Inson kapitalining parvozi - Human capital flight

"Miya oqimi" bu erga yo'naltiriladi. Boshqa maqsadlar uchun qarang Miya drenaji (ajralish).
Nazariy fizik Albert Eynshteyn fashistlarning ta'qibidan qutulish uchun Qo'shma Shtatlarga ko'chib kelgan, siyosiy o'zgarishlar natijasida inson kapitalining qochishiga misol bo'la oladi

Inson kapitalining parvozi ga ishora qiladi emigratsiya yoki immigratsiya Uy sharoitida malaka oshirgan shaxslarning. Qabul qiluvchi mamlakat uchun inson kapitali parvozining sof foydalari ba'zan "deb nomlanadimiya yutuqlari"holbuki, jo'natuvchi mamlakat uchun sof xarajatlar ba'zan" deb nomlanadimiya oqishi".[1] Bitiruvchilarning ortiqcha qismini boshdan kechirayotgan kasblarda, chet elda o'qitilgan mutaxassislarning immigratsiyasi og'irlashishi mumkin ishsizlik mahalliy bitiruvchilar,[2] Bitiruvchilarning ko'pligi bo'lgan hududdan emigratsiya qolganlar uchun yaxshi imkoniyatlarga olib keladi. Boshqa tomondan, kasb-hunar yoki bitiruvchilar etishmayotgan hududlar bilan, ko'chish bu hududga nisbatan ko'proq qiyinchiliklarga olib keladi.

Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, inson kapitali parvozining muhojirlarning o'zlari uchun ham, qabul qiluvchi mamlakat uchun ham katta iqtisodiy foydalari bor.[3][4][5][6][7] Ko'plab mamlakatlar iqtisodiyotida bir qator ijobiy va salbiy ta'sirlar mavjud rivojlanayotgan davlatlar malakali ishchi kuchining emigratsiyasini oldini olish uchun strategiyalar ishlab chiqish.[6][7][8] Malakali shaxslarning rivojlangan dunyoga ko'chishi rivojlanayotgan dunyoda katta ta'lim va innovatsiyalarga hissa qo'shishi aniqlandi.[9][10][11][12][13] Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, hijrat, pul o'tkazmalari va qaytish migratsiyasi ijobiy ta'sir ko'rsatishi mumkin demokratlashtirish va kelib chiqqan mamlakatda siyosiy institutlarning sifati.[14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22]

Turlari

Inson kapitali parvozining bir necha turlari mavjud:

  • Tashkiliy: Iste'dodli, ijodiy va yuqori malakali xodimlarning yirik korporatsiyalardan qochib ketishi, bu xodimlar kompaniyaning yo'nalishi va etakchiligini beqaror yoki turg'un deb bilganda va shu bilan o'zlarining shaxsiy va professional ambitsiyalariga javob bera olmaslikda.
  • Geografik: Yuqori o'qitilgan shaxslar va kollej bitiruvchilarining yashash joyidan uchib ketishi.
  • Sanoat: An'anaviy malakali ishchilarning sanoatning bir sektoridan ikkinchisiga harakatlanishi.

Boshqalar singari odamlarning migratsiyasi, ko'pincha ijtimoiy muhit bu aholi siljishining asosiy sababi deb hisoblanadi. Yilda manba mamlakatlar, imkoniyatlarning etishmasligi, siyosiy beqarorlik yoki zulm, iqtisodiy tushkunlik, sog'liq uchun xavf va boshqalar (Durang omillar)[8] inson kapitali parvoziga o'z hissasini qo'shadi mezbon mamlakatlar odatda boy imkoniyatlar, siyosiy barqarorlik va erkinlik, rivojlangan iqtisodiyot va yaxshi yashash sharoitlarini taklif qiladilar (Torting omillar)[8] iste'dodni jalb qiladigan. Shaxsiy darajada oilaviy ta'sirlarni (masalan, chet elda yashovchi qarindoshlar), shuningdek shaxsiy imtiyozlarni, martaba ambitsiyalarini va boshqa turtki beruvchi omillarni hisobga olish mumkin.

Kelib chiqishi va ishlatilishi

"Miya qochishi" atamasi Qirollik jamiyati emigratsiyasini tavsiflash uchun "olimlar va texnologlar "ga Shimoliy Amerika dan urushdan keyingi Evropa.[23] Boshqa bir manbada bu atama Buyuk Britaniyada hindistonlik olimlar va muhandislar oqimini tavsiflash uchun birinchi marta ishlatilganligi ko'rsatilgan.[24] Dastlab bu atama texnologiyani ishchilarni millatni tark etishini nazarda tutgan bo'lsa-da, bu ma'no "ma'lumotli yoki professional odamlarning bir mamlakatdan, iqtisodiy sektordan yoki sohadan boshqasiga, odatda yaxshiroq ish haqi yoki yashash sharoitlari uchun ketishi" ga aylandi.[25]

Miyani tashlab yuborish - bu qolgan aholiga nisbatan ko'proq ma'lumotli (raqamli, savodli) odamlarning katta qismi ko'chib ketadigan hodisa.[26]

"Miya qochishi" atamasi tez-tez pejorativ sifatida ishlatilishini va malakali emigratsiya kelib chiqqan mamlakat uchun zararli ekanligini anglatishini hisobga olsak, ba'zi olimlar ushbu atamani yanada betaraf va ilmiy muqobil atamalar foydasiga ishlatmaslikni tavsiya qiladilar.[27][28]

Ta'sir

Inson kapitali parvozining ijobiy ta'siri ba'zida "miyaning ortishi" deb nomlanadi, salbiy ta'siri esa ba'zan "miyaning oqishi" deb nomlanadi. Miyani tashlab ketish tushunchasi, asosan, ilmiy adabiyotlarda qo'llab-quvvatlanmaydi. Iqtisodchining fikriga ko'ra Maykl Klemens, yuqori malakali emigratsiya cheklovlari kelib chiqish mamlakatlaridagi tanqislikni kamaytirishi ko'rsatilmagan.[29] Rivojlanish bo'yicha iqtisodchi Jastin Sandefurning so'zlariga ko'ra, "u erda hech qanday tadqiqot yo'q ... migratsiya cheklovlari rivojlanishiga hissa qo'shganligi to'g'risida biron bir empirik dalillarni ko'rsatmoqda".[30] Xayn de Xaas, sotsiologiya professori Amsterdam universiteti, miya oqishini "afsona" deb ta'riflaydi.[31][32] Biroq, ko'ra Luvayn universiteti (UCLouvain) iqtisodchisi Frederik Docquier, inson kapitalining parvozi, ba'zi rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlar uchun foydali bo'lishi mumkin bo'lsa ham, aksariyat rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlarga salbiy ta'sir ko'rsatadi.[33] Mamlakat "miya yutug'i" yoki "miya qochishi" ni boshdan kechiradimi, migratsiya tarkibi, rivojlanish darajasi va demografik jihatlar, shu jumladan uning aholisi soni, tili va geografik joylashuvi kabi omillarga bog'liq.[33]

Iqtisodiy ta'sir

Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, migratsiya (ham past, ham yuqori malakali) qabul qiluvchi va eksport qiluvchi mamlakatlar uchun ham foydali.[3][4][34][6] Bir tadqiqotga ko'ra, har ikkala mamlakatda ham farovonlik oshadi: "migratsiyaning kuzatilgan darajasining farovonligi sezilarli darajada, asosiy qabul qiluvchi mamlakatlar uchun taxminan 5% dan 10% gacha va katta miqdordagi pul o'tkazmalari bo'lgan mamlakatlarda taxminan 10% ni tashkil qiladi".[3] Iqtisodchilarning fikriga ko'ra Maykl Klemens va Lant Prathett, "odamlarning kam mahsuldor joylardan yuqori mahsuldorlik joylariga o'tishiga ruxsat berish, qashshoqlikni kamaytirish uchun eng samarali umumlashtirilgan siyosat vositasi bo'lib ko'rinadi".[35] Muvaffaqiyatli ikki yillik joyida Masalan, qashshoqlikka qarshi kurash dasturi kambag'al odamlarga bir yil ichida rivojlangan dunyoda bir kun ishlashga teng keladigan narsani qilishga yordam beradi.[35] Tonganlarga Yangi Zelandiyaga ko'chib o'tishga imkon bergan migratsion lotereya bo'yicha olib borilgan tadqiqotlar natijalariga ko'ra lotereya g'oliblari migratsiyadan tushadigan daromad (Yangi Zelandiyada bir yildan keyin) muvaffaqiyatsiz lotereya ishtirokchilariga nisbatan 263% ga o'sgan.[36] 2017 yilda Qo'shma Shtatlardagi meksikalik immigrant uy xo'jaliklari o'rtasida o'tkazilgan tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatdiki, Qo'shma Shtatlarga ko'chib o'tish evaziga uy xo'jaliklari o'z daromadlarini darhol besh baravarga ko'paytirmoqdalar.[37] Tadqiqot shuni ko'rsatdiki, "migrantlarga tegishli o'rtacha daromad iqtisodiy rivojlanishning eng muvaffaqiyatli dasturlaridan ham ustundir".[37]

Pul o'tkazmalari kelib chiqqan mamlakatda turmush darajasini oshirish. Pul o'tkazmalari ko'plab rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlarda YaIMning katta qismidir,[38][39] va qabul qiluvchi oilalar farovonligini oshirishi ko'rsatilgan.[40] Gaiti bilan bog'liq vaziyatda, OECDda yashovchi 670 ming voyaga etgan gaitiyalik, yiliga har bir migrant uchun uyiga taxminan 1700 dollar yuborgan. Bu Gaitida aholi jon boshiga to'g'ri keladigan YaIMning 670 AQSh dollaridan ikki baravar ko'pdir.[30] Meksikaga pul o'tkazmalari bo'yicha olib borilgan tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatdiki, pul o'tkazmalari Meksikada davlat xizmatlari narxining sezilarli darajada oshishiga olib keladi va ba'zi joylarda hukumat xarajatlaridan oshib ketadi.[41] 2017 yilgi tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatdiki, pul o'tkazmalari tabiiy ofatlardan keyin qashshoqlikni sezilarli darajada engillashtiradi.[42] Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, ko'proq ma'lumotli va yuqori daromadli emigrantlar ko'proq pul o'tkazishadi.[43] Ba'zi tadkikotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, pul o'tkazmalarining ta'siri yuqori emigratsiya oqimiga ega mamlakatlarda qolgan mahalliy aholini yaxshi yashashga imkon berish uchun etarli emas.[3] 2016 yil NBER gazetasi shuni ko'rsatadiki, Italiyadan keyin emigratsiya 2008 yil global moliyaviy inqiroz Italiyadagi siyosiy o'zgarishlarning kamayishi.[44]

Qaytish migratsiyasi rivojlanayotgan davlatlar iqtisodiyotiga ham turtki bo'lishi mumkin, chunki muhojirlar yangi olingan ko'nikmalarni, jamg'armalarni va aktivlarni qaytarib berishadi.[45] Davomida Yugoslaviya qochoqlarini o'rganish Yugoslaviya urushlari 1990-yillarning boshlarida Germaniyada vaqtincha yashashga ruxsat berilgan sobiq Yugoslaviya fuqarolari 1995 yilda uylariga qaytishlarida o'z mamlakatlariga malaka, bilim va texnologiyalarni qaytarib berishgan (keyin Deyton bilan kelishilgan ), yuqori mahsuldorlik va eksport ko'rsatkichlariga olib keladi.[46]

Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, migratsiya yo'lidagi to'siqlarni bartaraf etish jahon YaIMga katta ta'sir ko'rsatishi mumkin va daromadlar 67-147,3% gacha baholanadi.[47][48][49] Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, migratsiya jo'natuvchi va qabul qiluvchi mamlakatlar o'rtasida tovar va xizmatlarning katta savdosiga olib keladi.[50][51][52] Qo'shma Shtatlarga tarixiy migratsiya haqidagi 130 yillik ma'lumotlardan foydalangan holda, bitta tadqiqot "ma'lum bir xorijiy mamlakatdan kelib chiqqan ajdodlari bo'lgan aholi sonining o'rtacha ko'rsatkichga nisbatan ikki baravar ko'payishi, hech bo'lmaganda bitta mahalliy firmaning sarmoya kiritish ehtimoli 4,2 foiz punktga ko'payganligini aniqladi. ushbu mamlakatda va ushbu mamlakatdan to'g'ridan-to'g'ri xorijiy investitsiyalarni qabul qiluvchilarida ishchilar soni 31 foizga ko'payadi, bu ta'sir miqdori mahalliy aholining etnik xilma-xilligi, kelib chiqish mamlakatiga geografik masofa va etno-lingvistik jihatdan ortib boradi. kelib chiqadigan mamlakatni fraktsiyalash. "[53] Emigrantlar sezilarli darajada ko'payishi aniqlandi To'g'ridan-to'g'ri xorijiy investitsiyalar (FDI) o'zlarining kelib chiqish mamlakatlariga qaytib kelishadi.[54][55][56] Tadqiqotlardan biriga ko'ra, umumiy dalillar shuni ko'rsatadiki, emigratsiya rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlarning global iqtisodiyotga qo'shilishiga yordam beradi.[57]

2016 yilda migratsiya va iqtisodiy o'sish bo'yicha adabiyotlarni ko'rib chiqqan holda olib borilgan tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, "migrantlar o'z mamlakatlarini jahon bozoriga qo'shilishiga hissa qo'shadilar, bu ayniqsa muhim bo'lishi mumkin iqtisodiy o'sish rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlarda. "[58] Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, emigratsiya kelib chiqadigan mamlakatda qolganlarning ish haqining oshishiga olib keladi. 2014 yilda mavjud bo'lgan emigratsiya haqidagi adabiyotlarni o'rganish natijasida 10 foiz emigrantlar shok yuborgan mamlakatda ish haqini 2-5,5 foizga oshirishi mumkin.[59] Polshadan emigratsiyani o'rganish shuni ko'rsatadiki, bu qolgan polyaklar uchun yuqori va o'rta malakali ishchilar uchun ish haqining biroz oshishiga olib keldi.[60] 2013 yilgi tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, Sharqiy Evropadan ko'chib ketish 2004 yil Evropa Ittifoqining kengayishi kelib chiqqan mamlakatda qolgan yosh ishchilarning ish haqini 6 foizga oshirdi, ammo bu eski ishchilarning ish haqiga ta'sir ko'rsatmadi.[61] Litva erkaklarining ish haqi Evropa Ittifoqi kengaygandan keyin emigratsiya natijasida oshdi.[62] Qaytish migratsiyasi uy xo'jaliklarining katta daromadlari bilan bog'liq.[63]

2019 yilda o'rganish Siyosiy iqtisod jurnali 19-asr oxiri va 20-asr boshlarida AQShga shved emigratsiyasi ishchilar harakatini kuchaytirdi va chap qanot siyosati va ovoz berish tendentsiyalarini kuchaytirdi.[64] Mualliflarning ta'kidlashicha, hijrat qilish qobiliyati mehnatning savdolashuv pozitsiyasini kuchaytirgan, shuningdek zulmga uchragan bo'lishi mumkin bo'lgan siyosiy dissidentlarga chiqish imkoniyatlarini taqdim etgan.[64]

Ta'lim va innovatsiya

Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, emigratsiya va past migratsiya to'siqlari jo'natuvchi mamlakatlarda inson kapitalini shakllantirish va innovatsiyalarga aniq ijobiy ta'sir ko'rsatadi.[9][10][11][12][13][65] Bu emigratsiya uchun "miya qochishi" o'rniga "miya yutug'i" mavjudligini anglatadi. Bitta tadqiqot shuni ko'rsatadiki, jo'natuvchi mamlakatlar uzoq muddatli malakali ishchilarning ko'chib ketishida bilvosita foyda ko'rishadi, chunki bu malakali ishchilar rivojlangan mamlakatlarda ko'proq yangilik olib borishga qodir, chunki jo'natuvchi mamlakatlar ijobiy sifatida foyda ko'rishlari mumkin. tashqi ko'rinish.[66] Natijada malakali ishchilarning ko'proq emigratsiyasi uzoq muddatli istiqbolda iqtisodiy o'sish va farovonlikning yaxshilanishiga olib keladi.[66] Iqtisodchi Maykl Klemensning so'zlariga ko'ra, yuqori malakali emigratsiya cheklovlari kelib chiqish mamlakatlaridagi tanqislikni kamaytirishi isbotlanmagan.[29]

