridagi barcha qonuniy vositalardan foydalanish.[37]

Sektalar xavfi to'g'risida hukumat tomonidan nashr etilgan nashrlar 1996-1998 yillarda ko'paygan va ularning katta qismi sayentologiya cherkovi bilan bog'liq.[30] Germaniya sudlari 1989 yilda bunday nashrlarni hukumatning jamoatchilikni xabardor qilish majburiyatining bir qismi deb bilganligi va diniy erkinlikka to'sqinlik qilmaganligini aniqlagan.[30] 1996 yilda Germaniya parlamenti sektalar va shunga o'xshash guruhlarni tergov qilish uchun Enquete (Surishtiruv) komissiyasini ishga tushirdi, chunki bu asosan Scientology haqida jamoatchilikning xavotirlariga sabab bo'lgan.[15][30] 1998 yil iyun oyida chop etilgan yakuniy hisobotida yangi diniy oqimlar orasida sayentologiyaning o'zi Germaniyaning ichki razvedka xizmatlari tomonidan nazorat qilinishi kerak degan xulosaga keldi.[30][36]

Nemis ommaviy axborot vositalarida keng tarqalgan tashvish doirasi, Scientology tomonidan dunyoga hukmronlik qilishga tayyorgarlik ko'rish uchun jamiyat, siyosat va biznesga kirib borishni e'lon qilgan maqsadiga muvofiq, Scientologlar tomonidan biznesning "kirib borishi".[38] Xabarlarga ko'ra, biznesga kirib borishga urinishlar kichik va o'rta kompaniyalar, masalan, ko'chmas mulk agentlari, menejment bo'yicha maslahatchilar va menejmentni o'qitish kompaniyalari orasida eng muvaffaqiyatli bo'lgan.[38] Sayentologlar boshchiligidagi menejment-konsalting kompaniyalari ko'pincha Scientology bilan aloqalarini yashirishadi; o'zlarining mijozlari yuqori menejmenti a'zolarini jalb qilgandan so'ng, ushbu menejerlar xodimlarni kompaniya o'qitish va o'qitish dasturlarining bir qismi sifatida Scientology trenerlariga yuborishlari mumkin, ular ishlatilgan o'quv usullarining kelib chiqishi to'g'risida ularga xabar bermasdan.[39] Scientology-ning qimmat tijorat versiyasi Oksfordning imkoniyatlarini tahlil qilish, odatda, Scientology jamoat joylarida prozelitizm qilishning bir qismi sifatida bepul taqdim etilib, ba'zi bir yirik nemis kompaniyalariga (uning isbotlanishidan bexabar bo'lgan) vaqtincha mana shunday boshqaruv konsalting firmasi orqali kirib kelgan.[39]

2000-yillarning o'rtalarida nemis sektasi mutaxassislari Scientologlar Germaniyaning maktabdan keyingi repetitorlik bozorida faollashib borayotganidan xavotir bildirdilar.[40] Frankfurt, Gamburg, Shtutgart va boshqa joylardagi Scientologlar tomonidan boshqariladigan 20 ga yaqin maktabdan tashqari repetitorlik markazlari mijozlari sayentologlar tomonidan o'z bolalariga sayentologlar tomonidan o'qitilayotganligini bilmasliklari sababli bu tashvishlar paydo bo'ldi.[40] Repetitorlik xizmatlarini reklama qiluvchi risolalarda ko'pi bilan ularning nomi keltirilgan L. Ron Xabard, Scientology asoschisi, ammo Scientology o'zi emas.[40]

2008 yil boshida Tomas Gandov, firqaning komissari Nemis lyuteran cherkovi Berlinda va Brandenburg,[41] va tarixchi Gvido Knopp ikkalasi ham Scientologistni o'xshatdi Gollivud aktyor Tom Kruz ga Gebbels, Natsist targ'ibot vaziri.[42] Gandov va Knopp Kentning tomoshabinlardan Scientologlar dunyoni "tozalashi" kerakmi, yo'qmi deb so'raganligi haqidagi "Scientology" videofilmini keltirdilar, tinglovchilar baquvvat xursandchilik bilan javob berishdi - Gandov va Knopp his qilgan xitoblar tomoshabinlarning Gebbelsning mashhur savoliga bergan javobini eslatdi. , "Siz umumiy urushni xohlaysizmi? "[42] Gandov va Knoppning izohlari Germaniyada kam tanqidchilarni topdi.[42] Ko'pgina nemislar sayentologiyani buzg'unchi tashkilot deb bilishadi.[43] 1997 yilda, Vaqt nemislarning 70 foizi Scientology-ni taqiqlashni ma'qullaganligini xabar qildi;[43] tomonidan 2008 yil sentyabr oyida o'tkazilgan so'rovnoma Der Spiegel taqiqni 67% qo'llab-quvvatladi.[44]