2017 yilgi hujjatda H-1B viza dasturi tomonidan taqdim etilgan yuqori malakali hindular uchun AQShga ko'chib o'tish imkoniyatlari ajablanarli darajada o'sishiga hissa qo'shganligi aniqlandi. Hindistonning IT-sohasi.[6][67] Qo'shma Shtatlarga ko'chib o'tish uchun ko'proq hindular kompyuter fanlari dasturlariga yozilishdi; ammo, bu hindlarning ko'p qismi hech qachon Qo'shma Shtatlarga ko'chib o'tmagan (H-1B dasturidagi cheklovlar tufayli) yoki vizalari tugagandan so'ng Hindistonga qaytib kelishmagan.[6][67] 2011 yildagi bir tadqiqot shuni ko'rsatadiki, emigratsiya jo'natuvchi mamlakatda innovatsiyalarga turli xil ta'sir ko'rsatmoqda, bu muhim yangiliklar sonini ko'paytirmoqda, ammo o'rtacha ixtirolarning sonini kamaytiradi.[68] 2019 gazetasida Fidjidan emigratsiya Fidjidagi mahorat zaxiralarining aniq o'sishiga olib kelganligi aniqlandi, chunki fuqarolar o'z bilimlarini oshirdilar.[69] 2019 yilgi tahlil shuni ko'rsatdiki, Italiyadan yoshlarning emigratsiyasi innovatsiyalarning pasayishiga olib keldi.[70]

Demokratiya, inson huquqlari va liberal qadriyatlar

Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, emigratsiya, pul o'tkazmalari va qaytib kelgan migratsiya kelib chiqishi mamlakatda siyosiy institutlar va demokratlashtirishga ijobiy ta'sir ko'rsatishi mumkin.[71][72][64][73][74][22][75][76][14] Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, muhojirlarga ta'sir qilish saylov faolligini oshiradi.[77][78] Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, pul o'tkazmalari kelib chiqqan mamlakatda fuqarolar urushi xavfini kamaytirishi mumkin.[79] Migratsiya terrorizmning past darajalariga olib keladi.[80] Liberal gender normalariga ega bo'lgan mamlakatlardan qaytish migratsiyasi liberal gender normalarining o'z mamlakatiga o'tishi bilan bog'liq.[81][82][83] 2009 yilgi tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatdiki, demokratiyada ta'lim olgan chet elliklar o'z mamlakatlarida demokratiyani qo'llab-quvvatlamoqda.[84] Tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatadiki, G'arbda ta'lim olgan rahbarlar o'z mamlakatlarida demokratiyani amalga oshirish istiqbollarini sezilarli darajada yaxshilaydilar.[85][86] 2016 yildagi tadqiqot shuni ko'rsatdiki, Xitoyda tsenzuraga uchragan G'arb ommaviy axborot vositalariga duch kelgan xitoylik muhojirlar o'z hukumatining ommaviy axborot vositalarida yoritilgan masalalar bo'yicha ishlarini ko'proq tanqid qilishdi va rasmiy nutqqa kamroq ishonishdi.[87] 2014 yilgi tadqiqot shuni ko'rsatdiki, pul o'tkazmalari demokratik davlatlarda korruptsiyani kamaytiradi.[88]

2015 yilgi tadqiqotlar shuni ko'rsatdiki, Xitoyning qishloq joylarida ayollarning emigratsiyasi kamayadi o'g'ilning afzalligi.[89]

Tarixiy misollar

Neoplatonik akademiya faylasuflarining parvozi

Keyin Yustinian yopildi Platon akademiyasi Milodiy 529 yilda, tarixchi Agatiasning so'zlariga ko'ra, uning qolgan a'zolari himoyani qidirib topganlar Sosoniylar hukmdor, Xosrau I, o'zlari bilan adabiyot, falsafa va ozgina darajada ilm-fanning qimmatbaho varaqalarini olib yurish. 532 yilda Fors va Vizantiya imperiyalari o'rtasida tuzilgan tinchlik shartnomasi ularning shaxsiy xavfsizligini kafolatlaganidan so'ng, ushbu guruhning ba'zi a'zolari butparastlarning qal'asida muqaddas joy topdilar. Harran, yaqin Edessa. Ushbu guruhning so'nggi etakchi shaxslaridan biri edi Simplicius, o'quvchisi Damaskius, Afina maktabining so'nggi rahbari. Suriyadagi surgun akademiyasining talabalari IX asrda omon qolishgan bo'lishi mumkin, bu O'rta asrlarda Neoplatonistik sharhlash an'analarini qayta tiklashga yordam beradi. Bag'dod.[90]

Yahudiylarni Ispaniyadan haydab chiqarish (XV asr)

Tugaganidan keyin Ispaniyaning katoliklarni qayta zabt etishi, Katolik monarxlari diniy jihatdan bir hil qirollikning maqsadini ko'zlagan. Shunday qilib, Yahudiylar 1492 yilda mamlakatdan chiqarib yuborilgan. Ispaniyaning moliyaviy xizmat ko'rsatish sohasida hukmronlik qilganligi sababli, ularni chiqarib yuborish kelajakdagi iqtisodiy muammolarni keltirib chiqarishda muhim rol o'ynagan, masalan, chet elga ehtiyoj bankirlar kabi Fugger oila va boshqalar Jenova. 1492 yil 7-yanvarda Qirol barcha yahudiylarni Ispaniyadan - Kastiliya va Leon qirolliklaridan (Galisiya, Leon, Eski Kastiliya, Yangi Kastiliya yoki Toledo), Navarra va Aragon (Aragon, Kataloniya knyazligi, Valensiya, Malorka va Ruzilyon qirolliklari va ikkala Sitsiliya). Bungacha qirolicha ularni Andalusiyaning to'rtta shohligidan (Sevilya, Kordova, Xen va Granada) chiqarib yuborgan edi.[91][92] Ularning ketishi Ispaniyaning ayrim mintaqalarida iqtisodiy pasayishga yordam berdi. Shunday qilib, konservativ aristokratiya ushbu yangi egallangan hududlar ustidan o'z hokimiyatini mustahkamladi va ularning tanazzulga uchrashiga hissa qo'shdi.

Gugenotning Frantsiyadan ko'chib o'tishi (17-asr)

1685 yilda, Lui XIV bekor qilingan Nant farmoni va protestantizmni noqonuniy deb e'lon qildi Fonteynboning farmoni. Shundan keyin ko'pchilik Gugenotlar (taxminlar 200,000 dan 1,000,000 gacha[93]) atrofdagi protestant mamlakatlariga qochib ketgan: Angliya, Gollandiya, Shveytsariya, Norvegiya, Daniya va Prussiya - kimning kalvinisti buyuk saylovchisi, Frederik Uilyam, urushda vayron bo'lgan va aholisi kam bo'lgan mamlakatni tiklashga yordam berish uchun ularni kutib oldi. Ko'pchilik Keypdagi (Janubiy Afrika) Gollandiyalik mustamlakaga bordi, u erda ular sharob sanoatini yaratishda muhim rol o'ynadi.[94] Kamida 10000 Irlandiyaga jo'nab ketdi, u erda ular protestantlik ozchiliklariga singib ketishdi plantatsiyalar.

Ko'p gugenotlar va ularning avlodlari obod bo'lishdi. Anri Basnaji de Boval Frantsiyadan qochib, Gollandiyaga joylashdi va u erda nufuzli yozuvchi va tarixchi bo'ldi. Abel Boyer, yana bir taniqli yozuvchi Londonga joylashdi va o'qituvchiga aylandi Britaniya qirol oilasi. Genri Fourdrinier, Angliyada Gugenot ko'chmanchilarining avlodi, zamonaviy qog'oz sanoatiga asos solgan. Augustin Kurtul Angliyaga qochib, Esseksga joylashdi va Britaniyaning ipak sanoatiga asos solgan sulolani o'rnatdi. Shveytsariyalik matematik Gabriel Kramer Jenevada Gugenot qochoqlarida tug'ilgan. Janob Jon Xublon, ning birinchi hokimi Angliya banki, Londonda Gugenot oilasida tug'ilgan. Ishoq Barre, Irlandiyada Gugenot ko'chmanchilarining o'g'li, nufuzli ingliz askari va siyosatchisiga aylandi. Gugenot qochoqlarining avlodlari Gustav va Piter Karl Faberge dunyoga mashhur asos solganlar Faberge mashhur Faberge tuxumlarini ishlab chiqaruvchi Rossiyadagi kompaniya.

Gugenotlarning Frantsiyadan ko'chib o'tishi miya qochqinligini keltirib chiqardi, chunki gugenotlarning nomutanosib soni tadbirkor, hunarmand va mamlakatda texnik kasblar. Ushbu texnik tajribani yo'qotish, shohlik ko'p yillar davomida to'liq tiklanmagan zarba edi.[iqtibos kerak ]

19-asr Sharqiy Evropa migratsiyasi

19-asr o'rtalarida Sharqiy Evropa migratsiyasi diniy omillar ta'sirida sezilarli darajada shakllandi. Ushbu davrda yahudiy ozchilik Rossiya imperiyasida kuchli diskriminatsiyani boshdan kechirdi, bu 1880-yillarning pogrom to'lqinlarida maksimal darajaga etdi. 1880-yillar davomida ikki milliondan ortiq rus yahudiylarining ommaviy ko'chishi boshlandi. Bundan oldin, yahudiylarning yuqori malakali kishilarga xos bo'lgan migratsiya oqimi boshlandi. Bu aniq selektivlikka iqtisodiy rag'bat emas, balki siyosiy ta'qiblar sabab bo'ldi.[26]

Iezuitlarni haydab chiqarish

The Iso Jamiyatini bostirish 1767 yilda Ispaniyada Amerikada Iezuitlar paydo bo'ldi Perudagi uzumzorlar bolmoq kim oshdi savdosi yuqori narxlarda, ammo yangi egalar ishlab chiqarishni pasayishiga hissa qo'shadigan jizvitlar kabi tajribaga ega emas edilar.[95]

1767 yilda Iso Jamiyati bostirilgandan keyin ishlab chiqarish va ahamiyati turmush o'rtoqlar ishlab chiqaradigan hududlar jizvitlar hukmronlik qilgan tanazzul boshlandi.[96][97] Plantsiyalarda hindistonlik ishchilarning haddan tashqari ekspluatatsiyasi bu sohada parchalanishga va missiyalarda yashovchi Guaranilarning tarqalishiga olib keldi.[97][98] Paragvay Iezuitlarning qulashi va tojning noto'g'ri boshqaruvi va Iezuitlar plantatsiyalarini egallab olgan yangi tadbirkorlar raqobatbardosh mavqega ega bo'lishdi. yerba mate. Jizvitlarning plantatsiya tizimi g'alaba qozonmadi va turmush o'rtog'i asosan yovvoyi o'rmondan 18-asrdan 19-asrga qadar yig'ib olinishda davom etdi.[97]

Ikkinchi Jahon Urushigacha Evropada antisemitizm (1933-1943)

Antisemitik 1930 va 1940 yillarda Evropada his-tuyg'ular va qonunlar Holokost, ziyolilarning ko'chib ketishiga sabab bo'ldi. Taniqli misollar:

Yahudiylardan tashqari, fashistlarning ta'qiblari Germaniyadagi liberallar va sotsialistlarga ham taalluqli bo'lib, bu hijratga hissa qo'shdi. Nyu-York shahridagi qochqinlar Surgundagi universitet. Urushgacha matematika va fizika bo'yicha eng samarali tadqiqot markazi nemislar bo'lgan Göttingen universiteti, bu fokus markaziga aylandi Natsist asari bilan ifodalangan "yahudiy fizikasi" ga qarshi kurash Albert Eynshteyn. Keyinchalik nima deb nomlangan 1933 yilgi "katta tozalash", akademiklar haydab chiqarilgan yoki qochib ketgan, natijada AQSh, Kanada va Buyuk Britaniyada. Katta tozalashdan so'ng Malaka oshirish instituti Prinston matematika va fizika bo'yicha etakchi tadqiqot muassasasi rolini o'z zimmasiga oldi.

The Bauhaus, ehtimol, 20-asrning eng muhim san'at va dizayn maktabi davomida yopilishga majbur bo'ldi Natsist fashistlar hisobga olgan liberal va sotsialistik moyilliklari tufayli rejim buzilib ketgan.[iqtibos kerak ] Veymarda maktab siyosiy mavqei tufayli yopilgan edi, ammo yopilishidan oldin Dessauga ko'chib o'tdi. Ushbu tark etishdan so'ng, uchta kashshofdan ikkitasi zamonaviy arxitektura, Mies Van Der Rohe va Valter Gropius, Germaniyadan Amerikaga jo'nab ketdi (shu orada Le Corbusier Frantsiyada qoldi). Ular Evropa zamonaviy harakatini Amerika jamoatchiligiga tanishtirdilar va bu harakatni qo'llab-quvvatladilar Xalqaro uslub arxitektura va dizayn sohasida,[iqtibos kerak ] Amerika universitetlarida dizayn bo'yicha ta'limni o'zgartirishga yordam beradi va keyinchalik me'morlarga ta'sir qiladi.[iqtibos kerak ] 2014 yilda o'tkazilgan tadqiqot Amerika iqtisodiy sharhi AQShdagi nemis yahudiy muhojirlari u erda yangiliklarni kuchaytirganligini aniqladilar.[99]

Ko'pchilik Germaniya tomonidan bosib olingan Evropadan Buyuk Britaniyaga qochib ketgan yahudiylar nashriyot, tibbiyot, ilm-fan, psixoanaliz va boshqa kasblarda muvaffaqiyatli kareralarni o'rnatdi. Taniqli olimlar orasida Maks Peruts, Rudolf Peierls, Frensis Simon, Ernst Boris zanjiri va Xans Adolf Krebs.[100] Ziyolilar orasida san'atshunoslar ham bor Nikolaus Pevsner va Ernst Gombrich, sotsiologlar Norbert Elias va Karl Manxaym va faylasuflar Karl Popper va Lyudvig Vitgenstayn.[100]

Vengriya olimlari 20-asr boshlari va o'rtalarida

Turli xil emigratsiya to'lqinlari paydo bo'ldi.

Birinchi jahon urushidan oldin: Jozef Galamb, T-Ford muhandisi va yaratuvchisi; Evgeniya Farkas, muhandisi va yaratuvchisi Fordson[101] traktor; Filipp Lenard (Nobel mukofoti / fizika)

  • Birinchi va eng katta to'lqin Birinchi Jahon urushi atrofida bo'lgan.
  • 1920 yilda Trianondan keyin Vengriya o'z hududining uchdan ikki qismini yo'qotganda: Mariya Telkes, Istvan Sabo (muhandis / fizik), Xans Selye
  • Ikkinchi jahon urushi va Uchinchi reyx
  • Sovet ishg'oli va 1948 yil atrofida kommunistik ishg'ol, keyin esa 1956 yilgi inqilob

1930-1940 yillarda Vengriya Gollivudda eng ko'p ishlatiladigan uchinchi til edi.

Asosiy maqola: Marsliklar (olimlar)

"Marsliklar" - natsizm yoki kommunizm tufayli Ikkinchi Jahon urushi paytida va undan keyin AQShga qochib ketgan yahudiy millatiga mansub taniqli venger olimlari (asosan, faqat fiziklar va matematiklar). Ular orasida, boshqalar qatorida, Teodor fon Karman, Jon fon Neyman, Pol Halmos, Eugene Wigner, Edvard Telller, Jorj Polya, Jon G. Kemeny va Pol Erdos. Ularning bir nechtasi Budapeshtdan bo'lgan va Amerika ilmiy taraqqiyotida muhim rol o'ynagan (masalan, atom bombasini yaratish). Kommunizm tufayli yana ko'plab odamlar: Vengriya Nobel mukofoti sovrindorlari: György von Békésy, Szent-Dyorgi, Xarsoniy va Xersko va boshqalar yoqadi Viktor Szebehely, Zoltan ko'rfazi, Aleksandr Lamfalussi (iqtisodchi), Mixali Tsikszentmihali (Oqim )

Ikkinchi Jahon Urushidan keyin AQSh va SSSR tomonidan nemis olimlarini yollash

Asosiy maqolalar: Paperclip operatsiyasi, Lusty operatsiyasi va "Osoaviaxim" operatsiyasi

Ikkinchi Jahon urushidan keyingi va keyingi oylarda Amerika va Sovet hukumatlari o'zlarining ilmiy ishlarini davom ettirish uchun AQSh va SSSRga minglab sobiq natsist olimlarini majburan jalb qilishdi va olib ketishdi.

Sharqiy blok ostida Sharqiy Evropa

Berlin devori 1975 yil noyabrda
Asosiy maqolalar: Sharqiy Blokning emigratsiyasi va qochib ketishi va Sharqiy blok

1922 yilga kelib Sovet Ittifoqi cheklovlar qo'ygan edi emigratsiya uning fuqarolarini boshqa mamlakatlarga deyarli imkonsiz.[103] Sovet Bosh vaziri Nikita Xrushchev keyinroq "Biz qo'rqardik, chindan ham qo'rqardik. Biz erimay suv toshqini boshlashidan qo'rqdik, biz uni boshqarolmaymiz va bizni cho'ktirishi mumkin edi. Qanday qilib bizni cho'ktirishi mumkin edi? Sovet daryosi bo'yi va to'lqin to'lqinini yaratdi, bu bizning jamiyatimizning barcha to'siqlari va devorlarini yuvib tashlagan bo'lar edi. "[104] Sovet Ittifoqi Ikkinchi Jahon urushi oxirida Sharqiy Evropani ishg'ol qilganidan so'ng, mamlakatlarning ko'pchiligida Sharqiy blok mustaqillikka intildi va Sovetlarning ketishini xohladi.[105] 1950 yillarning boshlariga kelib, yondashuv Sovet Ittifoqi cheklash uchun emigratsiya qolganlarning aksariyati tomonidan taqlid qilingan Sharqiy blok, shu jumladan Sharqiy Germaniya.[106]

Rasmiy yopilgandan keyin ham Ichki Germaniya chegarasi 1952 yilda,[107] sektorlari orasidagi chegara Sharqiy Berlin va G'arbiy Berlin Chegaraning qolgan qismiga qaraganda ancha qulay bo'lib qoldi, chunki u to'rtta istilochi davlat tomonidan boshqarilardi.[108] Berlin sektori chegarasi asosan Sharqiy Blok fuqarolari hijrat qilishlari mumkin bo'lgan "bo'shliq" edi.[107] Chaqirilgan 3,5 million Sharqiy nemislar Republikfluchtlinge 1961 yilga qadar tark etganlar butun Sharqiy Germaniya aholisining taxminan 20 foizini tashkil etdi.[109] Emigrantlar yosh va yaxshi ma'lumotli bo'lishga moyil bo'lib, Sharqiy Germaniyadagi amaldorlar tomonidan qo'rqib ketadigan miya qochishiga olib keldi.[105] Yuriy Andropov, keyin KPSS Sotsialistik mamlakatlarning kommunistik va ishchi partiyalari bilan aloqalar bo'yicha direktori 1958 yil 28 avgustda Markaziy Qo'mitaga qochqinlar orasida Sharqiy Germaniya ziyolilari sonining 50 foizga ko'payishi to'g'risida shoshilinch xat yozishga qaror qildi.[110] Andropovning so'zlariga ko'ra, Sharqiy Germaniya rahbariyati ular iqtisodiy sabablarga ko'ra ketayotganliklarini aytgan bo'lsa-da, qochqinlarning guvohliklari sabablar moddiy jihatdan ko'proq siyosiy ekanligini ko'rsatmoqda.[110] Uning ta'kidlashicha, "ziyolilarning parvozi ayniqsa muhim bosqichga yetdi".[110] Sharqiy Germaniya partiyasi rahbari bilan ishchi kuchini yo'qotishlarining to'g'ridan-to'g'ri qiymati 7 milliarddan 9 milliard dollargacha baholandi Valter Ulbrixt keyinchalik G'arbiy Germaniya unga 17 milliard dollar kompensatsiya qarzdorligini da'vo qilmoqda, shu jumladan zararni qoplash bilan bir qatorda ishchi kuchini yo'qotish bilan.[109] Bundan tashqari, Sharqiy Germaniyaning yosh aholisini tashlab ketishi 22,5 milliard markadan ko'proq yo'qotilgan ta'lim investitsiyalariga olib kelishi mumkin.[111] 1961 yil avgust oyida Sharqiy Germaniya tikanli simli to'siqni o'rnatdi va oxir-oqibat qurilish ichiga kengaytirildi Berlin devori, bo'shliqni samarali ravishda yopish.[112]

Mintaqalar bo'yicha

Evropa

Evropada inson kapitalining parvozi ikkita aniq tendentsiyaga mos keladi. Birinchisi, yuqori malakali olimlarning chiqib ketishi G'arbiy Evropa asosan Qo'shma Shtatlarga.[113] Ikkinchisi - malakali ishchilarning ko'chishi Markaziy va Janubi-sharqiy Evropa ichida G'arbiy Evropaga EI.[114] Ba'zi mamlakatlarda bu tendentsiya sekinlashishi mumkin,[115][116] Italiya kabi Janubi-Sharqiy Evropaning ayrim mamlakatlari inson kapitali parvozlarining juda yuqori sur'atlariga ega.[117] Evropa Ittifoqi yuqori malakali ishchilarning aniq yo'qotilishini qayd etdi va joriy etdi "ko'k karta" siyosat - amerikaliklarga o'xshaydi yashil karta - bu "kelasi yigirma yil ichida Osiyo, Afrika va Amerikadan qo'shimcha 20 million ishchi jalb qilishga intilmoqda".[118]

Garchi Evropa Ittifoqi keksayib qolgan aholi ta'sirini yumshatish uchun keng immigratsiya zarurligini tushunsa ham,[119] milliy populist siyosiy partiyalar ko'plab Evropa mamlakatlarida immigratsiyani cheklovchi qonunlarni kuchaytirishga chaqirib qo'llab-quvvatladilar.[120] Immigrantlar ham davlat uchun og'irlik, ham ko'paygan kabi ijtimoiy muammolarning sababi sifatida qabul qilinadi jinoyat stavkalari va joriy etilishi katta madaniy farqlar.[121]

G'arbiy Evropa

2006 yilda 250 mingdan ortiq evropaliklar AQShga ko'chib ketishdi (164,285),[122] Avstraliya (40,455),[123] Kanada (37,946)[124] va Yangi Zelandiya (30,262).[125] Germaniya birgina 155,290 kishi mamlakatni tark etganini ko'rdi (garchi asosan Evropa yo'nalishlariga). Bu ishchilar emigratsiyasining eng yuqori ko'rsatkichidir birlashish, va keyingi kursga teng edi Ikkinchi jahon urushi.[126] Portugaliya G'arbiy Evropada inson kapitali bo'yicha eng katta parvozni boshdan kechirdi. Mamlakat malakali aholisining 19,5 foizini yo'qotdi va Avstraliyaga, Kanadaga etkazilgan zararni qoplash uchun etarli malakali muhojirlarni o'zlashtira olmaydi. Shveytsariya, Germaniya va Avstriya.[127]

Markaziy va Sharqiy Evropa

Markaziy va Sharqiy Evropa tashkil etilgandan so'ng, mamlakatlar malakali ishchilarning Irlandiya va Buyuk Britaniyaga keng migratsiyasi to'g'risida xavotir bildirdi Shengen shartnomasi. Litva Masalan, 2003 yildan beri 100000 ga yaqin fuqarosini yo'qotdi, ularning aksariyati yosh va o'qimishli, xususan Irlandiyaga hijrat qilishdi.[iqtibos kerak ] (Irlandiyaning o'zi ilgari AQSh, Buyuk Britaniya va Kanadaga inson kapitalining yuqori darajadagi parvozlarini boshdan kechirgan Seltik yo'lbarsi iqtisodiy dasturlar.) Xuddi shunday hodisa Polshada Yevropa Ittifoqi. Evropa Ittifoqiga a'zolikning birinchi yilida 100,000 polshaliklar Angliyada ishlash uchun ro'yxatdan o'tdilar va taxminan 750,000 polyak millatiga mansub aholiga qo'shildilar.[128] Biroq, Polshada ish haqining tez o'sishi bilan uning tez rivojlanayotgan iqtisodiyoti, ning kuchli qiymati złoty va ishsizlikning kamayishi (2006 yil may oyida 14,2% dan 2008 yil martda 8% gacha kamaydi[129]), Polsha ishchilarining parvozi sekinlashdi.[130] 2008 yilda va 2009 yil boshida qaytib kelganlar soni mamlakatdan chiqib ketayotganlardan ko'p edi. Ammo ko'chish davom etishi mumkin.[131]

Vengriya

Janubi-sharqiy Evropa

Yuqori malakali ishchilarning Janubi-Sharqiy Evropadan tez, ammo kichik hajmda ketishi Evropa Ittifoqida chuqurroq integratsiyani rivojlantirayotgan davlatlar haqida xavotirga sabab bo'ldi.[132] Bu malakali texnik va olimlarni xalqaro loyihalarda ishlash uchun mintaqada qolishga undash orqali chet elga chiqishni to'xtatish dasturlarini keltirib chiqardi.[133]

Serbiya kommunistik tuzum qulashidan inson kapitali parvozini boshidan kechirgan eng yaxshi mamlakatlardan biridir. 1991 yilda odamlar Italiya va Gretsiyaga ko'chishni boshladilar, keyin esa uzoqroqqa, Buyuk Britaniya, Kanada va AQShga borishni boshladilar. So'nggi o'n yil ichida o'qimishli odamlar va mutaxassislar mamlakatni tark etib, boshqa mamlakatlarga ketmoqdalar, ular yaxshi va xavfsiz hayot uchun imkoniyatlarni yaxshilay olishlarini his qildilar. Bu Albaniyani ham tashvishga solmoqda, chunki u o'z malakali ishchilari va mutaxassislarini yo'qotmoqda.

Gretsiya, Irlandiya, Italiya, Portugaliya va Ispaniya

Evropadagi iqtisodiy inqirozdan eng ko'p zarar ko'rgan mamlakatlarning ko'plab fuqarolari ko'chib ketishdi, ularning aksariyati Avstraliya, Braziliya, Germaniya, Buyuk Britaniya, Meksika, Chili, Ekvador, Angola va Argentinaga ko'chib ketishdi.[134][135]

kurka

1960-yillarda ko'plab malakali va o'qimishli odamlar ko'chib ketishdi kurka shu jumladan ko'plab shifokorlar va muhandislar. Ushbu emigratsiya to'lqini siyosiy beqarorlik, shu jumladan 1960 yilgi harbiy to'ntarish. Keyingi o'n yilliklarda, 2000-yillarda ko'plab turkiyalik mutaxassislar ko'chib ketishdi va chet elda tahsil olayotgan talabalar, asosan, yaxshi iqtisodiy imkoniyatlar tufayli chet elda qolishni tanladilar. Ushbu inson kapitalining parvoziga milliy ommaviy axborot vositalari e'tibor qaratildi va 2000 yilda hukumat "miya qochishi" muammosini o'rganish uchun maxsus guruh tuzdi.[136]

Birlashgan Qirollik

Buyuk Britaniyadan boshqa mamlakatlarga, xususan Avstraliya va AQShga ketayotganlar soni juda ko'p.[137]

Tijorat sohalari bundan xavotir bildirdi Brexit miya oqishini keltirib chiqaradigan katta xavf tug'diradi.[138]

Afrika

Afrikadagi mamlakatlar rivojlangan mamlakatlarga ko'chib ketish natijasida juda ko'p ma'lumotli va malakali aholisini yo'qotdilar, bu esa bunday xalqlarning qashshoqlikdan chiqish qobiliyatiga zarar etkazdi. Nigeriya, Keniya va Efiopiya eng ko'p ta'sirlangan deb ishoniladi. Ga ko'ra Birlashgan Millatlar Tashkilotining Taraqqiyot Dasturi, Efiopiya 1980-1991 yillarda 75% malakali ishchi kuchini yo'qotdi.[iqtibos kerak ]

Keyin Janubiy Afrika prezidenti o'rinbosari Tabo Mbeki 1998 yilda aytgan "Afrika Uyg'onish davri "nutq:

"Bizning dunyoda yangi bilimlar avlodi va uning inson holatini o'zgartirish uchun qo'llanilishi insoniyat jamiyatini vahshiylikdan uzoqlashtiradigan vosita hisoblanadi, biz Afrikaning yuz minglab ziyolilarini o'zlarining hijrat qilgan joylaridan qaytarib olishlariga hojat yo'q. G'arbiy Evropa va Shimoliy Amerikada hali ham bizning qirg'og'imizda qolganlarga qo'shilish uchun!

Vashington va Nyu-Yorkdagi afrikalik matematiklar va kompyuter mutaxassislari, afrikalik fiziklar, muhandislar, shifokorlar, biznes menejerlari va iqtisodchilar London va Manchesterdan va Parijdan va Bryusseldan qaytib kelib, Afrika hovuziga qo'shilishlarini orzu qilaman. miya kuchi, Afrikaning muammolari va muammolarini o'rganish va echimlarini topish, Afrika dunyosiga bilimlar eshigini ochish, Afrikaning yangi bilim, ta'lim va ma'lumot ma'lumotlarini tadqiq qilish koinotidagi o'rnini ko'tarish. "

Afrikecruit tomonidan qo'shma tashabbus hisoblanadi NEPAD va Hamdo'stlik ishbilarmonlar kengashi chet elda ishlagandan keyin Afrikaga qaytib ishga joylashish uchun professional chet ellik afrikaliklarni jalb qilish.[139]

Inson kapitali parvozi haqidagi munozaralarning kuchayishiga javoban sog'liqni saqlash xodimlari, ayniqsa, kam daromadli mamlakatlardan ba'zi yuqori daromadli mamlakatlarga, 2010 yilda Jahon Sog'liqni saqlash tashkiloti qabul qildi Xalqaro sog'liqni saqlash xodimlarini jalb qilish bo'yicha global amaliyot kodeksi, shifokorlar, hamshiralar va boshqa sog'liqni saqlash mutaxassislarini axloqiy ravishda xalqaro yollash bo'yicha barcha mamlakatlar uchun siyosat bazasi.