Brigit Shyon va Jerald Uilms kabi nemis olimlari, ritorika Germaniyadagi Scientology atrofidagi jamoatchilik nutqida ustunlik qiladi, deb ta'kidladilar: ularning fikriga ko'ra "ramka "fikrni shakllantiradigan ma'lumot uzoq vaqtdan beri asosiy haqiqatlarga qaraganda muhimroq bo'lgan.[45][46] Shonning so'zlari bilan aytganda, bunga "nemis siyosatchilarining o'zlarining mashhurligini kuchli so'zlar bilan ommalashtirishga qaratilgan sa'y-harakatlari" ham, "Scientologyning o'zini adolatsiz ta'qiblar qurboni sifatida ko'rsatish harakatlari" ham kiradi; Germaniyadagi Scientology gazetasida chop etilgan xorijiy xabarlarga izoh berar ekan, u "Amerika matbuoti zerikarli tergovdan ko'ra sensatsionistik yangiliklarni afzal ko'rishi va bu masalani Amerika stereotiplariga ko'ra belgilashi mumkin", deb qo'shimcha qildi.[46] Uillms ham, Sxen ham vaziyatni Scientology ilmiy tadqiqotlarining umumiy sustligi kuchaytirmoqda, deb ta'kidlaydilar.[45][46] Shon, shuningdek Irving Hexham, Dinshunoslik professori Kalgari universiteti Kanadada, xususan, nemis olimlari tomonidan akademik tadqiqotlar o'tkazilmaganligi haqida ta'kidladilar.[46][47] Xeksem bu holatni Germaniyadagi xristian cherkovlarining kuchli ta'siri bilan izohlaydi, bu esa nemis akademiklarini mavzuga yaqinlashishdan ehtiyot qildi, chunki ular o'zlarining tadqiqotlarini moliyalashtirish va agar ular o'zlarini munozaraga jalb qilsalar, kelajakda ish bilan ta'minlash istiqbollari ta'siridan qo'rqishadi.[46][47]

2010 yilda Germaniyaning jamoat teleradiokompaniyasi, ARD, filmni namoyish etdi Hech narsa qolmaguncha, Scientology-ning bitta nemis oilasiga ta'siri haqida dramatizatsiyalangan ma'lumot.[48][49] Haqiqiy voqeaga asoslangan deb aytilgan ushbu film keng ommaviy axborot vositalarining e'tiborini va 8,69 million tomoshabinni jalb qildi.[48][49]

Huquqiy holat

Sayentologiyani taqiqlash talablari ilgari surilgan bo'lsa-da, Sayentologiya cherkovi Germaniyada qonuniy bo'lib qoladi va u erda ishlashga ruxsat beriladi.[14] Ammo uning aniq huquqiy maqomi hal qilinmagan.[3] Ikki nuqta bo'yicha bahs yuritiladi: birinchidan, sayentologiya ta'limoti "din yoki dunyoqarash" darajasiga to'g'ri keladimi yoki yo'qmi (Din yoki Weltanschauung; bular Germaniya qonunchiligi oldida tengdir[50]), ikkinchidan, ushbu ta'limotlar faqat tijorat faoliyati uchun bahona sifatida ishlatiladimi yoki yo'qmi; agar ikkinchisi shunday bo'lgan bo'lsa, bu ehtimol Scientology "diniy yoki dunyoqarash birligi" sifatida himoya qilish huquqiga ega emasligini anglatadi (Dinlar - Weltanschauungsgemeinschaft) ning 4-moddasiga binoan Germaniya konstitutsiyasi, bu e'tiqod, din va dunyoqarash erkinligini kafolatlaydi.[3] "Diniy yoki dunyoqarash hamjamiyati" maqomi Germaniyada soliqqa tortish va birlashish erkinligi kabi boshqa ko'plab boshqa masalalarga ham ta'sir qiladi.[3]

The Germaniya Federal Adliya sudi hali bu masala bo'yicha aniq qaror qabul qilmagan, ammo 1980 yilda Scientology diniy yoki dunyoqarash hamjamiyatini vakili deb taxmin qilgan.[3] Yuqori ma'muriy sud Gamburg 1994 yilda Scientology-ga dunyoqarash birligi sifatida qarash kerakligi haqida aniq ta'kidlangan.[3] 1995 yilda, Germaniya Federal mehnat sudi Sayentologiya cherkovi shunchaki tijorat maqsadlarini ko'zlagan va Germaniya Konstitutsiyasining 4-moddasiga binoan himoyalanish huquqiga ega bo'lgan diniy yoki dunyoqarash jamoatini ifodalamaydi, degan qarorga keldi, garchi o'sha sudning boshqa qarori 2003 yilda yana savolni ochiq qoldirdi.[3][40] 2003 yil yana bir qarorda Ma'muriy sud Baden-Vyurtemberg yilda Manxaym Scientology ta'limoti shunchaki tijorat faoliyati uchun bahona bo'lib xizmat qilganiga oid ko'rsatmalar yo'qligini aytdi.[3][51][52] 2005 yilda Germaniya Federal Ma'muriy sudi diniy erkinlik va dunyoqarash daxlsizligini e'lon qilgan Germaniya Konstitutsiyasining 4.1-moddasiga binoan Scientologist himoyasi aniq berilgan.[3][53][54]

Ko'plab sudlar Scientology-ning diniy maqomini baholashdan bosh tortishdi, chunki bu savol ishni ko'rib chiqishda ahamiyatsiz edi.[3] Masalan, Federal Ma'muriy Sud 1997 yilda Scientology dinmi yoki yo'qmi degan savolga ahamiyatsiz bo'lgan va uning huquqiy maqomi uning biznes faoliyati bilan baholanishi kerak degan qaror chiqardi.[3][40] Germaniya hukumati sayentologiya cherkovini diniy yoki dunyoqarash birligi deb hisoblamaydi[3] va Scientology din emas, balki foyda keltiradigan korxona ekanligini ta'kidlaydi.[29][43]So'nggi yillarda siyosatchilar va keng jamoatchilik orasida Sayentologiyaga salbiy munosabat juda keng tarqalganiga qaramay, bir qator sud qarorlari Scientology foydasiga ko'rildi.[15]

Hukumat nazorati

Logotipi Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz (BfV)