Afrikalik inson kapitalining parvozi ko'plab afrikalik davlatlarda jadal o'sish va rivojlanish va afrikalik o'rta sinfning paydo bo'lishi tufayli o'zini o'zgartira boshladi. 2001 yildan 2010 yilgacha dunyoning eng tez rivojlanayotgan o'nta iqtisodiyotining oltitasi Afrikada edi va 2011-2015 yillarda Afrikaning iqtisodiy o'sishi Osiyodan ustun bo'lishi kutilgan edi. Bu, shuningdek, rivojlangan texnologiyalar, tezroq Internetga ulanish va uyali telefonlar, yuqori ma'lumotli aholi va yangi texnologik startap-kompaniyalar boshqaradigan biznes muhiti kabi texnologiyalarni joriy etish bilan birga Afrikadan ko'plab chet elliklarning o'z uylariga qaytishiga olib keldi. mamlakatda va yana ko'plab afrikaliklar uyda ishlash uchun qolishadi.[140]

Gana

Yosh shifokorlar va hamshiralarning ish haqi va ish sharoitlarini yaxshilashga intilish tendentsiyasi asosan G'arbning yuqori daromadli mamlakatlarida sog'liqni saqlash sohasiga jiddiy ta'sir ko'rsatmoqda Gana. Hozirgi kunda Gana 3600 ga yaqin vrachga ega - bu har 6700 aholiga to'g'ri keladi. Bu Amerika Qo'shma Shtatlaridagi 430 kishiga bitta shifokorga to'g'ri keladi.[141] Mamlakatning ko'plab malakali shifokorlari va hamshiralari Buyuk Britaniya, AQSh, Yamayka va Kanada singari mamlakatlarga ishlash uchun ketishadi. Ma'lumotlarga ko'ra, 1993 yildan 2000 yilgacha mamlakatdagi o'qitilgan tibbiyot xodimlarining 68 foizigacha tark etishgan va Gana rasmiy statistika instituti ma'lumotlariga ko'ra 1999 yildan 2004 yilgacha 448 shifokor yoki ushbu davrda o'qitilganlarning 54 foizi tark etgan. chet elda ishlash.[142]

Janubiy Afrika

Asosiy maqola: Janubiy Afrika iqtisodiyoti § Miya oqimi

Ko'pgina Afrika xalqlari qatori Janubiy Afrika oxiridan beri so'nggi 20 yil ichida inson kapitali parvozini boshdan kechirmoqda aparteid. Bu mintaqaviy iqtisodiyotga zarar etkazishi mumkin deb ishoniladi,[143] va, shubhasiz, mintaqaning qashshoq ko'pchiligining farovonligiga zarar etkazadi, bu esa umidsizlikka bog'liq Sog'liqni saqlash infrastructure because of the HIV/AIDS epidemic.[144] The skills drain in South Africa tends to reflect racial contours exacerbated by Qora iqtisodiy imkoniyatlar policies, and has thus resulted in large Oq Janubiy Afrika chet eldagi jamoalar.[145] The problem is further highlighted by South Africa's request in 2001 of Canada to stop recruiting its doctors and other highly skilled medical personnel.[146]

For the medical sector, the loss of return from investment for all doctors emigrating from South Africa is $1.41bn. The benefit to destination countries is huge: $2.7 billion for the Birlashgan Qirollik alone, without compensation.[147]

More recently, in a case of teskari miya oqishi a net 359,000 highly skilled South Africans returned to South Africa from foreign work assignments over a five-year period from 2008 to 2013. This was catalysed by the global financial crisis of 2007-8 and perceptions of a higher quality of life in South Africa relative to the countries to which they had first emigrated. It is estimated that around 37% of those who returned are professionals such as lawyers, doctors, engineers and accountants.[148]

Yaqin Sharq

Iroq

Davomida Iroq urushi, especially during the early years, the lack of basic services and security fed an outflow of professionals from Iroq that began under Saddam Xuseyn, under whose rule four million Iraqis are believed to have left the country.[149] In particular, the exodus was fed by the violence that plagued Iraq, which by 2006 had seen 89 university professors and senior lecturers killed.[150]

Eron

Asosiy maqola: Eronda miya oqimi

2006 yilda, Xalqaro valyuta fondi tartiblangan Eron "first in brain drain among 61 developing and less developed countries (LDC)"[151][152][153] In the early 1990s, more than 150,000 Iranians emigrated, and an estimated 25% of Iranians with post-secondary education were residing in developed countries of the OECD. 2009 yilda, Xalqaro valyuta fondi reported that 150,000-180,000 Iranians emigrate annually, with up to 62% of Iran's academic elite having emigrated, and that the yearly exodus is equivalent to an annual capital loss of $50 billion.[154] Better possibilities for job markets is thought to be the motivation for absolute majority of the human capital flight while a small few stated their reasons as in search of more social or political freedom.[155][156]

Isroil

Asosiy maqola: Yerida

Isroil has experienced varying levels of emigration throughout its history, with the majority of Israeli expatriates moving to the United States. Currently, some 330,000 native-born Israelis (including 230,000 Israeli Jews) are estimated to be living abroad, while the number of immigrants to Israel who later left is unclear. According to public opinion polls, the main motives for leaving Israel have not been the political and security situation, but include desire for higher living standards, pursuit of work opportunities and/or professional advancement, and higher education. Many Israelis with degrees in scientific or engineering fields have emigrated abroad, largely due to lack of job opportunities. From Israel's establishment in May 1948 to December 2006, about 400,000 doctors and academics left Israel. In 2009, Israel's Council for Higher Education informed the Knesset 's Education Committee that 25% of Israel's academics were living overseas, and that Israel had the highest human capital flight rate in the world. However, an OECD estimate put the highly educated Israeli emigrant rate at 5.3 per 1,000 highly educated Israelis, meaning that Israel actually retains more of its highly educated population than many other developed countries.

In addition, the majority of Israelis who emigrate eventually return after extended periods abroad. In 2007, the Israeli government began a programme to encourage Israelis living abroad to return; since then, the number of returning Israelis has doubled, and in 2010, Israeli expatriates, including academics, researchers, technical professionals, and business managers, began returning in record numbers. The country launched additional programmes to open new opportunities in scientific fields to encourage Israeli scientists and researchers living abroad to return home. These initiatives have since succeeded in luring many Israeli scientists back home.[157][158][159][160][161]

Arab dunyosi

By 2010, the Arab mamlakatlari were experiencing human capital flight, according to reports from the Birlashgan Millatlar va Arab Ligasi.[iqtibos kerak ] About one million Arab experts and specialists were living in developed countries, and the rate of return was extremely low. The reasons for this included attraction to opportunities in technical and scientific fields in the West and an absence of job opportunities in the Arab world, as well as wars and political turmoil that have plagued many Arab nations.[162]

In 2012, human capital flight was showing signs of reversing, with many young students choosing to stay and more individuals from abroad returning. In particular, many young professionals are becoming entrepreneurs and starting their own businesses rather than going abroad to work for companies in Western countries. This was partially a result of the Arab bahori, after which many Arab countries began viewing science as the driving force for development, and as a result stepped up their science programmes. Another reason may be the ongoing global recession.[163][164]

Osiyo Tinch okeani

Indoneziya

While there is no empirical data about human capital flight from Indoneziya, the brain drain phenomena in Indonesia was estimated to reach 5% in Indonesia. The one famous example of brain drain in Indonesia is Indoneziya Aerospace, keyin 1997 yil Osiyo moliyaviy inqirozi, many Indonesian Aerospace workers choose to leave their country to find a better career overseas. As of 2018, there are at least 60 Indonesians graduated from local or overseas universities working at Boeing va Airbus, with half of them holding middle management positions.[165] Keyin 1998 yil may oyida Indoneziyadagi tartibsizliklar, ko'p Xitoy indoneziyaliklar decided to flee to other countries like Singapore, Taiwan, Australia, or United States which also contributes to brain drain within the country

Malayziya

There have been high rates of human capital flight from Malayziya. Major pull factors have included better career opportunities abroad and compensation, while major push factors included corruption, social inequality, educational opportunities, racial inequality such as the government's Bumiputera tasdiqlovchi harakat siyosat. 2011 yildan boshlab, Bernama has reported that there are a million talented Malaysians working overseas.[166] Recently human capital flight has increased in pace: 305,000 Malaysians migrated overseas between March 2008 and August 2009, compared to 140,000 in 2007.[167]Non-Bumiputeras, particularly Malayziya hindulari va Malayziya xitoylari, were over-represented in these statistics. Popular destinations included Singapur, Australia, the United States and the United Kingdom.[168] This is reported to have caused Malaysia's economic growth rate to fall to an average of 4.6% per annum in the 2000s compared to 7.2% in the 1990s.[169]

Filippinlar

Post-colonial Philippines

In 1946, colonialism in the Filippinlar ended with the election of Manuel Roksas.[170] The Philippines' infrastructure and economy had been devastated by Ikkinchi jahon urushi, contributing to serious national health problems and uneven boylikni taqsimlash.[171] As part of reconstruction efforts for the newly independent state, education of nurses was encouraged to combat the low ratio of 1 nurse per 12,000 Filipinos[172] and to help raise national health care standards. However Roxas, having spent his last three years as the secretary of finance and chairman of the National Economic Council and a number of other Filipino companies, was particularly concerned with the country's financial (rather than health) problems.[171] The lack of government funding for rural community clinics and hospitals, as well as low wages, continued to perpetuate low retention rates for nurses in rural areas and slow economic recovery. When the United States relaxed their Immigration Act laws in 1965, labour export emerged as a possible solution for the Philippines.

Labour export from the 1960s onwards

Since the 1960s and 1970s, the Philippines has been the largest supplier of nurses to the United States, in addition to export labour supplied to the UK and Saudi Arabia.[173] In 1965, with a recovering post-WWII economy and facing labour shortages, the United States introduced a new occupational clause to the Immigration Act.[174] The clause encouraged migration of skilled labour into sectors experiencing a shortage,[174] particularly nursing, as well relaxing restrictions on race and origin.[175] This was seen as an opportunity for mass labour exportation by the Philippine government, and was followed by a boom in public and private nursing educational programmes. Seeking access through the Exchange Visitors Program (EVP) sponsored by the US government, workers were encouraged to go abroad to learn more skills and earn higher pay, sending remittance payments back home.[176] As nursing was a highly feminized profession, labour migrants through the beginning of the 1980s were predominantly female and young (25–30 years of age).[177]

Pursuing economic gains through labour migration over infrastructural financing and improvement, the Philippines still faced slow economic growth during the 1970s and 1980s.[178] With continuously rising demand for nurses in the international service sector and overseas, the Philippine government aggressively furthered their educational programmes under Ferdinand Marcos, president at the time. Although complete statistical data are difficult to collect, studies done in the 1970s show 13,500 nurses (or 85% of all Filipino nurses) had left the country to pursue work elsewhere.[179] Additionally, the number of existing public and private nursing school programmes multiplied from a reported 17 nursing schools in 1950, to 140 nursing schools in 1970.[180]

Pul o'tkazmalari

Studies show stark wage discrepancies between the Philippines and developed countries such as the US and the UK. This has led Philippine government officials to note that pul o'tkazmalari sent home may be seen as more economically valuable than pursuit of local work. Around the turn of the 20th century, the average monthly wage of Filipino nurses who remained in their home country was between 550–1000 pesos per month (roughly $70–140 US at that time).[181] In comparison, the average nurse working in the U.S. was receiving $800–400 US per month.[181]

However, scholars have noted that economic disparities in the Philippines have not been eased in the past decades. Although remittance payments account for a large portion of Filipino GDP ($290.5 million US in 1978, increased to $10.7 billion US in 2005),[182] and are therefore regarded as a large economic boost to the state, Filipino unemployment has continued to rise (8.4% in 1990, increased to 12.7% in 2003).[182] Here scholars have begun to look at the culture of nurse migration endorsed by the Philippine state as a contributing factor to the country's economic and health problems.

Migration culture of nursing

The Philippines spent only 3.6% of their GDP on health care and facilities in 2011, ranking them 170th in health spending according to the World Health Organization.[183] The country's health system, particularly in rural areas, has been underfunded, understaffed and lacking advancements in health technologies, causing retention difficulties and poor access to services.[184] However, with reported figures of Filipino nursing graduates reaching 27,000 between 1999 and 2003, and jumping to a total of 26,000 in 2005 alone, there are clear discrepancies between skilled Filipino nurses and availability of health services in the country.[185] Scholars have pointed to the increasing privatisation and commercialization of the nursing industry as a major reason for this loss of skill.[iqtibos kerak ]

Migration has arguably become a "taken-for-granted" aspect of a nursing career, particularly with regard to the culture of migration that has been institutionally perpetuated in the health sector.[186] Most nursing schools have been built since the turn of the century and are concentrated in metro Manila and other provincial cities. Of approximately 460 schools providing bachelor's degrees in nursing,[187] the majority are privately controlled, in part due to the inability of the Philippine government to keep up with rising education demand. However, private schooling has also been a lucrative business, fulfilling the dire need of Philippine labour looking for potential access to higher income.

Education industry

Ga qo'shimcha ravishda Filippinning chet elda ish bilan ta'minlash ma'muriyati (POEA) run by the government that serves as both a source of overseas recruitment agreements and as a marketer of Philippine labour overseas, private nursing schools have acted as migration funnels, expanding enrolment, asserting control over the licensure process, and entering into business agreements with other overseas recruitment agencies.[188] However, retaining qualified instructors and staff has been reported to be as problematic as retaining actual nurses, contributing to low exam pass rates (only 12 of 175 reporting schools had pass rates of 90% or higher in 2005,[189] with an average pass rate of 42% across the country in 2006).[190] Private schools have also begun to control licensure exam review centres, providing extra preparation for international qualification exams at extra cost and with no guarantee of success.[191] It is estimated that between 1999 and 2006, US$700 million was spent on nursing education and licensure review courses by individuals who never took the licensing exams or completed the programming.[191]

Discrepancies in wages between Philippine nurses working at home and those working abroad, as noted above, provide clear economic incentives for nurses to leave the country; however, physicians have also been lured into these promises of wealth through the creation of "Second Course" nursing programs.[192] Studies comparing wages of Philippine nurses at home and abroad from 2005 to 2010, showed at-home nurses receiving US$170 per month, or $2040 per annum, compared to US$3000–4000 per month in the US, or $36,000–48,000 per annum.[193] Philippine physician salaries for those working at home are not much more competitive; they earn on average $300–800 US per month, or $3600–9600 US per annum.[194] Although it is important to note along with such discrepancies that the costs of living are also higher in the US, and that remittance payment transfers back home are not free, there is still evidently a large economic pull to studying as a nurse and migrating overseas.

Push and pull factors, and the lasting effects

The Philippines' colonial and post-WWII history contribute an understanding of the process by which nurses have increasingly turned to migration for greater economic benefits. Discussed in terms of numbers and financial gains, export labour migration has been suggested as a solution to the struggling Philippine economy, with labour transfers and remittance payments seen as beneficial for both countries.[195] However, since in 2004, 80% of all Philippine physicians had taken "second courses" to retrain as nurses, it is suggested that export labour migration is undermining the national health sector of the country.[196]

With physicians and nurses leaving en masse for greater financial promise abroad, the ratio of nurses to patients in the Philippines has worsened from 1 nurse per 15–20 patients in 1990 to 1 nurse per 40–60 patients in 2007.[197] Additionally, the increase in private institution recruitment has evaded government oversight, and arguably has led to lower standards and working conditions for nurses actually working abroad. Once abroad, Philippine nurses have identified discriminatory workplace practices, receiving more night and holiday shifts, as well as more mundane tasks than non-Philippine counterparts.[198] Nurses also discuss the lack of opportunity to train and learn new skills, an enticement that is advertised by the export labour migration system.[199] Homesickness and lack of community integration can also cause emotional duress to migrants, and family separation can have negative effects on both the migrants and their families.

As noted, financial and economic statistics cannot fully describe the complexity of en-masse migration of nurses and physicians. A multitude of elements combine to encourage a culture of migration. The term "brain drain" can be applied to the Philippine situation; however, it is important to note, this does not suggest export labour migration as the primary causal factor of the country's current economic situation. Lack of government funding for healthcare systems, in addition to the export labour migration culture, as well as other local factors, all contribute to what is occurring in the Philippines. It is important to understand the complexity of the nation's socioeconomic history with regard to labour export and government funding in order to determine benefits, costs, and perpetuated problems within the society's infrastructure.

Vetnam

Ga binoan Vetnam yangiliklari, 70% of Vietnamese students abroad did not return to Vetnam. The New York Times tasvirlangan Barak Obama 's remarks at the Young Southeast Asian Leaders Initiative on conditions which cause brain drain as "slyly" describing Vietnam, with corruption, pollution, and poor education.[200][201]

Janubiy Osiyo

Nepal

Every year, 250,000 youth are reported to leave Nepal turli sabablarga ko'ra. They seek opportunity in its various manifestations — higher living standards, employment, better income, education, an alluring western lifestyle, stability and security.[202] This number is expected to rise as a result of a devastating 2015 yil 25 aprelda zilzila.[iqtibos kerak ]

Shri-Lanka

Shri-Lanka has lost a significant portion of its intellectuals, mainly due to Fuqarolar urushi and the resulting uncertainty that prevailed in the country for the thirty-year period prior to the end of the conflict in 2009.[iqtibos kerak ] Most of these sought refuge in countries such as the United States, Australia, Canada, and Great Britain. In recent years, many expatriates have indicated interest in returning to Sri Lanka, but have been deterred by slow economic growth and political instability. Both the government and private organizations are making efforts to encourage professionals to return to Sri Lanka and to retain resident intellectuals and professionals.[iqtibos kerak ]

Sharqiy Osiyo

Xitoy

With rapid GDP growth and a higher degree of openness towards the rest of the world, there has been an upsurge in Chinese emigration to Western countries—particularly the United States, Canada and Australia.[203] China became the biggest worldwide contributor of emigrants in 2007.[iqtibos kerak ] According to the official Chinese media, in 2009, 65,000 Chinese secured immigration or permanent resident status in the United States, 25,000 in Canada and 15,000 in Australia.[203] The largest group of emigrants consists of professionals and experts with a middle-class background,[203] who are the backbone for the development of China. According to a 2007 study, seven out of every ten students who enroll in an overseas university never return to live in their homeland.[204]

Since the beginning of the last century, xalqaro talabalar were sent to different countries to learn advanced skills, and they were expected to return to save the nation from invasion and poverty. While most of these students came back to make a living, there were still those who chose to stay abroad. From the 1950s to the 1970s, China was in a period of widespread upheaval due to political instability. As a result, many Chinese felt upset and disappointed about the situation. The situation did not improve after the gradual liberalization of China during the 1980s; just as many people chose to go abroad, since there were more opportunities overseas. More social upheavals happened with the Tiananmen maydonidagi qirg'in —the result of which was an increasing Xitoy diasporasi. As steady economic growth boosts GDP per capita, more families in China are able to pay for their children to go abroad for study or to live.[iqtibos kerak ]

Avstraliya

Tinch okean orollari

The post-WWII migration trends in the Pacific Islands have essentially followed this pattern[iqtibos kerak ]:

  • Most Pacific island nations that were formerly under UK mandate have had migration outflows to Australia and New Zealand since the decolonisation of the region from the 1960s to the 1990s. There has only been a limited outflow from these islands to Canada and the UK since decolonisation. Fidji, Tonga va Samoa also have had large outflows to the United States.
  • Most Pacific islands administered by France (like Tahiti) have had an outflow to France.
  • Most Pacific islands under some kind of US administration have had outflows to the US, and to a lesser extent, Canada.

Yangi Zelandiya

During the 1990s, 30,000 New Zealanders were emigrating each year. An OECD report released in 2005 revealed that 24.2% of Yangi zelandiyaliklar with a tertiary education were living outside of New Zealand, predominantly in Avstraliya.[205] In 2007, around 24,000 New Zealanders settled in Australia.[206]

During the 2008 election campaign, the National Party campaigned on the ruling Labour Party's inability to keep New Zealanders at home, with a series of billboards announcing "Wave goodbye to higher taxes, not your loved ones".[207] However, four years after the National Party won that election, the exodus to Australia had intensified, surpassing 53,000 per annum in 2012.[208] Bosh Vazir Jon Key aybdor global moliyaviy inqiroz for the continuing drain.[209]

It was estimated in December 2012 that 170,000 New Zealanders had left for Australia since the Key government came to power in late 2008.[210] However, this net migration was reversed soon after, with a net migration gain of 1,933 people achieved in 2016.[211] Economist Paul Bloxham described New Zealand's strong economy, with a housing and construction boom at the time.[212] Australia's weaker economy and reduced investment in mining industries during this time were also mentioned as key factors.

New Zealand enjoys immigration of qualified foreigners, potentially leaving a net gain of skills.[213] Nevertheless, one reason for New Zealand's attempt to target immigration at 1% of its population per year is because of its high rate of emigration, which leaves its migration balance either neutral or slightly positive.

Shimoliy Amerika

Kanada

Colonial administrators in Kanada observed the trend of human capital flight to the United States as early as the 1860s, when it was already clear that a majority of immigrants arriving at Kvebek shahri were en route to destinations in the United States. Alexander C. Buchanan, government agent at Quebec, argued that prospective muhojirlar should be offered free land to remain in Canada. The issue of attracting and keeping the right immigrants has sometimes been central to Canada's immigration history.[214]

In the 1920s, over 20% of university graduating classes in engineering and science were emigrating to the United States. When governments displayed no interest, concerned industrialists formed the Technical Service Council in 1927 to combat the brain drain. As a practical means of doing so, the council operated a placement service that was free to graduates.[iqtibos kerak ]

By 1976, the council had placed over 16,000 men and women. Between 1960 and 1979 over 17,000 engineers and scientists emigrated to the United States. However, the exodus of technically trained Canadians dropped from 27% of graduating classes in 1927 to under 10% in 1951 and 5% in 1967.[iqtibos kerak ]

In Canada today, the idea of a brain drain to the United States is occasionally a domestic political issue. At times, brain drain is used as a justification for daromad solig'i kesishlar. During the 1990s, some alleged a brain drain from Canada to the United States, especially in the dasturiy ta'minot, aerokosmik, Sog'liqni saqlash va o'yin-kulgi industries, due to the perception of higher wages and lower income taxes in the US.[215] Some also suggest that engineers and scientists were also attracted by the greater diversity of jobs and a perceived lack of research funding in Canada.

The evidence suggests that, in the 1990s, Canada did lose some of its homegrown talent to the US.[216] Nevertheless, Canada hedged against these losses by attracting more highly skilled workers from abroad. This allowed the country to realize a net brain gain as more professionals entered Canada than left.[216] Sometimes, the qualifications of these migrants are given no recognition in Canada (see credentialism ), resulting in some - though not all - highly skilled professionals being forced into lower paying service sector jobs.

In the mid-2000s, Canada's resilient economy, strong domestic market, high standard of living, and considerable wage growth across a number of sectors, effectively ended the brain drain debate.[217][218] Canada's economic success even prompted some top US talent to migrate north.[217][218][219][220][221] Anecdotal evidence also suggests that stringent US security measures put in place after 11 September 2001 have helped to temper the brain drain debate in Canada.[222]

Qo'shma Shtatlar

The 2000 United States Aholini ro'yxatga olish led to a special report on domestic worker migration, with a focus on the movement of young, single, college-educated migrants.[223] The data show a trend of such people moving away from the Zang kamari va shimoliy Buyuk tekisliklar region towards the G'arbiy Sohil, AQShning janubi-g'arbiy qismi va Janubi-sharqiy. The largest net influx of young, single, college-educated persons was to the San-Frantsisko ko'rfazi hududi.

Many predominantly rural communities in the Appalaxiya region of the United States have experienced a "brain drain" of young college students migrating to urban areas in and outside of Appalachia for employment, political reasonings, and opportunities offered in urban areas that rural communities are currently unable to.[224][225]

The country as a whole does not experience large-scale human capital flight as compared with other countries, with an emigration rate of only 0.7 per 1,000 educated people,[226] but it is often the destination of skilled workers migrating from elsewhere in the world.[227]

Regarding foreign scholars earning their degrees in the United States and return to their home country, Danielle Guichard-Ashbrook of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology has been quoted as stating "We educate them, but then we don't make it easy for them to stay".[228]

Markaziy va Janubiy Amerika

Kolumbiya

In recent years, many people from younger generations (people born from 1994-onward) have migrated out of Colombia. Many of them are looking for better employment opportunities elsewhere due to the political turmoil that has been going on in the past decades. In many cases, the flight of educated people from Colombia does not occur, due to a lack of economic resources from the people and no governmental support in any extracurricular endeavors (sports or liberal arts). Even though, Colombia has recently implemented programs to benefit people that have higher scores in the ICFES (a national exam mandated for every high schooler in the country before graduation), such as the ICETEX (Instituto Colombiano de Crédito Educativo y Estudios Técnicos en el Exterior) scholarships; many people who score high on these mandate exam end up migrating to other countries for higher education. Some may argue, including those who have scored high in the ICFES, that they are taking the place of someone less fortunate who deserves, wants, and will use an ICETEX scholarship.

Kuba

1997 yilda, Kuba officials claimed that 31,000 Cuban doctors were deployed in 61 countries.[229] A large number practice in South America. In 2007, it was reported that 20,000 were employed in Venesuela in exchange for nearly 100,000 barrels (16,000 m3) kuniga neft.[230]

However, in Venezuela and Boliviya, where another 1,700 doctors work, it is stated that as many as 500 doctors may have fled the missions in the years preceding 2007 into countries nearby.[229] This number increased dramatically, with 1,289 visas being given to Cuban medical professionals in the United States alone in 2014, with the majority of Cuban medical personnel fleeing from Venezuela due to poor social conditions and not receiving adequate payment; the Cuban government allegedly receives the majority of payments while some doctors are left with about $100 per month in earnings.[231]

Venesuela

Asosiy maqola: Venesuela qochqinlari inqirozi

Saylovdan so'ng Ugo Chaves as president and his establishment of the Bolivar inqilobi, millions of Venezuelans emigrated from Venesuela.[232][233][234] In 2009, it was estimated that more than 1 million Venezuelan emigrated since Hugo Chávez became president.[233] It has been calculated that from 1998 to 2013, over 1.5 million Venezuelans, between 4% and 6% of the Venezuela's total population, left the country following the Bolivarian Revolution.[234] Academics and business leaders have stated that emigration from Venezuela increased significantly during the last years of Chávez's presidency and especially during the presidency of Nikolas Maduro.[235]

An analysis of a study by the Venesuela Markaziy universiteti titled "Venezuelan Community Abroad. A New Method of Exile" states that the Venezuelan refugee crisis was caused by the "deterioration of both the economy and the social fabric, rampant crime, uncertainty and lack of hope for a change in leadership in the near future".[232] The Wall Street Journal stated that many "oq yoqalilar Venesuela aholisi mamlakatdagi jinoyatchilikning yuqori darajasidan qochib, inflyatsiya darajasi oshib, kengayib bormoqda statistika nazorati ".[236] Reasons for leaving cited by the former Venezuelan citizens studied included lack of freedom, high levels of insecurity and lack of opportunity in the country.[234][237]

In the "Venezuelan Community Abroad. A New Method of Exile" study, of the more than 1.5 million Venezuelans who had left the country following the Bolivarian Revolution, more than 90% of those who left were college graduates, with 40% holding a Magistrlik darajasi and 12% having a doktorlik or post doctorate.[234][237] Some Venezuelan parents encourage their children to leave the country.[234]

Karib dengizi

Ko'pchilik Karib orollari endure a constant and substantial emigration of qualified workers. Approximately 30% of the labour forces of many islands have left, and more than 80% of college graduates from Surinam, Gaiti, Grenada va Gayana have emigrated, mostly to the United States.[238] Over 80% of Yamaykaliklar with higher education live abroad.[239] However, it is noted that these nationals pay valuable remittances. Yilda Yamayka, the money sent back amounts to 18% of YaMM.[240]