Tarixini hisobga olgan holda Natsizm 1930-yillarda Germaniyada hokimiyat tepasiga kelgan hozirgi Germaniya davlati o'z ichiga olgan qadriyatlarga tahdid soluvchi har qanday mafkuraning paydo bo'lishiga yo'l qo'ymaslik uchun faol choralar ko'rishga majbur bo'ldi. Germaniya konstitutsiyasi.[55][56] The BfV ichki razvedka xizmati (Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz(yoki Konstitutsiyani himoya qilish federal idorasi) Scientology-ning maqsadlarini Germaniyaning erkin va demokratik tuzumiga zid deb hisoblaydi va 1997 yildan beri Scientology-ni kuzatib keladi, shuningdek, bir qator nemis tilidagi Konstitutsiyani himoya qilish idoralari. Lander.[3][57] Oila siyosati vaziri Klaudiya Nolte cherkovda bor deb, kuzatuvni o'rnatdi totalitar tendentsiyalari va u Scientology-ga qo'lidagi barcha vositalar bilan qarshi turishi.[58]

Nemis Scientology cherkovi ushbu kuzatuvning qonuniyligini sudda bir necha bor shubha ostiga qo'ygan. 2001 yil dekabrda Ma'muriy sud Berlin Berlin konstitutsiyasini himoya qilish idorasiga qarshi qaror chiqardi va unga sayentologiya Berlin cherkovi xodimlari va a'zolarini pullik ma'lumot beruvchi sifatida jalb qilish va joylashtirishni to'xtatishni buyurdi. Sud axborot beruvchilardan foydalanish nomutanosib deb qaror qildi.[59][60] 2003 yilda o'sha sud Berlin konstitutsiyani himoya qilish byurosi tomonidan hisobotda konstitutsiyaga zid bo'lgan har qanday faoliyat ko'rsatilmaganligini hisobga olib, sayentologiya faoliyatini o'z hisobotiga kiritishi noqonuniy deb topdi.[61][62]

Federal darajada, Scientology tomonidan doimiy kuzatuvga qarshi shikoyat yo'qoldi BfV 2004 yil noyabrda. Federal sud o'z fikrini Scientology-ning maqsadi, ta'kidlaganidek, o'z qaroriga asosladi L. Ron Xabard uning asarlarida Germaniya konstitutsiyasiga mos kelmagan.[57][63] Federal Konstitutsiyani himoya qilish idorasida ishlaydigan yuristlar Xabard buni yozganligini ta'kidladilar inson huquqlari Masalan, sayentologlar bilan cheklanishi kerak va ular sayentologiya tashkiloti antisentologiya qonunchiligini oldini olish maqsadida jamiyat va hukumat institutlariga kirib borish uchun tizimli choralar ko'rmoqda, deb ta'kidlashdi.[57] Sayentologiya cherkovi uchun ishlaydigan qarama-qarshi maslahatchilar Scientology siyosiy bo'lmagan, uning maqsadi insonni ozod qilish va Xabardning ko'rsatmalari faqat Sayentologiya cherkovi ichida amal qiladi va talqin qilinishi kerak edi va har qanday joyda u erda Germaniyada ushbu ko'rsatmalarni amalga oshirish uchun hech qanday harakat bo'lmagan.[57] Sud bu fikrga qo'shilmadi va ko'plab manbalarga, ularning ba'zilari keng jamoatchilikka ochiq emasligiga, sayentologiya cherkovining maqsadlari tenglik va boshqa muhim inson huquqlari printsiplarini bekor qilishni o'z ichiga olganligini ko'rsatdi.[57]

Yilda Saarland, 2005 yilda kuzatuv sud tomonidan noo'rin deb to'xtatildi, chunki Sayentologiyaning mahalliy bo'limi yo'q va uning a'zolari kam.[63] 2008 yil 6-may holatiga ko'ra Germaniyadagi Sayentologiya cherkovi o'z faoliyatini kuzatishni oldini olish uchun qonuniy kurashni to'xtatdi BfV keyin Shimoliy Reyn-Vestfaliya Oliy ma'muriy sud Myunster masala bo'yicha apellyatsiya shikoyatini ko'rib chiqishdan bosh tortdi.[64] Scientology tashkiloti "erkin, demokratik asosiy tuzumga qarshi ambitsiyalarni" qo'llab-quvvatlashda gumon qilinib, unga inson huquqlari va demokratiya to'g'risidagi deklaratsiyani qo'shdi. nizom.[64]

Germaniyadan tashqarida nemis razvedka xizmatlari tomonidan Scientology tomonidan kuzatilgan kamida bitta misol mavjud. 1998 yilda Shveytsariya hukumati Germaniya hukumatining agentini hibsga oldi va unga "xorijiy davlat uchun noqonuniy biznes olib borganligi, siyosiy axborot xizmatida ishlaganligi va shaxsni tasdiqlovchi hujjatlarni qalbakilashtirganligi" da aybladi.[65][66] Germaniya hukumati agentga garov puli to'lagan.[67] Oxir oqibat u Scientology-ga josuslik qilgani uchun 30 kunlik shartli qamoq jazosiga hukm qilindi va Germaniya hukumati ushbu hodisa uchun Shveytsariyadan kechirim so'radi.[65][68]

Sekt filtrlari

Head and upper body of a plump middle-aged woman with grey-blonde hair speaking at a wooden lectern, two slim microphones in front of her.
Ursula Kaberta 2008 yilda Gamburgdagi Scientology konferentsiyasida nutq so'zlagan

"Himoya deklaratsiyasi" deb ham ataladigan "mazhab filtri" (Schutzerklärung), istiqbolli biznes sheriklari yoki xodimlaridan mazhab bilan birlashishni yoki tan olishni talab qiladigan hujjatdir yangi diniy harakat biznes yoki mehnat shartnomasini tuzishdan oldin.[53][69] Asosan Scientologlarni tekshirish uchun ishlatiladigan bunday sekta filtrlari Germaniya davlat idoralari tomonidan korxonalar tomonidan foydalanish uchun ishlab chiqilgan.[69] "Tariqat komissari" idoralari Germaniyada mintaqaviy yoki mahalliy hukumat tarkibida mavjud.[69]