Shuningdek qarang

Adabiyotlar

Iqtiboslar

  1. ^ Baptiste, Nathalie (25 February 2014). "Brain Drain and the Politics of Immigration". Tashqi siyosat diqqat markazida. Siyosiy tadqiqotlar instituti. Olingan 15 iyun 2018. The migration of highly skilled workers can pay dividends for immigrants and their employers, but it produces losers as well.
  2. ^ Birrell, Bob (8 March 2016). "Australia's Skilled Migration Program: Scarce Skills Not Required" (PDF). The Australian Population Research Institute. Monash universiteti. Olingan 15 iyun 2018.
  3. ^ a b v d di Giovanni, Julian; Levchenko, Andrei A.; Ortega, Francesc (1 February 2015). "A Global View of Cross-Border Migration" (PDF). Journal of the European Economic Association. 13 (1): 168–202. doi:10.1111/jeea.12110. hdl:10230/22196. ISSN  1542-4774. S2CID  3465938.
  4. ^ a b Andreas, Willenbockel, Dirk; Sia, Go, Delfin; Amer, Ahmed, S. (11 April 2016). "Global migration revisited : short-term pains, long-term gains, and the potential of south-south migration". Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  5. ^ "The Gain from the Drain - Skill-biased Migration and Global Welfare" (PDF).
  6. ^ a b v d e Khanna, Gaurav; Morales, Nicolas (30 April 2017). "The IT Boom and Other Unintended Consequences of Chasing the American Dream". Rochester, Nyu-York. SSRN  2968147. Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  7. ^ a b Hillel, Rapoport (20 September 2016). "Migration and globalization: what's in it for developing countries?". Xalqaro ishchi kuchi jurnali. 37 (7): 1209–1226. doi:10.1108/IJM-08-2015-0116. hdl:10419/145243. ISSN  0143-7720. S2CID  4931047.
  8. ^ a b v Dodani, Sunita; LaPorte, Ronald E (Nov 2005). "Brain drain from developing countries: how can brain drain be converted into wisdom gain?". J R Soc Med. 98 (11): 487–491. doi:10.1258/jrsm.98.11.487. PMC  1275994. PMID  16260795.
  9. ^ a b Shrestha, Slesh A. (1 April 2016). "No Man Left Behind: Effects of Emigration Prospects on Educational and Labour Outcomes of Non-migrants". Iqtisodiy jurnal. 127 (600): 495–521. doi:10.1111/ecoj.12306. ISSN  1468-0297. S2CID  154362034.
  10. ^ a b Beine, Michel; Docquier, Fréderic; Rapoport, Hillel (1 April 2008). "Brain Drain and Human Capital Formation in Developing Countries: Winners and Losers" (PDF). Iqtisodiy jurnal. 118 (528): 631–652. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0297.2008.02135.x. hdl:2078.1/5768. ISSN  1468-0297. S2CID  28988486.
  11. ^ a b Dinkelman, Taryn; Mariotti, Martine (2016). "The Long-Run Effects of Labor Migration on Human Capital Formation in Communities of Origin" (PDF). American Economic Journal: Amaliy iqtisodiyot. 8 (4): 1–35. doi:10.1257/app.20150405. S2CID  5140105.
  12. ^ a b Batista, Catia; Lacuesta, Aitor; Vicente, Pedro C. (1 January 2012). "Testing the 'brain gain' hypothesis: Micro evidence from Cape Verde". Rivojlanish iqtisodiyoti jurnali. 97 (1): 32–45. doi:10.1016/j.jdeveco.2011.01.005. hdl:10419/44193. S2CID  4489444.
  13. ^ a b "Skilled Emigration and Skill Creation: A quasi-experiment - Working Paper 152". Olingan 2016-07-03.
  14. ^ a b Barsbai, Toman; Rapoport, Hillel; Steinmayr, Andreas; Trebesch, Christoph (2017). "The Effect of Labor Migration on the Diffusion of Democracy: Evidence from a Former Soviet Republic" (PDF). American Economic Journal: Amaliy iqtisodiyot. 9 (3): 36. doi:10.1257/app.20150517. hdl:10419/83491. S2CID  4973898.
  15. ^ Ivlevs, Artjoms; King, Roswitha M. (2017). "Does emigration reduce corruption?". Jamoatchilik tanlovi. 171 (3–4): 389–408. doi:10.1007/s11127-017-0442-z.
  16. ^ "Migration, Political Institutions, and Social Networks in Mozambique".
  17. ^ Lodigiani, Elisabetta (2016). "The effect of emigration on home-country political institutions". IZA World of Labor. doi:10.15185/izawol.307.
  18. ^ Meseguer, C.; Burgess, K. (2014). "International Migration and Home Country Politics". Qiyosiy xalqaro rivojlanish bo'yicha tadqiqotlar. 49 (1): 1–12. doi:10.1007/s12116-014-9149-z. ISSN  1936-6167.
  19. ^ Docquier, Frederik; Lodigiani, Elisabetta; Rapoport, Hillel; Schiff, Maurice. "Emigration and democracy" (PDF). Bar-Ilan universiteti.
  20. ^ Burgess, Katrina (2012). "Migrants, Remittances, and Politics: Loyalty and Voice after Exit" (PDF). Fletcher dunyo ishlari forumi. 36 (1): 43–55.
  21. ^ Ratha, Dilip Mohapatra; Sanket Scheja, Elina (2011). Impact of Migration on Economic and Social Development: A review of evidence and emerging issues (PDF). Migrants may also serve as a channel for democratic attitudes and behaviors...
  22. ^ a b Batista, Catia; Vicente, Pedro C. (1 January 2011). "Do Migrants Improve Governance at Home? Evidence from a Voting Experiment". Jahon bankining iqtisodiy sharhi. 25 (1): 77–104. doi:10.1093/wber/lhr009. hdl:10419/36182. ISSN  0258-6770. S2CID  1813461.
  23. ^ Cervantes, Mario; Guellec, Dominique (January 2002). "The brain drain: Old myths, new realities". OECD Observer. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  24. ^ Joel Spring. Globalization of Education: an introduction. First published 2009, by Routledge, 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016, pp185
  25. ^ "Brain drain - Definition and More", Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary, 2010, web: MW-b.
  26. ^ a b Yvonne Stolz and Joerg Baten "Brain Drain, Numeracy and Skill Premia during the Era of Mass Migration: Testing the Roy-Borjas Model"
  27. ^ Clemens, Michael (2015). "CSAE Conference 2015 Plenary 3: Migration and Labour Mobility". Starts at 19:35.
  28. ^ Klemens, Maykl. "Why It's Time to Drop the 'Brain Drain' Refrain". Olingan 2015-09-19.
  29. ^ a b Clemens, Michael (2015). "Smart policy toward high-skill emigrants". IZA World of Labor. doi:10.15185/izawol.203.
  30. ^ a b "Migration and Development: Who Bears the Burden of Proof? Justin Sandefur replies to Paul Collier | From Poverty to Power". oxfamblogs.org. Olingan 2016-07-03.
  31. ^ de Xaas, Xayn (2017 yil 21 mart). "Migratsiya haqidagi afsonalar: biz noto'g'ri deb bilgan narsalarning aksariyati". Der Spiegel. Olingan 29 fevral 2020.
  32. ^ de Xaas, Xayn (2005 yil 1-noyabr). "Xalqaro migratsiya, pul o'tkazmalari va rivojlanish: afsonalar va faktlar". Uchinchi dunyo chorakligi. 26 (8): 1269–1284. CiteSeerX  10.1.1.371.1384. doi:10.1080/01436590500336757. ISSN  0143-6597.
  33. ^ a b Docquier, Frederik (2014 yil 1-may). "Rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlardan miya qochishi". IZA World of Labor. doi:10.15185 / izawol.31.
  34. ^ "Drenajdan yutuq - ko'nikmaga asoslangan migratsiya va global farovonlik" (PDF).
  35. ^ a b Klemens, Maykl A.; Pritset, Lant (2016 yil fevral). "Migratsiyani cheklash bo'yicha yangi iqtisodiy holat: baholash". 9730-sonli IZA muhokamasi. SSRN  2731993.
  36. ^ MakKenzi, Devid; Stillman, Stiven; Gibson, Jon (2010 yil 1-iyun). "Tanlash qanchalik muhim? Eksperimental va boshqalar. Migratsiyadan olingan daromadlarni eksperimental choralari" (PDF). Evropa iqtisodiy assotsiatsiyasi jurnali. 8 (4): 913–945. doi:10.1111 / j.1542-4774.2010.tb00544.x. hdl:10289/1638. ISSN  1542-4774. S2CID  14629302.
  37. ^ a b Gove, Maykl (2017 yil 18-aprel). "Migratsiya taraqqiyoti sifatida: Uy xo'jaliklari o'rtasida o'tkazilgan muhojirlarning ish haqi bo'yicha dalillari". Ijtimoiy ko'rsatkichlarni tadqiq qilish. 137 (3): 1033–1060. doi:10.1007 / s11205-017-1630-4. ISSN  0303-8300. S2CID  157541486.
  38. ^ Rata, Dilip; Silwal (2012). "2011 yilda pul o'tkazmalari oqimi" (PDF). Migratsiya va rivojlanish haqida qisqacha ma'lumot - Jahon banki Migratsiya va pul o'tkazmalari bo'limi. 18: 1–3.
  39. ^ "Pul o'tkazmalari bo'yicha global qo'llanma". Migrasiyapolicy.org. 2013 yil 31-iyul. Olingan 2016-06-06.
  40. ^ Mergo, Teferi (2016 yil 1-avgust). "Xalqaro migratsiyaning migrant manbali uy xo'jaliklariga ta'siri: Efiopiya xilma-xilligi-Visa lotereyasi migrantlari dalillari". Jahon taraqqiyoti. 84: 69–81. doi:10.1016 / j.worlddev.2016.04.001.
  41. ^ Adida, Kler L.; Girod, Desha M. (2011 yil 1-yanvar). "Muhojirlar o'z shaharlarini obod qilyaptimi? 1995-2000 yillarda Meksikada pul o'tkazmalari va davlat xizmatlaridan foydalanish". Qiyosiy siyosiy tadqiqotlar. 44 (1): 3–27. doi:10.1177/0010414010381073. ISSN  0010-4140. S2CID  154767019.
  42. ^ Mbaye, Linguer Mous; Drabo, Alassane (2017 yil 1-dekabr). "Tabiiy ofatlar va qashshoqlikni kamaytirish: pul o'tkazmalari muhimmi?". CESifo iqtisodiy tadqiqotlar. 63 (4): 481–499. doi:10.1093 / cesifo / ifx016. ISSN  1610-241X.
  43. ^ Bollard, Albert; MakKenzi, Devid; Morten, Melani; Rapoport, Xill (2011 yil 1-yanvar). "Pul o'tkazmalari va miyani to'kib tashlash jarayoni qayta ko'rib chiqildi: ko'proq ma'lumotli migrantlar ko'proq pul jo'natayotganligini ko'rsatuvchi mikrodata". Jahon bankining iqtisodiy sharhi. 25 (1): 132–156. doi:10.1093 / wber / lhr013. hdl:10419/36282. S2CID  52261006.
  44. ^ Anelli, Massimo; Peri, Jovanni (2017). "Emigratsiya siyosiy o'zgarishlarni kechiktiradimi? Buyuk turg'unlik davrida Italiyadan olingan dalillar". Iqtisodiy siyosat. 32 (91): 551–596. doi:10.1093 / epolic / eix006.
  45. ^ Vahba, Jeklin (2015 yil 1-fevral). "Rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlarga qaytib kelgan migratsiya kimga foyda keltiradi?". IZA World of Labor. doi:10.15185 / izawol.123.
  46. ^ "Migratsiya va mojarodan keyin tiklanish: Qochqinlarni qaytarib yuborishning eksport ko'rsatkichlariga sobiq Yugoslaviya". iza.org. Olingan 2019-06-24.
  47. ^ Iregui, Ana Mariya (2003 yil 1-yanvar). "Mehnat harakatchanligi bo'yicha global cheklovlarni bekor qilishdan samaradorlik ortadi: ko'p mintaqali CGE modeli yordamida tahlil qilish". Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  48. ^ Klemens, Maykl A (2011 yil 1-avgust). "Iqtisodiyot va emigratsiya: trotuarda trillion dollarlik qonun loyihalari?". Iqtisodiy istiqbollar jurnali. 25 (3): 83–106. doi:10.1257 / jep.25.3.83. ISSN  0895-3309. S2CID  59507836.
  49. ^ Xemilton, B .; Whalley, J. (1984 yil 1-fevral). "Mehnat harakatchanligini global cheklashlarning samaradorligi va taqsimot oqibatlari: hisob-kitoblar va siyosatning ta'siri". Rivojlanish iqtisodiyoti jurnali. 14 (1–2): 61–75. doi:10.1016/0304-3878(84)90043-9. ISSN  0304-3878. PMID  12266702.
  50. ^ Aner, Emili; Graneli, Anna; Lodefolk, Magnus (2015 yil 14 oktyabr). "Odamlarning transchegaraviy harakati savdoni rag'batlantiradi". VoxEU.org. Iqtisodiy siyosatni o'rganish markazi. Olingan 19 oktyabr 2015.
  51. ^ Bratti, Massimiliano; Benediktis, Luka De; Santoni, Janluka (2014 yil 18-aprel). "Immigrantlarning savdo-sotiqga ta'siri to'g'risida" (PDF). Jahon iqtisodiyoti sharhi. 150 (3): 557–594. doi:10.1007 / s10290-014-0191-8. hdl:11393/195448. ISSN  1610-2878. S2CID  4981719.
  52. ^ Fuli, C. Fritz; Kerr, Uilyam R. (2013). "Etnik innovatsiya va AQShning ko'p millatli faoliyati". Menejment fanlari. 59 (7): 1529–1544. CiteSeerX  10.1.1.361.36. doi:10.1287 / mnsc.1120.1684. S2CID  7275466.
  53. ^ Burchardi, Konrad B.; Chaney, Tomas; Hassan, Tarek A. (2016 yil yanvar). "Migrantlar, ajdodlar va sarmoyalar". NBER ishchi hujjati № 21847. doi:10.3386 / w21847.
  54. ^ Javorcik, Beata S.; O'zden, Chaglar; Spatareanu, Mariana; Neagu, Kristina (2011 yil 1-yanvar). "Migrant tarmoqlari va to'g'ridan-to'g'ri xorijiy investitsiyalar". Rivojlanish iqtisodiyoti jurnali. 94 (2): 231–241. CiteSeerX  10.1.1.319.9420. doi:10.1016 / j.jdeveco.2010.01.012. S2CID  17934565.
  55. ^ Tong, Sara Y. (2005 yil 1-noyabr). "Xorijiy investitsiyalarning etnik tarmoqlari va institutsional rivojlanish ta'siri". Rivojlanish iqtisodiyotining sharhi. 9 (4): 563–580. doi:10.1111 / j.1467-9361.2005.00294.x. ISSN  1467-9361. S2CID  154262328.
  56. ^ Kugler, Moris; Levintal, Oren; Rapoport, Xill (2017). "Migratsiya va transchegaraviy moliyaviy oqimlar" (PDF). Jahon bankining iqtisodiy sharhi. 32: 148–162. doi:10.1093 / wber / lhx007. hdl:10986/32169.
  57. ^ "Migratsiya va globallashuv: rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlar uchun bu nimani anglatadi?" (PDF).
  58. ^ Xill Rapoport (2016 yil 20 sentyabr). "Migratsiya va globallashuv: rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlar uchun bu nimani anglatadi?". Xalqaro ishchi kuchi jurnali. 37 (7): 1209–1226. doi:10.1108 / IJM-08-2015-0116. hdl:10419/145243. ISSN  0143-7720. S2CID  4931047.
  59. ^ "Manba mamlakatlarida emigratsiya va ish haqi: empirik adabiyotlar bo'yicha so'rov". Migratsiya va iqtisodiy rivojlanish bo'yicha xalqaro qo'llanma. Olingan 2016-01-25 - elgaronline.com orqali.
  60. ^ Dustmann, nasroniy; Frattini, Tommaso; Rosso, Anna (2015 yil 1-aprel). "Polshadan emigratsiyaning Polsha maoshiga ta'siri" (PDF). Skandinaviya iqtisodiyot jurnali. 117 (2): 522–564. doi:10.1111 / sjoe.12102. ISSN  1467-9442. S2CID  7253614.
  61. ^ Elsner, Benjamin (2013 yil 1 sentyabr). "Emigratsiya va ish haqi: Evropa Ittifoqining kengayishi bo'yicha tajriba" (PDF). Xalqaro iqtisodiyot jurnali. 91 (1): 154–163. doi:10.1016 / j.jinteco.2013.06.002. hdl:10419/48716.
  62. ^ Elsner, Benjamin (2012 yil 10-noyabr). "Muhojirlik fuqarolarga foyda keltiradimi? Evropa Ittifoqining kengayishidan dalillar". Aholi iqtisodiyoti jurnali. 26 (2): 531–553. doi:10.1007 / s00148-012-0452-6. hdl:10419/67322. ISSN  0933-1433. S2CID  155884602.
  63. ^ "Qaytgan migratsiyaning Misr uy xo'jaliklarining daromadlariga ta'siri".
  64. ^ a b v Qoradja, Mounir; Prawitz, Erik (2018-11-14). "Chiqish, ovoz va siyosiy o'zgarishlar: Shvetsiyaning AQShga ommaviy migratsiyasidan dalillar" (PDF). Siyosiy iqtisod jurnali. 127 (4): 1864–1925. doi:10.1086/701682. hdl:10419/183466. ISSN  0022-3808.
  65. ^ Laurentsyeva, Nadzeya; Gizing, Yvonne; Fackler, Tomas (2018). "Bilim pul o'tkazmalari: Emigratsiya innovatsiyalarni kuchaytiradimi?". Rochester, Nyu-York. SSRN  3338774. Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  66. ^ a b Xu, Rui (mart 2016). "Yuqori malakali migratsiya va global innovatsiyalar" (PDF). SIEPR muhokamasi № 16-016.
  67. ^ a b "H-1B vizasini Hindistonning miyasidan qochib ketishida ayblashni bas qiling - aslida buning aksi bo'ldi". Kvarts. Olingan 2017-06-03.
  68. ^ Agrawal, Ajay; Kapur, Devesh; McHale, Jon; Oettl, Aleksandr (2011 yil 1-yanvar). "Miya oqimi yoki miya banki? Malakali emigratsiyaning kambag'al mamlakatlarning innovatsiyalariga ta'siri" (PDF). Shahar iqtisodiyoti jurnali. 69 (1): 43–55. doi:10.1016 / j.jue.2010.06.003. S2CID  12708566.
  69. ^ "Chiqish imkoniyatlari bo'yicha inson kapitaliga investitsiyalar: tabiiy kvaziy eksperimentdan olingan dalillar - ishchi hujjat 152". Global Taraqqiyot Markazi. Olingan 2019-03-12.
  70. ^ Anelli, Massimo; Basso, Gaetano; Ippediko, Juzeppe; Peri, Jovanni (2019). "Yoshlarning drenajlanishi, tadbirkorlik va innovatsiyalar". doi:10.3386 / w26055. S2CID  199299212. Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  71. ^ Docquier, Frederik; Lodigiani, Elisabetta; Rapoport, Xill; Schiff, Maurice (2016 yil 1-may). "Emigratsiya va demokratiya" (PDF). Rivojlanish iqtisodiyoti jurnali. 120: 209–223. doi:10.1016 / j.jdeveco.2015.12.001. S2CID  15380816.
  72. ^ Eskriba-Folch, Abel; Meseguer, Kovadonga; Rayt, Jozef (2015 yil 1 sentyabr). "Pul o'tkazmalari va demokratlashtirish" (PDF). Xalqaro tadqiqotlar chorakda. 59 (3): 571–586. doi:10.1111 / isqu.12180. ISSN  1468-2478.
  73. ^ Tuccio, Michele; Vahba, Jeklin; Xamduch, Bachir (2016 yil 1-yanvar). "Xalqaro migratsiya: siyosiy va ijtimoiy o'zgarishlarning haydovchisi?". Mehnatni o'rganish instituti (IZA). Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  74. ^ "Mozambikdagi migratsiya, siyosiy institutlar va ijtimoiy tarmoqlar".
  75. ^ Pfutze, Tobias (2014 yil 1-iyun). "Ijtimoiy ta'limga qarshi klientelizm: xalqaro migratsiyaning saylovga ta'siri". Xalqaro tadqiqotlar chorakda. 58 (2): 295–307. doi:10.1111 / isqu.12072. ISSN  1468-2478.
  76. ^ Beyn, Mishel; Sekkat, Xolid (2013 yil 19-iyun). "Malakali migratsiya va institutsional normalarni o'tkazish". IZA Migratsiya jurnali. 2 (1): 9. doi:10.1186/2193-9039-2-9. ISSN  2193-9039.
  77. ^ Chauvet, Liza; Mercier, Marion (2014 yil 1-avgust). "Qaytib kelgan migrantlar siyosiy me'yorlarni kelib chiqish mamlakatlariga o'tkazadimi? Malidan dalillar". Qiyosiy iqtisodiyot jurnali. 42 (3): 630–651. doi:10.1016 / j.jce.2014.01.001.
  78. ^ Peres-Armendarez, Klarisa; Crow, David (2010 yil 1-yanvar). "Migrantlar demokratiyani kechiradimi? Xalqaro migratsiya, siyosiy e'tiqod va Meksikadagi xatti-harakatlar". Qiyosiy siyosiy tadqiqotlar. 43 (1): 119–148. doi:10.1177/0010414009331733. ISSN  0010-4140. S2CID  154333341.
  79. ^ Regan, Patrik M.; Frank, Richard V. (2014 yil 1-noyabr). "Migrantlarning pul o'tkazmalari va fuqarolar urushining boshlanishi". Konfliktlarni boshqarish va tinchlik haqidagi fan. 31 (5): 502–520. doi:10.1177/0738894213520369. ISSN  0738-8942. S2CID  154500219.
  80. ^ Bove, Vinchenso; Bohmelt, Tobias (2016 yil 11-fevral). "Immigratsiya terrorizmni qo'zg'atadimi?" (PDF). Siyosat jurnali. 78 (2): 572–588. doi:10.1086/684679. ISSN  0022-3816.
  81. ^ Tuccio, Michele; Vahba, Jeklin (2015 yil 4 sentyabr). "Uydan chiqishga ruxsat olsam bo'ladimi? Qaytish migratsiyasi va gender normalarini o'tkazish". Rochester, NY: Ijtimoiy fanlarni tadqiq qilish tarmog'i. SSRN  2655237. Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  82. ^ Lodigiani, Elisabetta; Salomone, Sara (2015 yil 23-iyun). "Migratsiya bilan bog'liq normalarni o'tkazish. Ayollarning siyosiy vakolatlarini oshirish masalasi". Rochester, NY: Ijtimoiy fanlarni tadqiq qilish tarmog'i. SSRN  2622394. Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  83. ^ Ferrant, Gall; Tuccio, Michele (2015 yil 1-avgust). "Janubiy-janubiy migratsiya va ijtimoiy muassasalarda ayollarga nisbatan kamsitish: ikki tomonlama munosabatlar". Jahon taraqqiyoti. 72: 240–254. doi:10.1016 / j.worlddev.2015.03.002.
  84. ^ Spilimbergo, Antonio (2009 yil 1 mart). "Demokratiya va chet el ta'limi". Amerika iqtisodiy sharhi. 99 (1): 528–543. CiteSeerX  10.1.1.372.3312. doi:10.1257 / aer.99.1.528. ISSN  0002-8282.
  85. ^ Sovg'a, Tomas; Krcmaric, Daniel (2015 yil 31-iyul). "Kim demokratlashtirmoqda? G'arbda o'qigan rahbarlar va rejimning o'tishlari". Nizolarni hal qilish jurnali. 61 (3): 0022002715590878. doi:10.1177/0022002715590878. ISSN  0022-0027. S2CID  156073540.
  86. ^ Mercier, Marion (2016 yil 1-sentyabr). "Ajablanarlisi o'g'lining qaytishi: Qaytgan migrantlar yaxshi rahbarlarni etishtiradimi?". Rivojlanish iqtisodiyoti jurnali. 122: 76–91. CiteSeerX  10.1.1.646.5019. doi:10.1016 / j.jdeveco.2016.04.005. S2CID  31029361.
  87. ^ Tai, Tsuuqing (2016 yil 2-yanvar). "G'arb ommaviy axborot vositalarining fosh etilishi va xitoylik muhojirlarning siyosiy tushunchalari". Siyosiy aloqa. 33 (1): 78–97. doi:10.1080/10584609.2014.978921. ISSN  1058-4609. S2CID  147034160.
  88. ^ Tyburski, Maykl D. (2014 yil 1-iyul). "Lanatmi yoki davo? Migrantlar pul o'tkazmalari va korruptsiya". Siyosat jurnali. 76 (3): 814–824. doi:10.1017 / S0022381614000279. ISSN  0022-3816.
  89. ^ Lu, Yao; Tao, Ran (2015 yil 4 mart). "Xitoyning qishloq joylarida ayollarning migratsiyasi, madaniy konteksti va o'g'il bolalarning afzalligi". Aholini o'rganish va siyosatni ko'rib chiqish. 34 (5): 665–686. doi:10.1007 / s11113-015-9357-x. ISSN  0167-5923. S2CID  154873054.
  90. ^ Richard Sorabji, (2005), Miloddan 200-600 yilgacha sharhlovchilar falsafasi: psixologiya (axloq va din bilan), sahifa 11. Kornell universiteti matbuoti
  91. ^ "Ispaniyadan surgun qilish, milodiy 1492 y.". Yahudiylarning tarixiy manbalari. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  92. ^ "Ispaniya qirolliklari 1492". www.themaparchive.com. Olingan 2019-08-23.
  93. ^ Britannica entsiklopediyasi, 11-nashr, Frank Puaux, Gugenot
  94. ^ "Franschhoek - Keyptaun sharob mintaqasi". Cape-town.info. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  95. ^ Lakoste, Pablo (2004). "La vid y el vino en America del Sur: el desplazamiento de los polos vitivinícolas (siglos XVI al XX)". Universum (ispan tilida). 19 (2): 62–93. doi:10.4067 / S0718-23762004000200005.
  96. ^ Ernesto Daumas. 1930. El problema de la yerba mate. Buenos-Ayres, Compañia Impresora Argentina.
  97. ^ a b v Ross V. Jeymison. Tovarlanish mohiyati: zamonaviy dunyoda kofeinga bog'liqlik. Ijtimoiy tarix jurnali, 2001 yil qish. Iqtibos: [1]
  98. ^ Folch, Kristin. Iste'molni rag'batlantirish: Fathdan tortib to hozirgi kungacha bo'lgan afsonalar, bozorlar va ma'nolar. Jamiyat va tarixni qiyosiy o'rganish jamiyati, 2010 yil.
  99. ^ Mozer, Petra; Voena, Alessandra; Waldinger, Fabian (2014). "Germaniyalik yahudiy muhojirlari va AQSh ixtirosi" (PDF). Amerika iqtisodiy sharhi. 104 (10): 3222–3255. doi:10.1257 / aer.104.10.3222.
  100. ^ a b "Kontinental inglizlar: natsist Evropadan kelgan yahudiy qochqinlari" (PDF). Yahudiy qochqinlar uyushmasi. 2002. 16-bet, 19. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi (PDF) 2012 yil 14 aprelda. Olingan 1 iyul 2017.
  101. ^ http://ceautoclassic.eu/the-110-year-old-ford-model-t-and-the-hungarians-who-made-it-a-success/
  102. ^ Tsaba Horvat (kimyo muhandisi)
  103. ^ Dowty 1989 yil, p. 69
  104. ^ Dowty 1989 yil, p. 74
  105. ^ a b Thackeray 2004 yil, p. 188
  106. ^ Dowty 1989 yil, p. 114
  107. ^ a b Harrison 2003 yil, p. 99
  108. ^ Dowty 1989 yil, p. 121 2
  109. ^ a b Dowty 1989 yil, p. 122
  110. ^ a b v Harrison 2003 yil, p. 100
  111. ^ Volker Rolf Bergaxn, Zamonaviy Germaniya: yigirmanchi asrda jamiyat, iqtisodiyot va siyosat, p. 227. Kembrij universiteti matbuoti, 1987 yil
  112. ^ Pearson 1998 yil, p. 75
  113. ^ Jeff, Chu (2004 yil 11 yanvar). "Qanday qilib Evropaning miyasini to'kish kerak". TIME. Olingan 2008-06-01.
  114. ^ Stenman, Jim (2006 yil 28-iyun). "Evropa Buyuk Britaniyaga miya qochib ketishidan qo'rqadi". CNN. Olingan 2008-06-01.
  115. ^ "Buyuk Britaniya tomonidan chiqarilgan Sharqiy Evropa immigratsiya statistikasi". Workpermit.com. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  116. ^ "Buyuk Britaniyada Sharqiy Evropa immigratsiyasi sekinlashadi". Workpermit.com. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  117. ^ Stankovich, Mirjana va boshq., 2013 y., "Janubi-Sharqiy Evropada ilm-fan va innovatsion siyosat: miyani to'kish miyani ko'payishi", Texnologik o'rganish, innovatsiya va rivojlanish xalqaro jurnali, 6 (3): 262-282 (2013) SSRN  2162956
  118. ^ Bilefskiy, Dan (2007 yil 24 oktyabr). "Evropa o'zi afzal ko'rgan migrantlarni jalb qilishga intilmoqda". Nyu-York Tayms. Olingan 2008-06-01.
  119. ^ Malakali ishchilar uchun ochiq eshik Arxivlandi 2007 yil 28 oktyabrda Orqaga qaytish mashinasi
  120. ^ "Evropaning olis huquqi". Guardian. London. Olingan 2008-06-01.
  121. ^ "Immigratsiya mavzusi: immigrantlar va ularning farzandlariga oid fanlararo istiqbollar". Kaliforniya raqamli kutubxonasi. 2007 yil 2 mart. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  122. ^ "AQShning doimiy doimiy aholisi: 2006 yil" (PDF). Olingan 2011-02-28.
  123. ^ "Avstraliya aholisiga doimiy qo'shimchalar" (PDF). Olingan 2011-02-28.
  124. ^ Faktlar va raqamlar 2006 yil - Immigratsiya haqida umumiy ma'lumot: Doimiy va vaqtinchalik yashovchilar Arxivlandi 2007 yil 11-dekabr kuni Orqaga qaytish mashinasi
  125. ^ [2][o'lik havola ]
  126. ^ Paterson, Toni (2007 yil 1-iyun). "1940-yillardan beri Germaniyaning miyadagi oqimi eng yuqori darajada". Mustaqil. London. Olingan 2008-06-01.
  127. ^ Xornal de Notitsiya Arxivlandi Portugaliya veb-arxivida 2007 yil 21 sentyabr Arxivlangan nusxasi da Portugaliyaning veb-arxivi (2005 yil 28 oktyabr).
  128. ^ Smit, Devid (2005 yil 15-may). "Shifokorlar g'arbiy yo'nalish bo'yicha Polshadagi miya qochishi". Guardian. London. Olingan 2008-06-01.
  129. ^ Eurostat 2008 yil fevral - Evro hududidagi ishsizlik 7,1% darajasida barqaror Arxivlandi 2008 yil 8 aprel Orqaga qaytish mashinasi
  130. ^ Aleksi Mostrus va Kristin Seib (2008 yil 16-fevral). "Polshaliklar katta migratsiyani tugatganda oqim o'zgaradi". The Times. London. Olingan 2008-06-01.
  131. ^ Buyuk Britaniyalik polyaklar uylariga qaytishdi. Telegraf. 2009 yil 21 fevral.
  132. ^ Xorvat, Vedran: "Miya qurishi. Janubi-Sharqiy Evropada muvaffaqiyatli o'tishga tahdidmi?" (PDF). (58,6 KB)In: Janubi-sharqiy Evropa siyosati, V jild, 1-son, 2004 yil may
  133. ^ Janubi-Sharqiy Evropada Grid bilan miya oqishini to'xtatish Arxivlandi 2009 yil 1 fevral Orqaga qaytish mashinasi - YuNESKO
  134. ^ Pidd, Xelen; Makdonald, Genri; Smit, Xelena; Fillips, Tom; Rourke, Alison (2011 yil 21-dekabr). "Evropaliklar janubga ko'chib ketmoqdalar, chunki qit'a inqirozga yuz tutmoqda". Guardian. London.
  135. ^ Goni, Uki (2011 yil 22-dekabr). "Yosh evropaliklar Argentinaga ish topish uchun kelishmoqda". Guardian. London.
  136. ^ "Arxivlangan nusxa" (PDF). Arxivlandi asl nusxasi (PDF) 2013 yil 6 oktyabrda. Olingan 2013-06-04.CS1 maint: nom sifatida arxivlangan nusxa (havola)
  137. ^ Rojers, Simon (2010 yil 28-iyun). "Buyuk Britaniyaga immigratsiya: vizualizatsiya qilingan asosiy faktlar". Guardian. London.
  138. ^ "Evropa Ittifoqi fuqarolari nima uchun Buyuk Britaniyani tark etishlarini tushuntirishdi. 2017 yil 24-avgust.
  139. ^ www.afrikarecruit.com
  140. ^ Mayk Pflanz (2012 yil 21 oktyabr). "Miyani orqaga qaytarish:" Afrikalik sher "iqtisodiyoti va G'arbning tezkor yo'li". CSMonitor.com. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  141. ^ "Shifokorlar har 1000 kishiga (so'nggi) mamlakatlar bo'yicha". Jahon taraqqiyoti ko'rsatkichlari ma'lumotlar bazasi. Olingan 2011-10-23.
  142. ^ Narx, Styuart (2004 yil 1-noyabr). "Miya oqimini qaytarish". Hammasi Business.com. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  143. ^ Kalyer, Pol; Xeffler, Anke; Pattillo, Ketrin (2004). "Afrikadan chiqish: portfel qarorlari sifatida kapitalga uchish va miyani to'kish". Afrika iqtisodiyotlari jurnali. 13 (Qo'shimcha 2): ii15 – ii54. CiteSeerX  10.1.1.203.2508. doi:10.1093 / jae / ejh042.
  144. ^ "Janubiy Afrikadagi sog'liqni saqlash xodimlari: noto'g'ri tarqatish va miyaning qochib ketishiga qarshi turish" (PDF). Arxivlandi asl nusxasi (PDF) 2011 yil 30 aprelda. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  145. ^ Harun Bhorat; Jan-Batist Meyer; Sesil Mlatsheni (2002). "Rivojlanayotgan mamlakatlardan malakali mehnat migratsiyasi: Janubiy va Janubiy Afrikada o'qish" (PDF). Xalqaro migratsiya hujjatlari. 52. Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  146. ^ Ehman, Emi Jo; Sallivan, Patrik (2001). "Janubiy Afrika Kanadaga tibbiyot mutaxassislarini jalb qilishni to'xtatishni so'raydi" (PDF). Kanada tibbiyot birlashmasi jurnali. 164 (3): 387–388. PMC  80740. PMID  11232142.