1996 yilda kiritilgan ish yo'riqnomasi hukumat xodimlarini talab qiladi Arbeitsämter - tomonidan boshqariladigan mahalliy ish bilan ta'minlash agentliklari va ijtimoiy ta'minot idoralari Federal mehnat va ijtimoiy ishlar vazirligi - Scientologlarga tegishli kompaniyalarni "S" harfi bilan belgilash.[70] Agar kompaniyalar Scientologist xodimlariga ega deb gumon qilinsa, bo'lajak xodimlar bu haqda hukumat xodimlari tomonidan ogohlantiriladi.[71] Hukumat amaldorlari individual sayentologlarning ismlarini e'lon qildilar va ularning bizneslariga qarshi ommaviy aktsiyalar o'tkazdilar; ba'zi bir ishbilarmonlar, ular bilan bog'liq stigmaga yo'l qo'ymaslik uchun, sayentolog emasliklarini e'lon qilib, matbuotda reklama joylashtirdilar.[71]

Sayentologlar tomonidan hukumatning kirib borishi xavfi tufayli, davlat xizmatiga da'vogarlar Bavariya Sayentolog yoki yo'qligini e'lon qilishlari shart va shunga o'xshash siyosat o'rnatildi Xesse.[11][72] Hukumat shartnomalari bo'yicha tender o'tkazayotgan kompaniyalar ham xuddi shunday Scientologist emasligini bildirishlari shart edi; 2001 yilda ushbu talab o'zgartirilgan va hozirda firmalardan "shartnomani rasmiylashtirishda L. Ron Xabardning texnologiyasidan foydalanilmaydi" degan shaklga imzo qo'yishni so'rashmoqda.[71] Qachon ma'lum bo'ldi Microsoft "s Windows 2000 operatsion tizim kiritilgan a diskni birlashtiruvchi tomonidan ishlab chiqilgan Ijrochi dasturiy ta'minot xalqaro (Scientologist boshchiligidagi kompaniya), bu Germaniya hukumat amaldorlari va ruhoniylari o'rtasida ma'lumotlar xavfsizligi va josuslik ehtimoli haqida tashvish uyg'otdi.[5][69][73] Ushbu tashvishlarni bartaraf etish uchun Microsoft Germaniya yordam dasturini o'chirib qo'yish vositasini taqdim etishga rozi bo'ldi.[69][73] Scientology huquqshunoslarining kamsitilishi to'g'risida shikoyat xatlaridan so'ng, ba'zi Amerika kompaniyalari General Electric, IBM va Ford Motor Company Germaniya filiallariga himoya deklaratsiyalaridan foydalanishni to'xtatish to'g'risida ko'rsatma berdi.[74]

Shahar-davlat Gamburg Scientology-ga qarshi turishga bag'ishlangan kunduzgi ofisni tashkil etdi Gamburg ichki ishlar boshqarmasi uchun Scientology maxsus guruhi boshchiligida Ursula Kaberta.[75] 2005 yilda, Scientologist tomonidan olib borilgan holda, Germaniya Federal Ma'muriy sudi Gamburg shahriga ushbu amaliyot diniy erkinlikni buzgan deb topib, o'z biznes doiralariga himoya deklaratsiyalaridan foydalanishni tavsiya qilishni to'xtatishni buyurdi.[53] 2008 yil iyun oyida Gamburg ma'muriy sudi Gamburg shahrini "mazhab filtrlari" dan foydalanishni taqiqlovchi sud ko'rsatmalariga rioya qilmagani uchun 5000 evro (7000 dollar) miqdorida jarimaga tortdi.[76] Biznes uchun foydalaniladigan namunaviy filtrlarga Internet-ulanishlar mavjud bo'lib qolaverdi.[76] Eileen Barker, professor sotsiologiya da London iqtisodiyot maktabi, "Germaniya sayentologlarning fuqarolik huquqlarini cheklashda boshqa G'arbiy Evropa mamlakatlariga qaraganda ilgarilab ketdi" deb ta'kidladi.[55] Gamburg ishchi guruhi byudjetni qisqartirish natijasida 2010 yil avgust oyida yopilgan; Kaberta Gamburg ichki idorasi tarkibiga o'tdi va u erda Scientology bo'yicha ishini davom ettirdi.[77][78]

Sayentologlarga Germaniyadagi kabi yirik siyosiy partiyalarga qo'shilish taqiqlangan Xristian-demokratik ittifoqi, Bavariyaning nasroniy ijtimoiy ittifoqi, Germaniya sotsial-demokratik partiyasi va Erkin Demokratik partiya.[29][43][79] Ushbu partiyalarning amaldagi Scientologist a'zolari "tozalangan" Vaqt jurnal.[43] Sayentologlarning Germaniyada ish bilan ta'minlanishiga to'sqinlik qilindi; Bunday agentliklarni boshqargan sayentologlarning ruxsatnomalari bekor qilindi.[37] 1995 yilda sport olimi va Germaniyaning sobiq a'zosi qilichbozlik Germaniya Olimpiya qilichbozlik markazidagi ishi, u intervyuda L. Ron Xabardning kitoblarini o'qishni yaxshi ko'rganini va Scientologist menejment va aloqa bo'yicha konsalting firmasi tomonidan olib borilgan kursda qatnashganini aytganidan keyin ishdan bo'shatildi.[37][80] Tomas Gottschalk, nemis teleboshlovchisi, 1993 yilda Sayentologiya kurslarida qatnashganlikda yolg'on ayblangan; Gottschalk bunga javoban u yo'qligini va bundan buyon Scientology bilan aloqasi bo'lgan do'sti bilan aloqani to'xtatishini e'lon qildi.[37][81] 2007 yilda, Gyunter Ottinger, Vazir-Prezident Germaniya davlatining Baden-Vyurtemberg, Scientologistdan tashvish bildirdi Jon Travolta Gottschalk dasturida paydo bo'lishi kerak edi va so'radi ZDF Taklifnomani bekor qilishni ko'rib chiqish uchun telekanal; ZDF Travoltani chaqirmaslik katta zarar etkazishini aytdi va Scientology dasturda muhokama qilinmaydi.[82]