  147. ^ Mills, EJ; va boshq. "Afrikaning Sahroi sharqidan ko'chib ketgan shifokorlarining moliyaviy xarajatlari: inson kapitalini tahlil qilish". British Medical Journal. 2011: 343.
  148. ^ Xedli, Nik (2014 yil 14-yanvar). "Miya qochishi teskari bo'lganligi sababli, mutaxassislik SAga qaytadi". Biznes kuni. Olingan 14 yanvar 2014.
  149. ^ Hawley, Caroline (2005 yil 28-iyul). "Miya oqimi Iroqqa yangi yukni keltirib chiqarmoqda". BBC yangiliklari. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  150. ^ Jonathan Stil (2006 yil 24 mart). "Iroq miyasidan qochish". Guardian. London. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  151. ^ Harrison, Frensis (2007 yil 8-yanvar). "Eronning miyasiga qochish uchun katta xarajat". BBC yangiliklari. Olingan 2007-01-08.
  152. ^ "Eron hisoboti: 2004 yil 12 aprel". RadioFreeEurope / RadioLiberty. Olingan 2019-08-23.
  153. ^ "Moliya va taraqqiyot". Moliya va taraqqiyot - ilmiy-tadqiqot ishlari.
  154. ^ "Eron miyaning ko'payishi bilan duch keldi: hisobot". Payvand.com. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  155. ^ "Eronning miyasiga qochish uchun katta xarajat". 2007-01-08. Olingan 2019-08-23.
  156. ^ "BBC farsi - يyrاn - wززrt عlwm: ۲۵۰ hز r mtخصص يrاnى dar dآmrykاy shmاlyy xstnd". BBC yangiliklari. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  157. ^ "Isroilning miya qochishi yomonlashmoqda - Isroil yangiliklari, Ynetnews". Ynetnews.com. 1995 yil 20-iyun. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  158. ^ "Ta'lim organi: Isroil akademiyasining kelajagi noaniq - Israel News, Ynetnews". Ynetnews.com. 1995 yil 20-iyun. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  159. ^ "Hukumat miya qochishiga qarshi kurash dasturini boshladi - Isroil yangiliklari, Ynetnews". Ynetnews.com. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  160. ^ "Miya qochishiga qarshi kurash rejasi tasdiqlandi - Isroil yangiliklari, Ynetnews". Ynetnews.com. 1995 yil 20-iyun. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  161. ^ Ziri, Danielle (2012 yil 15 oktyabr). "Isroil ekspatatlari uyga rekord sonda qaytish | JPost | Isroil yangiliklari". JPost. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  162. ^ "Miyani to'kish Arab dunyosiga qimmatga tushadi | Milliy". Afterational.ae. 2010 yil 28 aprel. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  163. ^ "Yaqin Sharqdagi miyadagi qochqinlik orqaga qaytish alomatlarini ko'rsatmoqda | Arab News - Saudiya Arabistoni yangiliklari, Yaqin Sharq yangiliklari, Fikr, Iqtisodiyot va boshqalar". Arabnews.com. 2012 yil 26-iyul. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  164. ^ Bothina Osama. "Arab bahoridan keyin fanga va'da". SciDev.Net. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  165. ^ https://yonulis.com/2019/10/05/fenomena-brain-drain-hilangnya-otak-negara/
  166. ^ "Malayziya diasporasi 2010 yilda bir millionga etdi - Jahon banki rasmiysi". Bernama. 2011 yil 28 aprel. Olingan 2011-04-28.
  167. ^ "Malayziyaning miyasi". Osiyo Sentinel. 2010 yil 18 fevral. Olingan 2011-04-28.
  168. ^ "Malayziyaning miyadagi qochishi yomonlashmoqda, deydi Jahon banki". Malayziya insayderi. 28 Aprel 2011. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi 2011 yil 1 mayda. Olingan 2011-04-28.
  169. ^ "Ijtimoiy adolatsizlik mamlakatni miyasidan qochib qutulishning asosiy sababi". Malayziya insayderi. 28 Aprel 2011. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi 2011 yil 1 mayda. Olingan 2011-04-28.
  170. ^ Brush, Barbara L. (2010 yil sentyabr). "Mehnatning kuchli ko'taruvchisi: Postkolonial Filippinda hamshiralikni rivojlantirish va eksport qilish". Amerika sog'liqni saqlash jurnali. 100 (9): 1572–1581. doi:10.2105 / ajph.2009.181222. PMC  2920989. PMID  20634458.
  171. ^ a b Cho'tkasi, "Mehnatning kuchli dastasi", 1573.
  172. ^ Cho'tkasi, "Mehnatning kuchli dastasi", 1574 yil.
  173. ^ Fely Merilin Lorenzo, Xayme Galvez-Tan, Kriselle Ikamina, Lara Xavyer, "Hamshiraning migratsiyasi manba mamlakat nuqtai nazaridan: Filippin mamlakati ishi," Sog'liqni saqlash xizmatlari tadqiqotlari 42 (3 qism.2) 2007: 1411
  174. ^ a b Cho'tkasi, "Mehnatning kuchli dastasi", 1575 yil.
  175. ^ Ball, Rochelle E. (2004 yil iyun-iyul). "Turli xil rivojlanish, irqiy huquqlar: globallashgan mehnat bozori va hamshiralar savdosi - Filippin ishi". Ayollar tadqiqotlari xalqaro forumi. 27 (2): 122. doi:10.1016 / j.wsif.2004.06.003.CS1 maint: ref = harv (havola)
  176. ^ Masselink, Liya E .; Daniel Li, Shoou-Yih (2010). "Nurses Inc.: Filippinda hamshiralik ta'limini kengaytirish va tijoratlashtirish". Ijtimoiy fan va tibbiyot. 71 (1): 166–72. doi:10.1016 / j.socscimed.2009.11.043. PMID  20399550.
  177. ^ Joys, Richard E.; Ov, Chester (1982). "Filippinlik hamshiralar va miyani to'kish". Ijtimoiy fan va tibbiyot. 16 (12): 1223–33. doi:10.1016/0277-9536(82)90147-2. PMID  7112166.
  178. ^ Ball, "Turli xil rivojlanish, irqiy huquqlar", 121
  179. ^ Joys va Xant "Filippinlik hamshiralar va miyani to'kish", 1223 yil
  180. ^ Joys va Xant "Filippinlik hamshiralar va miyani to'kish", 1232
  181. ^ a b Joys va Xant "Filippinlik hamshiralar va miyani to'kish", 1229 yil
  182. ^ a b Lorenzo va boshq. "Resurs mamlakat nuqtai nazaridan hamshiralarning migratsiyasi", 1407
  183. ^ "JSST Tinch okeanining g'arbiy mintaqasi: Filippin statistik xulosasi (2002 yildan hozirgacha)". Apps.who.int. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  184. ^ Lorenzo va boshq. "Hamshiralarning migratsiyasi manba mamlakat nuqtai nazaridan", 1412
  185. ^ Masselink va boshq., "Nurses Inc.", 167
  186. ^ Masselink va boshq., "Nurses Inc.", 167-168
  187. ^ Lorenzo va boshq. "Hamshiralarning migratsiyasi manba mamlakat nuqtai nazaridan", 1409
  188. ^ Masselink va boshq., "Nurses Inc.", 168
  189. ^ Barbara L. Brush, "Bugungi kunda global hamshiralarning migratsiyasi", Hamshiralar uchun stipendiya jurnali 40(1) 2008: 22
  190. ^ Masselink va boshq., "Nurses Inc.", 170
  191. ^ a b Masselink va boshq., "Nurses Inc.", 170
  192. ^ Masselink va boshq., "Nurses Inc.", 169
  193. ^ Cho'tkasi, "Mehnatning kuchli dastasi", 1579 y
  194. ^ Cho'tkasi, "Mehnatning kuchli dastasi", 1579 y
  195. ^ Joys va Xant "Filippinlik hamshiralar va miyani to'kish", 1233 yil
  196. ^ Masselink va boshq., "Nurses Inc.", 171
  197. ^ Lorenzo va boshq. "Resurs mamlakat nuqtai nazaridan hamshiralarning migratsiyasi", 1414 yil
  198. ^ Joys va Xant "Filippinlik hamshiralar va miyani to'kish", 1225-26
  199. ^ Joys va Xant "Filippinlik hamshiralar va miyani to'kish", 1226 yil
  200. ^ Xarris, Gardiner (2016 yil 25-may). "Obama, ehtimol Slyly, Vetnamning miyasiga tushkunlikka e'tibor qaratadi". The New York Times. Olingan 29 fevral 2020.
  201. ^ https://www.entitymag.com/vietnamese-talent-brains-choosing-emigrate/
  202. ^ Nepalning miyasidan qochish uchun narxni kim to'laydi? , Himoloy Times
  203. ^ a b v Lam, Villi (2010 yil 5-avgust). "Xitoyning miyadagi drenaji: Elit emigratsiya". Jamestown jamg'armasi. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  204. ^ Watts, Jonathan (2007 yil 2-iyun). "Xitoy miyasidan qochib qutulishdan qo'rqmoqda, chunki chet elda o'qiyotgan talabalar". Guardian. London.
  205. ^ Kollinz, Simon (2005 yil 12 mart). "NZ-ning eng yorqinlari chorak qismi yo'qoldi". Nzherald.co.nz. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  206. ^ "Avstraliyaga immigrantlarning eng yaxshi manbasi". Yangi Zelandiya Herald. 2007 yil 25 sentyabr. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  207. ^ "Milliy saylov kampaniyasining birinchi reklama taxtasini ochdi". 3 yangiliklar NZ. 1 sentyabr 2008. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi 2014-08-09. Olingan 2012-12-05.
  208. ^ "Miya drenaji eng yuqori darajaga ko'tarildi". 3 yangiliklar NZ. 21 Avgust 2012. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi 2014-08-09. Olingan 2012-12-05.
  209. ^ "Miya qochib ketish va'dasining asosiy belgilari". 3 yangiliklar NZ. 23 Noyabr 2011. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi 2014-08-09. Olingan 2012-12-05.
  210. ^ "Chet elda ishlaydigan milliy kivi - mehnat". 3 yangiliklar NZ. 6 dekabr 2012. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi 2013-04-04 da. Olingan 2012-12-05.
  211. ^ "Ozga qaytish: Miya orqaga qaytadimi?". 2017 yil 29 oktyabr.
  212. ^ "Yangi Zelandiyaning rok-yulduz iqtisodiyoti valyuta kursining ko'tarilishi bilan markaziy o'rinni egallaydi". 2015 yil 12 aprel.
  213. ^ Shisha, Xeyden; Choy, Vay Kin (2001 yil dekabr). "Miya qurishi yoki miya almashinuvi?". Yangi Zelandiya G'aznachilikning ishchi hujjati 01/22. Olingan 2011-02-28. Iqtibos jurnali talab qiladi | jurnal = (Yordam bering)
  214. ^ Bu erga ko'chish, shu erda qolish: Kanadalik immigratsion tajriba - "Immigratsiya" Kanada provinsiyasi vazirining 1865 yilgi yillik hisoboti, 10-15 betlar.
  215. ^ "Soliq syurprizi: aksariyat kanadaliklar amerikaliklarga qaraganda kamroq soliq to'laydilar". Canadiansocialresearch.net. 1999 yil 6-noyabr. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  216. ^ a b "Kanadaning" miyani to'kish "suv toshqini emas: yangi statistik ma'lumotlarga ko'ra immigratsiya / emigratsiya bizning miyamizni to'kkanimizdek ko'paytiradi". Straightgoods.com. 7 iyun 2000. Arxivlangan asl nusxasi 2011 yil 10 martda. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  217. ^ a b Duncan Hood (2008 yil 25-iyun). "Kanada kunidagi maxsus hisobot: Kanada qanday qilib Amerika orzusini o'g'irladi". Macleans.ca. Arxivlandi asl nusxasi 2011 yil 25 fevralda. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  218. ^ a b Kalgari-Edmonton yo'lagi "AQSh uslubidagi boylik, Kanadalik hayot sifati" Arxivlandi 2004 yil 23 iyul Orqaga qaytish mashinasi - TD Iqtisodiyot bo'yicha maxsus hisobot, 2003 yil aprel
  219. ^ Milliy pochta
  220. ^ Calamai, Peter (2008 yil 12-yanvar). "Miya qurishi? Mana shunday to'qsoninchi yillar". Yulduz. Toronto. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  221. ^ "Kanadaning 200 million dollarlik jozibasi 19 taniqli tadqiqotchilarni jalb qilmoqda" - Globe and Mail | Milliy, 2010 yil may
  222. ^ Jeff Kolgan, Xalqaro savdoning va'dasi va xavfi, (2005) pp 141ff.
  223. ^ Ta'lim olgan yosh, yolg'iz va kollej migratsiyasi - AQSh aholini ro'yxatga olish byurosi, 2003 yil noyabr
  224. ^ Vazzana, Rudi-Polloshka, Caryn, Jeta (2019 yil 7-may). "Appalachia iste'dodga ega, ammo nega u uzoqqa oqadi? AQShning qishloq joylaridan miyani chiqarishni aniqlovchi moddalar to'g'risida tadqiqot". Iqtisodiy rivojlanish har chorakda. 33 (3): 220–233. doi:10.1177/0891242419844320. S2CID  164404424.
  225. ^ Shvarts, Jefri. "Appalachi oliy ta'lim tarmog'ining rivojlanishi va taraqqiyoti". www.arc.gov. Appalachi mintaqaviy komissiyasi. Olingan 27 iyun, 2020.
  226. ^ Dattel, Lior (2013 yil 15-aprel). "Nima uchun Isroilning miyasi susayib qoldi - Xotira va Mustaqillik 2013 Isroil yangiliklari". Haaretz. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  227. ^ Xalqaro migratsiya tashkiloti (2008). "Jahon migratsiyasi to'g'risidagi hisobot 2008 yil. Rivojlanayotgan global iqtisodiyotda ishchi kuchini boshqarish" (PDF). Arxivlandi asl nusxasi (PDF) 2016-04-04 da. Olingan 2013-08-09.
  228. ^ Pagliery, Jose (31 yanvar 2013). "Amerikadagi immigrant talabalarning miya qochishi muammosi - 2013 yil 31-yanvar". Money.cnn.com. Olingan 2013-12-18.
  229. ^ a b "Kubalik shifokorlar AQShning javobini kutishmoqda". Washington Post. 2007 yil 2-fevral. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  230. ^ Forero, Xuan (2007 yil 25-fevral). "Kubalik shifokorlar Venesuela postlaridan qochishdi". Vashington Post. Olingan 2011-02-28 - San-Fransisko xronikasi orqali.
  231. ^ Li, Brianna (2014 yil 17-noyabr). "Kubalik shifokorlar AQShning shartli ozod qilish dasturi yordamida Venesueladan qochmoqdalar". International Business Times. Olingan 18 noyabr 2014.
  232. ^ a b Olivares, Fransisko (2014 yil 13 sentyabr). "Eksport uchun eng yaxshi va yorqin". El Universal. Olingan 24 sentyabr 2014.
  233. ^ a b "Ugo Chaves iste'dodni qo'rqitmoqda". Newsweek. 2009 yil 30-iyun. Olingan 24 sentyabr 2014.
  234. ^ a b v d e Mariya Delgado, Antonio (2014 yil 28-avgust). "Venesuela agobiada por la fuga masiva de cerebros". El Nuevo Herald (ispan tilida). Arxivlandi asl nusxasi 2014 yil 28 avgustda. Olingan 28 avgust 2014.
  235. ^ Symmes Cobb, Julia; Garsiya Ravlinz, Karlos (2014 yil 15 oktyabr). "Iqtisodiy inqiroz, siyosiy mojarolar Venesuelani aqldan ozdirishga majbur qilmoqda". Reuters. Olingan 15 oktyabr 2014.
  236. ^ Gonsales, Anxel; Minaya, Ezequiel (2011 yil 17 oktyabr). "Venesuela diasporasi Chaves davrida kuchaymoqda". The Wall Street Journal. Arxivlandi asl nusxasi 2015-10-17 kunlari. Olingan 8 oktyabr 2014.
  237. ^ a b "El 90% los venezolanos for universal universitaria for theienen formación". El Impulso. 2014 yil 23-avgust. Olingan 28 avgust 2014.
  238. ^ Viveros, Alejandra; Jekson, Stevan (2006 yil 31 oktyabr). "Lotin Amerikasi pul o'tkazmalariga hamma narsani tikmasligi kerak" (Matbuot xabari). Jahon banki. Olingan 2011-02-28.
  239. ^ "Tadqiqot natijalariga ko'ra kichik rivojlanayotgan erlar" miya oqishi "bilan eng ko'p zarar ko'rmoqda", Dugger, Celia, The New York Times, 2005 yil 25 oktyabr
  240. ^ "Miya qurishi yoki eksportdan tushadigan daromadmi?". BBC yangiliklari. 2007 yil 23-iyul. Olingan 2011-02-28.