2010 yilda Bavariya ma'muriy sudi sobiq eri uni Scientologist deb tanishtirganda ishi tugatilgan bolalar bog'chasida ishlaydigan ayolni ishiga qaytarish to'g'risida qaror chiqardi.[49][83] Ayol suddan mamnuniyat bilan uning Scientological e'tiqodlari uning ishi uchun ahamiyatsiz ekanligini namoyish etdi.[49][83] Ishni tugatgan kelishuvga ko'ra, u o'z ishida sayentologiya usullaridan foydalanmaslikka va bolalarning ota-onalariga sayentologiyaga a'zoligi to'g'risida xabar berishga va'da berdi.[49][83]

Erin Payg'ambarning so'zlariga ko'ra Scientology qo'llanmasi ba'zi nemis kompaniyalari abituriyentlardan ular Scientologmi yoki yo'qligini aniq so'rashgan va cherkovga aloqador bo'lganlarga ish berishdan bosh tortishgan. Payg'ambarning aytishicha, xuddi shunday da'volar Iso Masihning oxirgi avliyolar cherkovi va katolik cherkoviga qarshi qilingan.[84]

Scientology-ni taqiqlash tashabbusi

A seven-story, modern building, predominantly grey and white, with a cross-like symbol and large letters spelling
Berlin Scientology shtab-kvartirasining ochilishida dunyoning turli joylaridan sayentologlar, shu jumladan taniqli shaxslar ishtirok etishdi Anne Archer va Chick Corea.[85]

2007 yil mart oyida Germaniyada Berlindagi yangi Scientology shtab-kvartirasining ochilishiga javoban Germaniya hukumati Scientology-ni kuzatish bo'yicha sa'y-harakatlarini ko'paytirayotgani haqida xabar berilgan edi.[86] 2007 yil 7 dekabrda Germaniya federal va shtat ichki ishlar vazirlari Scientology tashkiloti konstitutsiyaga qarshi maqsadlarni davom ettirib, "inson qadr-qimmati yoki teng muomala huquqi kabi asosiy asosiy va inson huquqlarini" cheklab kelayotgani to'g'risida fikr bildirdi va so'radi. Germaniyaning ichki razvedka agentliklari tashkilotni taqiqlashga qaratilgan mumkin bo'lgan sud tekshiruvi uchun zarur bo'lgan ma'lumotlarni to'plash va baholash uchun.[87][88][89]

Ushbu qadam siyosiy spektrning har tarafidan nemis siyosatchilari tomonidan tanqid qilindi, yuridik ekspertlar va razvedka idoralari tashkilotni taqiqlashga urinish sudlarda muvaffaqiyatsiz bo'lishidan xavotir bildirdi.[87][90][91] Berlindagi Sayentologiya cherkovi prezidenti Sabine Weber ayblovlarni "real bo'lmagan" va "bema'ni" deb atab, Germaniya ichki ishlar vazirlarining bahosi "Scientological adabiyotlarining 500000 sahifasidan bir nechta jumlaga" asoslanganligini aytdi.[89] U yana shunday dedi: "Shuningdek, men Muqaddas Kitobda totalitar mazmundagi yuzlab so'zlarni topishim mumkin, ammo bu men nasroniylikni taqiqlashni talab qilaman degani emas".[89]

A sidewalk, bordered on the left by a modern building featuring the inscription
Afishada Berlin shtab-kvartirasi oldida Scientology xavfidan ogohlantirish; sudlar keyinchalik afishani olib tashlashni buyurdilar.

2008 yil noyabr oyida hukumat Scientology-ni taqiqlash harakatlaridan voz kechdi, chunki noqonuniy yoki konstitutsiyaga zid faoliyatning etarli dalillarini topmadi.[92] Tomonidan hisobot BfV bilim bo'shliqlarini keltirdi va Scientology-ni taqiqlash bo'yicha har qanday qonuniy ishning muvaffaqiyati shubhali bo'lishiga olib keladigan bir nechta fikrlarni ta'kidladi.[44] Birinchidan, BfV hisobotda Scientology-ni xorijiy tashkilot sifatida ko'rish mumkinligi to'g'risida hech qanday dalil yo'qligi aytilgan; nemis cherkovlari va vakolatxonalari, nemislar kengashi, nemis nizomlari mavjud edi va tashkilot AQShdan "butunlay masofadan turib boshqarilgan" degan dalil yo'q edi.[44] Chet el tashkilotini taqiqlash nemis tashkilotiga qaraganda ancha osonroq bo'lar edi.[44][93] Taqiqlashni taklif qilganlar hisoblagan ikkinchi dalil Scientology-ning konstitutsiyaga agressiv qarshi chiqishi edi.[44] Bu erda, hisobotda Scientology-ning xatti-harakatlari Scientology agressiv tarzda Germaniyaning erkin va demokratik asosiy tartibiga qarshi hujum qilish va ag'darishga intilgan deb taxmin qilish uchun hech qanday asos yo'qligi aniqlandi.[44] "Na uning nizomnomalari va na boshqa biron bir so'zlari" "tashkilotning jinoiy maqsadlari bor degan xulosani" qo'llab-quvvatlamadi.[44] The BfV shuningdek, Sayentologiya cherkoviga tibbiyot bilan litsenziyasiz shug'ullanganliklari asosida qarshi harakat qilish uchun asoslar bor yoki yo'qligini ko'rib chiqdilar, ammo sud ushbu mulohazani qabul qilishiga shubha bildirdi.[44]

Commenting on the decision to drop the ban attempt, Ehrhart Körting, Berlin's interior minister, said, "This organization pursues goals – through its writings, its concept and its disrespect for minorities – that we cannot tolerate and that we consider in violation of the constitution. But they put very little of this into practice. The appraisal of the Government at the moment is that [Scientology] is a lousy organization, but it is not an organization that we have to take a hammer to."[94] The Church of Scientology expressed satisfaction with the decision, describing it as the "only one possible".[94] Monitoring of Scientology's activities by the German intelligence services continues.[92]

In February 2009, the Berlin Administrative Court ruled that a poster placed by local city authorities on an reklama ustuni next to a bus stop in front of the Berlin Scientology headquarters, warning passers-by of the potential dangers Scientology activities posed to democracy and individual freedom, should be removed.[44][95][96] The decision was upheld in July 2009 by the Upper Administrative Court of Berlin-Brandenburg, which ruled that the poster violated Scientologists' basic religious rights.[95][97]

Criticism of Germany's stance

Photo of Tom Cruise in 2014.
Tom Kruz is one of several Scientologist artists who have been subject to boykot calls in Germany.[72][98]

The United States media, while generally reporting negatively on Scientology in domestic news, has taken an at least partially supportive stance towards Scientology in relation to Germany.[46] Richard Koen for example, writing in Washington Post, said in 1996: "Scientology might be one weird religion, but the German reaction to it is weirder still – not to mention disturbing."[46][72] Alan Kovell, yozish Nyu-York Tayms, wrote in 1997 that the German response to Scientology – motivated by officials' fear that Scientology "was a totalitarian movement growing, like the Nazi party, from inconsequential beginnings" – was itself redolent of "the Nazi era's authoritarianism".[99]

The U.S. Department of State has repeatedly claimed that Germany's actions constitute government and societal discrimination against minority religious groups and expressed its concerns over the violation of Scientologists' individual rights posed by sect filters.[29][100][101][102] The U.S. Department of State began to include the issue of Scientology in Germany in its annual human rights reports after the 1993 agreement between the Church of Scientology and the U.S. Ichki daromad xizmati, through which Scientology gained the status of a tax-exempt religion in the United States.[36][102] That decision also marked the beginning of more intense lobbying efforts by the Church of Scientology in Washington, using paid lobbyists.[103] The State Department's 1996 human rights report on Germany, released in January 1997, warned that artists and businesses with Scientology connections "may face boycotts and discrimination, sometimes with government approval."[104] Past targets of such actions had included Scientologist actors Tom Kruz va Jon Travolta, as well as jazz pianist Chick Corea.[43][72][98]

Also in January 1997, an open letter to then-Chancellor Helmut Kol appeared, published as a newspaper advertisement in the International Herald Tribune, drawing parallels between the "organized oppression" of Scientologists in Germany and Natsist policies espoused by Germany in the 1930s.[101][105] The letter was conceived and paid for by Hollywood lawyer Bertram maydonlari, whose clients have included Tom Cruise and John Travolta, and was signed by 34 prominent figures in the U.S. entertainment industry, including the top executives of MGM, Warner Bros., Birlamchi, Umumjahon va Sony Pictures Entertainment as well as actors Dastin Xofman va Goldi Xon, direktor Oliver Stoun, yozuvchilar Mario Puzo va Gor Vidal va tok-shou boshlovchisi Larri King.[43][101][106][107] It echoed similar parallels drawn by the Church of Scientology itself, which until then had received scant notice,[46] and was followed by lobbying efforts of Scientology celebrities in Washington.[36][103]

U.S. Department of State spokesman Nikolas Berns rejected the Nazi comparisons in the open letter as "outrageous" and distanced the U.S. government from Nazi comparisons made by the Church of Scientology, saying, "We have criticized the Germans on this, but we aren't going to support the Scientologists' terror tactics against the German government."[43][46] Chancellor Kohl, commenting on the letter, said that those who signed it "don't know a thing about Germany and don't want to know."[43] German officials argued that "the whole fuss was cranked up by the Scientologists to achieve what we won't give them: tax-exempt status as a religion. This is intimidation, pure and simple."[43] Officials explained that precisely because of Germany's Nazi past, Germany took a determined stance against all "radical cults and sects, including right-wing Nazi groups", and not just against Scientology.[43] Kolning Xristian-demokratik ittifoqi party denounced the letter as "absurd" and cited German court rulings stating that Scientology had primarily economic goals and could legitimately be referred to using phrases such as a "contemptuous kartel of oppression".[105]

In February 1997, a United States immigration court judge granted boshpana to a German Scientologist who claimed she would be subject to diniy ta'qiblar uning vatanida.[29] In April 1997, John Travolta met personally with U.S. President Bill Klinton at a conference in Philadelphia.[36][108] Travolta later said Clinton assured him that he would "really love to help" with the "issue over in Germany with Scientology".[36] According to Travolta, Clinton recalled that "he had a roommate years ago who was a Scientologist and had really liked him, and respected his views on it", stating that Scientologists "were given an unfair hand in [Germany] and that he wanted to fix it".[36] In September 1997, John Travolta, Chick Corea and fellow Scientologist Ishoq Xeyz were heard by the Evropada xavfsizlik va hamkorlik bo'yicha komissiya (CSCE, also known as the Helsinki Commission), voicing their complaints about the treatment of Scientologists in Germany, and had a briefing with Amerika Qo'shma Shtatlari milliy xavfsizlik bo'yicha maslahatchisi Sendi Berger, whom Clinton had assigned to be "the administration's Scientology point person".[36] The German ambassador responded with a letter to the CSCE stating that the German government had come to the conclusion that Scientology's "pseudo-scientific courses can seriously jeopardize individuals' mental and physical health and that it exploits its members", adding that "membership can lead to psychological and physical dependency, to financial ruin, and even to suicide. In addition, there are indications that Scientology poses a threat to Germany's basic political principles."[36]

A Birlashgan Millatlar report in April 1998 raised concerns about the violation of individual rights posed by sect filters.[109] However, it rejected the comparison of the treatment of Scientologists with that of Yahudiylar davomida Natsist davr.[109]

In 2000, the German Stern magazine published the results of its investigation of the asylum case.[5] It asserted that several rejection letters which the woman had submitted as part of her asylum application – ostensibly from potential employers who were rejecting her because she was a Scientologist – had in fact been written by fellow Scientologists at her request and that of Scientology's Maxsus ishlar boshqarmasi, and that she was in personal financial trouble and about to go on trial for soliq to'lashdan bo'yin tovlash at the time she applied for asylum.[5] On a 2000 visit to Clearwater, Florida, Ursula Caberta ning Scientology Task Force for the Hamburg Interior Authority likewise alleged that the asylum case had been part of an "orchestrated effort" by Scientology undertaken "for political gain", and "a spectacular abuse of the U.S. system".[110] German expatriate Scientologists resident in Clearwater, in turn, accused Caberta of stoking a "hate campaign" in Germany that had "ruined the lives and fortunes of scores of Scientologists" and maintained that Scientologists had not "exaggerated their plight for political gain in the United States."[110] Mark Ratbun, a (former) top Church of Scientology official, said that although Scientology had not orchestrated the case, "there would have been nothing improper if it had."[110]

In 2003, Joachim Güntner, writing in the Swiss Neue Zürcher Zeitung, deb ta'kidladi Gerxard Besier, a German Christian theologian, director of the Hannah Arendt Institute for Research into Totalitarianism yilda Drezden and recipient of an honorary doctorate from Lund universiteti, Sweden, for his championing of religious freedom, had been pressured to forego publication of his scientific study of Scientology after having found himself the subject of widespread criticism in the German media for advocating a more tolerant attitude towards Scientology.[111][112][113] Güntner concluded that "alarmism" had "triumphed" over science and noted an apparent lack of confidence in Germany's ability to engage in open public discourse on the matter.[111]

The U.S. Department of State's 2012 report on religious freedom in Germany, published in 2013, stated that "The status of the Church of Scientology remains in limbo. The Constitutional Court and various courts at the state level have not explicitly ruled that Scientology is a religion. Government agencies at the federal and state level have rules and procedures that discriminate against Scientology as a group and against its members. Four of the major political parties (the Christian Democratic Union, Christian Social Union, Social Democratic Party, and Free Democratic Party) ban Scientologists from party membership. [...] Scientologists reported instances of governmental discrimination. Although courts at the state and federal level condemned the improper use of so-called 'sect filters' to blacklist and boycott Scientologists, they remained in use in the public sector. 'Sect filters' typically asked potential new employees to confirm in writing that they had no contact with Scientology, did not participate in its training courses, and rejected its doctrines. [...] Catholic and Protestant churches continued to oppose Scientology publically [sic], although press reporting and public reactions to Scientology decreased. Several private organizations issued warnings about after-school study programs run by Scientologists."[114]

Shuningdek qarang

Izohlar

  1. ^ a b Bayerisches Staatsministerium des Innern (2012)
  2. ^ a b Scientology-Fakten
  3. ^ a b v d e f g h men j k l m n Menzenbach & Hippe (2007), 1-2 bet
  4. ^ Barber (1997-01-30)
  5. ^ a b v d e Kent (2001), pp. 3, 12–13 |
  6. ^ Nicolai, Frank (2017-05-03). "Aktuelle Umfrage zeigt: Scientology wird als gefährlich empfunden" [Current survey shows: Scientology is perceived as dangerous]. Humanistischer Pressedienst (nemis tilida). Olingan 2020-07-11.
  7. ^ a b v Richardson (2009), p. 283
  8. ^ a b Palmer (2009), p. 316
  9. ^ Melton (2000), pp. 53–64
  10. ^ Beit-Hallahmi (2003), p. 31
  11. ^ a b v d Kent (1999)
  12. ^ Richardson (2009), pp. 286–288
  13. ^ a b v d e f g h German Embassy, Washington (2001)
  14. ^ a b v d Cieply & Landler (2007-06-30)
  15. ^ a b v d Richardson (2009), p. 289
  16. ^ Lauter (2009-10-28)
  17. ^ Luca (2004), p. 58
  18. ^ a b v d Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (2007-12-07)
  19. ^ a b Berliner Morgenpost (2007-01-15)
  20. ^ Willms (2005), p. 331
  21. ^ Fifka & Sykora (2009), 89-bet
  22. ^ a b Berliner Morgenpost (2007-06-24)
  23. ^ Deutsche Welle (2008-11-21)
  24. ^ Willms (2005), p. 92
  25. ^ Willms (2005), p. 90
  26. ^ Willms (2005), 92-93 betlar
  27. ^ a b v d e f Fifka & Sykora (2009), 65-67 betlar
  28. ^ a b Scherff (2008), 13-14 betlar
  29. ^ a b v d e Frantz (1997-11-08)
  30. ^ a b v d e f g h men j k Seiwert (2004), pp. 85–94
  31. ^ a b Melton (2000), 61-62 bet
  32. ^ Willms (2005), p. 284
  33. ^ Browne (1998), p. 201
  34. ^ Willms (2005), p. 12
  35. ^ Bavarian State Office for the Protection of the Constitution (2009)
  36. ^ a b v d e f g h men j Kent (2002)
  37. ^ a b v d Boyle & Sheen (1997), p. 312-313
  38. ^ a b Brendel (2009-04-03)
  39. ^ a b Fleischhauer (1991-04-01)
  40. ^ a b v d e Kleinhubbert (2006-06-22)
  41. ^ Moore (2008-01-13)
  42. ^ a b v Smee (2008-01-21)
  43. ^ a b v d e f g h men j k Bonfante & van Voorst (1997-02-10)
  44. ^ a b v d e f g h men Fröhlingsdorf & Stark (2008-09-22)
  45. ^ a b Willms (2005), pp. 11–14, 259–260
  46. ^ a b v d e f g h men Schön (2001), pp. 1, 6, 18
  47. ^ a b Hexham (1998)
  48. ^ a b Abendzeitung (2010-04-02)
  49. ^ a b v d e U.S. Department of State (2010-11-17)
  50. ^ Weber (1999), p. 175
  51. ^ Cologne Archdiocese (2003-12-12)
  52. ^ Baden-Württemberg Administrative Court (2003-12-12)
  53. ^ a b v Zacharias (2006)
  54. ^ Federal Administrative Court of Germany (2005-12-15)
  55. ^ a b Walker (1996-11-18)
  56. ^ Kent (2008-04-16)
  57. ^ a b v d e Hering (2004-11-11)
  58. ^ Hendon & Kennedy (1996), p. 445
  59. ^ Berliner Zeitung (2001-12-14)
  60. ^ CESNUR: Berlin Administrative Court press statement (2001-12-13)
  61. ^ Besier & Neumann (2004), p. 213
  62. ^ Berliner Morgenpost (2003-12-05)
  63. ^ a b Der Spiegel (2005-04-27)
  64. ^ a b Eddy (2008-05-06)
  65. ^ a b BBC yangiliklari (1998-04-09)
  66. ^ BBC yangiliklari (1998-06-23)
  67. ^ Hendon & Allman (1998), p. 714
  68. ^ Associated Press (1999-12-01)
  69. ^ a b v d e Shupe & Darnell (2006), p. 231
  70. ^ Devis (1999), p. 453
  71. ^ a b v Tulki (2008), 129-130-betlar
  72. ^ a b v d Cohen (1996-11-15)
  73. ^ a b Haddadin (2000-11-06)
  74. ^ Nordhausen & Billerbeck (2008), 469-470 betlar
  75. ^ Melton (2000), p. 62
  76. ^ a b U.S. Department of State (2009-02-25)
  77. ^ NeuesDeutschland (2010-08-19)
  78. ^ Ad Hoc News (2010-10-20)
  79. ^ Der Spiegel (2006-09-15)
  80. ^ Fokus (1995-10-22)
  81. ^ Fokus (1993-07-19)
  82. ^ Shpigel (2007-03-27)
  83. ^ a b v Abendzeitung (2010-05-19)
  84. ^ Prophet, Erin (2017). "Deconstructing the Scientology 'Monster'". In Lewis, James R.; Hellesoy, Kjersti (eds.). Scientology qo'llanmasi. Zamonaviy din bo'yicha Brill qo'llanmalari. Brill.
  85. ^ Hayot (2007-01-13)
  86. ^ Stark & Rosenbach (2007-03-27)
  87. ^ a b Tagesspiegel (2007-12-08)
  88. ^ German interior ministers' conference resolutions (2007-12-07)
  89. ^ a b v Grieshaber (2007-12-09)
  90. ^ Solms-Laubach (2007-12-07)
  91. ^ Der Spiegel (2007-12-10)
  92. ^ a b CBC News / AP (2008-11-21)
  93. ^ Netzeitung / AP (2007-12-03)
  94. ^ a b Fischer (2008-11-23)
  95. ^ a b Tagesspiegel (2009-07-14)
  96. ^ Berlin Senate's Justice Department (2009-03-02)
  97. ^ Berlin Senate's Justice Department (2009-07-13)
  98. ^ a b Die Zeit (2007-07-09)
  99. ^ Cowell (1997-11-23)
  100. ^ Lehmann (2004), 68-71 bet
  101. ^ a b v Vashington Post (1997-02-01)
  102. ^ a b Frantz (1997-03-09)
  103. ^ a b Dahl (1998-03-29)
  104. ^ Tank (1997-01-30)
  105. ^ a b Schmid (1997-01-15)
  106. ^ Masters (1997-02-10)
  107. ^ Drozdiak (1997-01-14)
  108. ^ Cockburn (1998-04-10)
  109. ^ a b U.S. Department of State (1999)
  110. ^ a b v Tobin (2000-07-26)
  111. ^ a b Güntner (2003-11-24)
  112. ^ Güntner (2004-06-30)
  113. ^ taz (2009-06-16)
  114. ^ U.S. Department of State (2014)

Adabiyotlar

Scholarly sources

Journalistic sources

Government and court documents

Scientology sources

Tashqi havolalar

Scientology sites

German government sites